Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

mini van vs third row SUV

who's talking here?

billiejean Doop 1
The Original LM 6
Monkey Manners 1
jb24 2
Fulu McVooDoo 3
newbernbears 2
Boobsy McNicehiney 2
GardenWitch 2
Champ 2
a4344896uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

The Original LM --- 13 years ago -

What do you have? What do you hate about it? What do you love about it? Recommendations??

Apparently I need to look into a new vehicle. 3 in car seats won't fit in my crew cab S-10 :( 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It depends on your family and needs. I have an suv with 3rd row seating because I have 4 kids and 2 dogs and we travel a lot. I need room for everyone. It's tight, but we fit. My sister has a van and 3 kids that she loves but zero pets, so she doesn't need as much hatch space that I have. That is why I drive an suv. ;-) HTH 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

And by two dogs, I mean 2 adult golden retrievers. 

The Original LM --- 13 years ago -

I have a dog and two ferrets. The ferrets don't travel with us unless we'll be gone longer than two days, but they do go occasionally. Gambit is like the fattest dog ever, he takes up a full seat. He loves car rides. I need cargo space. I'm tired of having to put my groceries in the truck bed or my truck box to get them home. DH has a 2012 Ford Fiesta because he drives 100 miles a day to get to school and work and it gets 40 mpg. He graduates in May and baby is due in June, so we may trade in his car then and he'll take my truck. That thing won't fit the kids for sure!!

What kind of SUV do you have? I'm in Missouri, no stalking, I promise. ;) 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Ha ha no worries. I have an '08 Explorer with 3rd row seating. It has the option to use one extra seat at a time or both. I only use one, so the dogs lay on the other since it isn't lifted into position but still part of the hatch floor. If that makes and sense. Then I'll stuff suitcases behind the seats and travel bags where the kids in the middle put their feet. You can also shop around at dealerships and look at both to better gauge what would be the best fit. I'll also add that I'm an suv girl for towing purposes. My truck came with a tow package on the body, not the bumper. We haul my boat with it, and we also have an 8ft trailer to haul home improvement supplies and all sorts of things. An suv just made sense for us, kwim. However, I'm sure a van may get better gas mileage and be more travel friendly if it's just mostly you guys and the kids. Considering the litter of kids, our recreational needs and the fact that my overneedy dogs come everywhere with us...well you get my point ;-) 

The Original LM --- 13 years ago -

I'm not quite ready for a van, but DH thinks I need to suck it up and get one. I have a 16ft car trailer I haul occasionally with 4 wheelers on it. 

Boobsy McNicehiney (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

My SUV with a 3rd row is TERRIBLE on gas. I do like having it though because like Fulu said, you still have hatch space. 

newbernbears --- 13 years ago -

Have had a Grand Caravan since 2003. Has been great;dependable, okay on gas, about 22 mpg. Grand Caravan gives you more space than Caravan behind rear seat. You will look cooler in an SUV. 

The Original LM --- 13 years ago -

I don't care about me looking cool, there's about a zero chance of me ever looking cool to anyone no matter what I drive. :) 

a4344896uu --- 13 years ago -

SUV really only makes sense if you need to travel dirt roads or pull a trailer. 

jb24 --- 13 years ago -

I have a third row chevy trailblazer, love it, it has the option to only fold one half of the seat down in both the second and third rows, I just told my husband though i'm interested in a van!! We only have one kid, one dog!! However Ilike the big, tahos and such, if i was rich that would be my next move, our trailblazer is paid off though so it'll be that for a long time! 

GardenWitch --- 13 years ago -

I had a Yukon XL, same thing as a Suburban. 4 years after trading it in, I STILL miss that thing but I don't need that kind of room now. Gas was alright @20 mpg. Traveling was a snap with room for everything. The kids played sports so we were always on the road plus we have toys to tow.

New ones are too pricey, but if you can find a used one with low miles, or a Tahoe/Yukon they are a great deal.(mine was 2 years old with 22,000 milezt and we drove it for another 150,000 miles)

I refuse to even look at minivans. I have never owned anything but SUV's or trucks. 

newbernbears --- 13 years ago -

there's about a zero chance of me ever looking cool to anyone no matter what I drive. :) 

:) 

The Original LM --- 13 years ago -

The book on my truck says it gets 18mpg. The effed up injectors beg to differ. Now that we live in town, I'm not driving as far so gas doesn't matter that much. I live two miles from anywhere I need to be.
I do need cargo space, room for 3 car seats, a comfortable ride, and to be able to pull a trailer occasionally. I'm going to have to convince DH to get rid of his truck, the spare vehicle, so this one will need to be able to tow in it's place. He did ask me to keep an open mind though which is why I asked about vans too. 

Champ --- 12 years ago -

We went from a Laramie longhorn ram to a Honda odyssey. Quite a change!!!! But!

All the middle row seats can be removed individually, so it can be configured a variety of ways, also the seats expand, so we have all three of our car seats in the middle row. Little guy rear faces behind the driver in a britax marathon, oldest (8)in the middle (now in a highback booster, but previously a frontier 85(so super wide) and our middle (3) in radian. Absolutely no issue fitting any car seat configuration. These seats also go forward and back for leg room.

The back row has 3 seats that fold completely flat (or you can fold one or two of the seats down) we fold both down for cargo space, but even with the seats up the cargo space isn't bad because its deep, so you can stack and fit a lot. When I grocery shop I usually flip one of the seats up, so I can put the groceries in the cargo area and they won't slope around.

Since we fit the three kids across trips are not an issue we usually have a dog kennel, 4 bags/suitcases, blankets, pillows, double stroller, and pack and play, portable highchair, ride on toy, and room for presents if we are celebration g a birthday on the trip. The kids never have anything crammed aground them except a cooler. 

billiejean Doop --- 12 years ago -

We finally bit the bullet and got a Suburban. We needed the 8th seat because of our new little one that arrived in August, but even with ALL the kids it still has great cargo room. I LOVE it. It gets about 15-17 mpg. but to me it's well worth it to have plenty of space. There really isn't anything I dislike about it. I would love to have a minivan, but again I would have to compromise on space, and with six kids that's not something I'm willing to do personally.

If you don't have the need for that much, I'd try a Tahoe. 

The Original LM --- 12 years ago -

Congrats on the new baby, Doop!!! 

Boobsy McNicehiney (Mod) --- 12 years ago -

A new doop!!!!!! Congrats!!!! 

Monkey Manners --- 12 years ago -

Definitely mini van
Usually 3rd row seat SUV's have very limited access to the back, don't give much leg room in 3rd row,
It would be very difficult to get back there and have room for a car seat.
I've had a Chevrolet Venture, Dodge Caravan and a Toyoa Sienna at this point. I didn't care much for the dodge but it was a short wheel base and had minimal additions.
I've also had a dodge Durango w 3rd row seating and my dad has a Toyota Highlander 3rd row seat. The Durango had way more room than the Toyota but still it's not easily accessible for you to get to small children. 

GardenWitch --- 12 years ago -

The Durangos are more crossover style now and much smaller/narrower than a Tahoe. My SIL had one with two car seats and she ditched it after their first road trip. They have a Suburban now with 2 kids in carseats and two kids who aren't. We are trading the truck in soon, so we have been prowling the car lots after hours(I hate car salesmen) It's now a toss-up between a regular length Tahoe/Yukon or a Jeep Grand Cherokee with the eco diesel that gets 30 mpg! They both come with a third row seat that I don't need but I'll just leave it flat for the cargo space instead ;-) 

jb24 --- 12 years ago -

I think it depends on the third row suv, some explorers have third rows...well nothing more than a toddler could ride back there, I have a Trailblazer with a third row and have had lots of adults back there comfortably along with carseats! the smaller/crossover type that have 3rd rows yea pretty useless...however with my 3rd row seats up the the storage space in the back is not very deep, I can still do grocery's and such but nothing big, a suitcase on its side would fit but not flat.. 

Champ --- 12 years ago -

I watched two kidlets this morning, so I had a total of 5 kids/ 5 car seats in my odyssey, and it worked well...

First trip I kept my three babes in the 2nd row, and put the 2 kids I was watching in the third row (one in a high back booster, one in a forward facing evenflo.

Later on I ended up taking out the center seat in the 2nd row, and putting the two highback boosters in the back, with the forward facing evenflo... Here is the awesome kicker... From standing on the outside of the van I could with no issue reach the kid in the 5 point harness in the back and unbuckle her! I was in complete shock, and made me like my van a little bit more! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

recommendations

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground