Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Did you Circumsize or not circumsize your child?

who's talking here?

Someone 8
*~LittleMissPerfect~* 1
ces1 3
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 35
dbal 1
BlueEyes 6
Cancer Sucks!!! 1
Kappy 1
The Original LM 14
~Bea~ 7
Bellagirl 1
Muse 1
Amel!A 1
Jingle Bell Rockin 2
Erin Marie 3
Susie Homemaker 12
Tiki, Tikcuf, dirty old perv! 4
ncnative 7
Cinde-freakin-rella 1
Boobsy McNiceass 6
QuickBlubbersMcGee 42
*M36@N* 2
Dominican Mom 1
Afrina Watkins 10
TaterFRIGGNsalad 3
Here 4 the moment 4
littleduck90 1
Krystal in NC 9
HELP BUTTON 7
binkadoodle 2
nicole 26
*~Rebel Princess~* 20
Maureenie 1
*loved* 1
meggles 1
Vespertina 2
HiImKia 3
Shutter Bug 5
PinkIce. 1
Kadie's Mommy 1
chatty cathy 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

POLL: Did you Circumsize or not circumsize your child?

Not trying to turn this into a debate, but I read circumcisions are now 50/50 in the united states, and there is no medical association that supports routine infant circumcisions.

Yes. Vote
 
 70.0% (35)
Yes, but I wouldn't do it again. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
No. Vote
 
 16.0% (8)
No, but I would if I had a boy. Vote
 
 8.0% (4)
I'd let my husband decide. Vote
 
 6.0% (3)
nicole --- 16 years ago -

Not trying to turn this into a debate, but I read circumcisions are now 50/50 in the united states, and there is no medical association that supports routine infant circumcisions. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

but I read circumcisions are now 50/50 in the united states, and there is no medical association that supports routine infant circumcisions.

Unsnipped ones just look eeeewwww and creepy! lol 

Kadie's Mommy --- 16 years ago -

and there is no medical association that supports routine infant circumcisions.

That's in the assumption that they have good hygiene. In corps school they taught that there was increased risk of infection in uncircumcised males who lacked personal hygiene.

I'm having a boy and there was no question- He will be cut! 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

Is it wrong to assume someone will have good hygeine? 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

In corps school they taught that there was increased risk of infection in uncircumcised males who lacked personal hygiene.


It's also said that males that aren't cut have a higher risk of HIV because the in out can give unsnipped ones little tears. 

ncnative --- 16 years ago -

No, they can make that decision for themselves when they grow up. 

Vespertina --- 16 years ago -

Nope. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

Is it wrong to assume someone will have good hygeine?

When talking about a boy, yes! lol 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

I just don't know if I find either of those valid reasons to get circumsized. I'm on the fence, but in my opinion if my son is sleeping with someone that is HIV+ wether cut or uncut he's increasing his risk. It's not like he has an increased risk just by having intercourse. Assuming he is raised properly, I'm hoping he's not running around sleeping with anything that moves and picking potential marriage canidates from back alleys or strip clubs. (and if he is... I think he has more problems then being snipped or unsnipped.) 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

Assuming he is raised properly, I'm hoping he's not running around sleeping with anything that moves

Please pay mind to the bolded word. lol

picking potential marriage canidates from back alleys or strip clubs.

First of all, all strippers or even alley dwellers don't have HIV. Secondly, everyone that does have HIV isn't a whore, hooker or stripper. 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

Okay I'm being stereotypical, but yet so are your responses. You assume because it is a male he won't clean himself properly.

and I like to assume my son wether circ or not will take good care of his penis. I also like to assume he will use condoms to prevent STDs, not his lack of foreskin. 

littleduck90 --- 16 years ago -

Secondly, everyone that does have HIV isn't a whore, hooker or stripper.

No kidding. I hate that mentality. You can be born with it. You could have been infected by blood when trying to help someone, etc. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

Okay I'm being stereotypical, but yet so are your responses. You assume because it is a male he won't clean himself properly.


No, I know from experience that young boys aren't very thorough when it comes to cleaning themselves.

Is this your first child? 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

No kidding. I hate that mentality. You can be born with it. You could have been infected by blood when trying to help someone, etc.

Or you could have been infected during intercourse, still doesn't automatically make you a whore. 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

No, it's not my first child. I'm hoping for a second girl to avoid this choice all together.

However; all medical benefits have been proven null, and it's been said the only reason people still do it is for social reasons or religious. 

~Bea~ --- 16 years ago -

We had it done right before he turned 2 in December. they didn't do it in the NICU, at Fort Sam when he was 3 mths, Jacksonville because the doc said to wait until he was two because of the anesthesia. Sooooo once we moved down here, we had it done. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 16 years ago -

However; all medical benefits have been proven null, and it's been said the only reason people still do it is for social reasons or religious.
So don't do it. You have a poll and people are answering it. I don't see the point in repeating the lack of benefit (and no, it's not proven to be useless and only for social reasons).


We had it done right before he turned 2 in December. they didn't do it in the NICU, at Fort Sam when he was 3 mths, Jacksonville because the doc said to wait until he was two because of the anesthesia. Sooooo once we moved down here, we had it done.

That must have been tough :( 

HiImKia --- 16 years ago -

We had it done right before he turned 2 in December. they didn't do it in the NICU, at Fort Sam when he was 3 mths, Jacksonville because the doc said to wait until he was two because of the anesthesia. Sooooo once we moved down here, we had it done.
:( Poor guy! I agree with QS, that must have been pretty tough. 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

Really Quick? Maybe you havn't read up on circumcisions recently, because I have been and not just on the opposing side because I wanted to make an educated choice on it.

I'm not looking for a debate, I was just curious because as I was trying to validate the reason to circumsize I found more reasons not too. I was simply curious of others choices which is why I made the poll. I wasn't curious of their reasons behind their choice(I have no problem reading researching for myself). Just their choice, but if people are going to list reasons why to do it why not list reasons not too, or conflicting views on their opinion?
--------------

and what people "feel" they are doing for medical reasons does not necessarily mean their are the benefits there. I could post numerous links I have came across from the AAP and other organizations disputing the validation for medical benefits. 

~Bea~ --- 16 years ago -

He did really well. The say we got home, he was playing with his cars. He was good about a week later. He just hated When it was time to apply ointment, even though the doc told me to heat the tube of Neosporin in a cup of warm water so the ointment would pour out onto his wee wee so we didn't have to touch it. Once he was able to sit in a bath again, he looked down and said "ball ball" LOL
For me, the hardest part was watching him come out of anesthesia AND the first day we sat him in bath water. The doc had said we could. OMG fiasco! I called and the nurse said next time just let the water run down his body. 

~Bea~ --- 16 years ago -

Nicole and I'm sure I could find just as many sites disputing websites that are against it.
When we took my son in the Urologist gave me all the reasons to do it and he said "the final reason is because the parents want it done and that's a viable reason" 

Shutter Bug --- 16 years ago -

Nicole make your OWN decision, don't base it off of others. Looks like you've already done your research. 

Vespertina --- 16 years ago -

Nicole, there's no point in continuing this. Yes, the data is clear (no, the recent report that surfaced several months ago is not sound research), but it's not going to change anyone's mind, especially those raised in areas where circumcision is common.

I've engaged in countless circ/no circ debates over the years. It's a joyless merry-go-round. I realize you didn't intend for this to be a debate, but the very nature of it makes for a very heated one.

You can always visit MDC if you want to look over the arguments and data/research. 

nicole --- 16 years ago -

If it ends up a boy 80% chance he will be circumsized because that's what my husband wants (and I like to think that's in his realm) but Before I completely pass the decision onto him I want to do as much research as possible so I can inform my husband because I think he will do it purely based on social reasons and assume because it was done to him it was the right chouice and it should be done to his son. 

~Bea~ --- 16 years ago -

No one is even debating. =/ 

~Bea~ --- 16 years ago -

Nicole, if you all decide to do it, it's best when he's newborn. I wish they had done my son when he was still younger. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

I don't have a boy but if I did he would not be circumcised.
IMO that decision should be left up to the boy.
I'll go a step farther and ask why is circing boys ok but against the law in the US to circ a girl? 

*M36@N* --- 16 years ago -

My son had his circumcion done when he was 2. He could not have it done when he was a newborn because he had surgery as soon as he was born.
It was much painful for him to have it done when he was two and much more difficult on us because it was an actual surgery.
I would recommend having it done when the child is born if possible because it is much less traumatic. 

*M36@N* --- 16 years ago -

against the law in the US to circ a girl?

What!? I did not know girls can be circumsized??lol. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

Most insurance will no longer pay for circumcising so that is something to keep in mind. 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground