Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Morality question

who's talking here?

dmc21 2
Monkey Manners 1
Fulu McVooDoo 2
sweetcheeks 1
Boobsy McNicehiney 1
GardenWitch 1
shizzlemydizzle 2
a3417938uu 2
SHomemaker 1
RMof2 1
LooNicey 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

a3417938uu --- 13 years ago -

Just a question about something that is bugging me. I am going to keep it sort of vague.

Could you make a HUGE promise to a family member and then break the promise and die with a clear conscience?

There are no circumstances that would keep you from keeping the promise, you just decide not to do it. 

sweetcheeks --- 13 years ago -

What was the promise? 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

It depends on the promise. But for everyday morality, if you make a promise, you should stick to it. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 13 years ago -

Sounds like someone got cut out of the will... 

GardenWitch --- 13 years ago -

Yep, especially if it was anything to do with the in-laws! 

a3417938uu --- 13 years ago -

I guess I should have included a few more details.

Man #1 helped Man #2(his grandfather) restore a car. Man #1 put time and quite a bit of money into this as his grandfather promised to leave it to him when he died if he didn't give it to him before. Man #1 took his word and sunk quite a good sum of money into this car. Not to mention time and energy.

Now the grandfather has decided to give the car to someone else. He is leaving Man #1 more money than the car is worth or valued at when he dies but that wasn't the promise. And that isn't what he wants.

The promise was the car and it has sentimental value as well as the cash value to Man #1. The person getting the car never has touched it and has said he will put it in a garage and leave it to his kid if he wants it.

Neither of those other people have ever shown any interest in it. Man #1 spent lots of time and energy on it when he could have done one for himself. But it was his grandfather and he thought they were doing something special. The sentimental value alone should mean something - in my opinion.

But for everyday morality, if you make a promise, you should stick to it.

I agree with this. No matter how small or large a promise is, if you made it, you should keep it. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

has he talked to his grandfather and told him how much it bothers him?

Has he spoken to the one being left the car to see if they can 'strike a deal'?


My husband helped my father restore his truck. He told my husband that he'd give him the title, and it would be his. This was in the mid 90s. My dad kept the truck, and has run it into the ground. It sits at his house, four flat tires, unable to start. My husband laughs about it. 

LooNicey --- 13 years ago -

Puke.


Ironically enough my husbands grandpop passed last night. Reading about some douche caring about the "sentimental" value of a foooking object when he still has time and life with his grandfather is wretched. Its obvious that someone values a car and money more than a grand family relationship.

SHAME ON YOU IF YOURE MAN #1 AND BIGGER SHAME SHAME SHAAAAAAAAME IF YOURE THE WIFE OF MAN #1ยก!!!! 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

awww Loo, I'm sorry for your (husband's) loss. :(

It always hurts me when it seems people don't appreciate they still have grandparents. My dad's dad died in 1994. Mom's mom in 1980 and her dad died when she was only 16 and the oldest of 5 kids. :(

I did have a crazy grandma (dad's mom) until the late 90s, I do believe, but I don't ever remember meeting her. I talked to her on the phone a few times, she was a loon. ha ha

but yeah, I don't remember any of them much. :( I'm jealous. 

shizzlemydizzle --- 13 years ago -

And bingo was his name Oh!

Loo,

So sorry for your family's loss. 

Fulu McVooDoo (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I'm sorry for your loss Loo. :-(

But I still think it's stank to back out on a promise like that. That car probably does hold sentimental value. And it's a slap in the face to give it to someone else who has no attachment or even memories of working with gramps on it. I'd be hurt more than anything, regardless of the monetary value. 

Boobsy McNicehiney (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I'm sorry Loo :(

As for the OP, if he hasn't told the grandfather how he feels he can't really expect much, can he? Grandpa probably thinks he is doing something nice by leaving him more money than the car is worth...

Enjoy Grandpa, you don't know how much time he has left. Don't be vultures circling him waiting for him to croak. 

LooNicey --- 13 years ago -

Thanks guys.

Hes been in poor health for a long time but its still sad. Its even harder because me and the kids are down here and j is up there:( He wants me to deal with the movers instead of going to the funeral. 

SHomemaker --- 13 years ago -

has he talked to his grandfather and told him how much it bothers him? Has he spoken to the one being left the car to see if they can 'strike a deal'?

^^that

Otherwise, I'd let it go. Family is more important than stuff. I get sentimental value, but it's the grandparent's decision. It sucks, but what can you do? 

Monkey Manners --- 13 years ago -

what Loo and DMC said

I'd give anything to have just one more day with mine. 

RMof2 --- 13 years ago -

I agree with MM. Both My Grandpa and Grandma died this month (within 18 days of each other) and I am probably not getting anything of theirs (they had 12 kids, 40 grandchildren, 20 great grandchild and 4 great great grandchildren) and the furthest thing from my mind is "did they leave something to me". Sure I would like to be able to go through some of the pictures and have the ones that are from our trips together but other than that, I have the books that my Grandmother got me for presents that have her handwriting in them and that is enough for me. I would love to have them back (and healthy) for just one more day, for one more adventure if I could have that but since I can't, I will treasure the good memories and be thankful that they are no longer in pain. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground