Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What do you think?

who's talking here?

dmc... 2
ces1 1
Mermaid 1
Susie Homemaker 6
ncnative 1
QuickBlubbersMcGee 6
MrsBeeLee 1
CivilianWife 2
Maureenie 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

ncnative --- 16 years ago -

The courts in this country have decided that fetuses don't have rights. Until and unless that changes, there's no way to charge someone with murder for killing them. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

He should have been charged with manslaughter or even involuntary manslaughter. His actions caused the death of the babies.

I for one don't think that people should be charged with murder unless the fetus was at the point that it could live on it's own. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

Ah, but both babies lived for several minutes. They were not fetuses.

Exactly. It's nice to see that someone knows the definition of fetus on here. :)

There were also laws put in place after the murder of Lacy Peterson that allowed someone to be charged with murdering the baby the woman is carrying.

He should be charged with the babies' deaths, as manslaughter. Had he not shot the gun and wounded the mother, those babies would not have been delivered as early as they were.

I agree with QS, that no one should be charged with the death of a baby unless it is old enough, usually 24 weeks, to survive outside the womb. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

He should be charged with the babies' deaths, as manslaughter.

that no one should be charged with the death of a baby unless it is old enough, usually 24 weeks, to survive outside the womb.

I'm confused. She was only 19 weeks pregnant, so by your definition, they weren't babies. As I read the article, they actually didn't 'live' outside the womb, they were kept alive. Their lungs weren't developed, therefore never breathed on their own.

I think he should be charged, with something, regardless. She more than likely wouldn't have delivered so early had he not shot her. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

I'm confused. She was only 19 weeks pregnant, so by your definition, they weren't babies. As I read the article, they actually didn't 'live' outside the womb, they were kept alive. Their lungs weren't developed, therefore never breathed on their own.


I think in this case, since he caused the babies to be born prematurely, he should be charged with manslaughter. Generally, I do think that you shouldn't be charged if the babies are too young to live on their own, unless your action caused them to be born prematurely. I'm sure that's confusing. LOL. 

CivilianWife --- 16 years ago -

I think in this case, since he caused the babies to be born prematurely, he should be charged with manslaughter. Generally, I do think that you shouldn't be charged if the babies are too young to live on their own, unless your action caused them to be born prematurely. I'm sure that's confusing. LOL.

Actually that makes perfect sense to me. She wouldn't have delivered them @ 19 weeks if he hadn't shot her. Therefore they would not have died to due their inability to live outside the womb. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

Actually that makes perfect sense to me. She wouldn't have delivered them @ 19 weeks if he hadn't shot her. Therefore they would not have died to due their inability to live outside the womb.

Exactly! BUT, this is such a slippery slope. There is no guarantee with pregnancy, especially multiples. So the defense would just argue that there is no proof those babies would have been born viable. It's a tough thing, that's why the laws are as they are. 

CivilianWife --- 16 years ago -

this is such a slippery slope

ITA. This whole case is going to cause a lot of controversy over the laws reguarding fetus deaths, etc. Maybe some new laws will come out of this or maybe we'll all get sick of hearing about it on the news everyday. Only time shall tell... :) 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

There is no guarantee with pregnancy, especially multiples. So the defense would just argue that there is no proof those babies would have been born viable.

Yep.
I would think as long as her doctor could present proof that her pregnancy was healthy and uneventful, he could be charged. Those circumstances would cut down her chances of delivering early, at least. 

ces1 --- 16 years ago -

NC is one of the few states that doesn't have the law that if you kill the Mother and she is pregnant and the baby(s) die that the shooter can be charged with the deaths of MOther and baby. 

Mermaid --- 16 years ago -

agree with QS, that no one should be charged with the death of a baby unless it is old enough, usually 24 weeks, to survive outside the womb.


I on the fence with it. I think if it is as a result of a crime & the baby/fetus the mom was carrying was wanted (meaning she wasn't going to get an abortion/within time frame to have an abortion) that the criminal should be charged with murder or 1st degree manslaughter. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

These were not fetuses.

Medical experts testified that the twins were 19 weeks, 4 to 5 days old and were not able to survive outside their mother’s womb. Both twins had heartbeats, but their lungs were not sufficiently developed to enable them to breathe,

They couldn't live outside the womb. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

Was she not 19 weeks?

no

The pregnancy was dangerous for both mother and child. Michelle Duggar suffered from preeclampsia and gave birth to Josie at only 25 weeks. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

The pregnancy was dangerous for both mother and child. Michelle Duggar suffered from preeclampsia and gave birth to Josie at only 25 weeks.

Yep. Josie was teeny tiny, too. I can only imagine how small those 19 wk old twins were.

Pre-eclampsia is bad. The only option is to get the baby out. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

*They* couldn't. Look at that Duggar baby. Was she not 19 weeks?

They didn't therefore they couldn't. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

I miscarried at 15 weeks and the fetus was about the size of the palm of my hand. It looked like a real baby. It was pretty tramatic because they do look so human like. Obviously different because they have a little tail and the fingers and toes aren't completely formed but you can definitely see a baby. I can't imagine a 19 week baby being much bigger. You can google pictures of baby inside the womb (not so upsetting) to see how big they would be. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

I miscarried at 15 weeks and the fetus was about the size of the palm of my hand.

My sister miscarried a little earlier than that. She put it in a ziplock bag in the bathroom closet for a couple days. I think she went a little "wooohoooo" for a few days there. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

My sister miscarried a little earlier than that. She put it in a ziplock bag in the bathroom closet for a couple days. I think she went a little "wooohoooo" for a few days there.

Oh, your poor sister. :(

I miscarried at 15 weeks and the fetus was about the size of the palm of my hand.

I'm sorry M. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

Oh, your poor sister. :(

Thankfully we are cut from the same cloth so we made jokes and laughed. I would call her and ask if she "cleaned out the closet" yet. And we would laugh about how she was going to get arrested for mistreatment of remains and improper disposal of remains. We're odd like that, we always have joked and laughed in the weirdest times! 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -


Thankfully we are cut from the same cloth so we made jokes and laughed. I would call her and ask if she "cleaned out the closet" yet. And we would laugh about how she was going to get arrested for mistreatment of remains and improper disposal of remains. We're odd like that, we always have joked and laughed in the weirdest times!


That's how my dad's family is. That's good that she could get support from you though. :) 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

Its good to joke. I don't want to sound morbid but I didn't know what to do with "it" either. I mean I didn't want to just flush it but burrying it in the yard just didn't seem right either.

For me though, looking back and even a couple days later I realized it wasn't that bad. I was going through a religious phase and I had actually prayed a few days before that if he wasn't the man I was supposed to be with, don't let me have it. I already had Maley as a single mom and didn't want to go through that with another one especially since he ended up in jail and was hiding a marriage and 4 kids from me. Well, I didnt. I also didn't get pregnant again until Cadence even though I wasn't preventing it. So I guess that's why I was okay and kinda my God story all in one. Also why I feel very strongly about making things work with Michael, which they are. 

MrsBeeLee --- 16 years ago -

Its good to joke. I don't want to sound morbid but I didn't know what to do with "it" either. I mean I didn't want to just flush it but burrying it in the yard just didn't seem right either.

thankfully I was in the hospital.. I couldn't have the baby 16 wks(miscarriage) on my own.. I dont know what Id do if i had to think about what to do with the baby 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

I had my sister with me. I was 19 and my mother had just told my dad that morning. He was angry and I called my mom (a nurse) and told her. She had to call my dad before he freaked out on me. He wanted to take me to dinner but I said no so he bought me flowers.

My douche of a boyfriend though... I went and visted him that afternoon, in jail, (he was arrested about 5 weeks before I miscarried) and told him. He blamed me for it because I was working on my exes car. I replaced a serpantine belt its not like I rebuilt the transmission I highly doubt that's why. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground