link title
HOPE HODGE
Marines and sailors stationed at Camp Lejeune may not realize how favorably their take-home pay compares to their civilian counterparts, officials with Jacksonvilles Employment Security Commission say.
A Government Accountability Office study mandated by the 2010 National Defense Authorization act and released in April found that the majority of service members across the country are out-earning civilians with comparable skills and experience.
In 2006, regular military compensation for enlisted personnel averaged $4,700 more annually than compensation for civilians included in the study, an introductory letter reads. Similarly, military officers received an average of about $11,500 more annually than civilians included in the study.
In the Jacksonville metropolitan region, the comparison holds true.
According to Maj. Nat Fahy, a spokesman for Marine Corps Installations East, the top 10 most common military occupational specialties for troops aboard Camp Lejeune are rifleman, motor vehicle operator, field radio operator, mortarman, automotive maintenance technician, machine gunner, combat engineer, field artillery cannoneer, supply administrator and warehouse clerk.
While no direct civilian job comparison exists for infantry MOSs such as rifleman and machine gunner, a heavy truck driver in the Jacksonville metropolitan area can expect to earn an average of $14.30 per hour; automotive service technicians and mechanics bring in $19.39 on average; shipping, receiving, and traffic clerks clear $13.75; and stock clerks make $9.87, according to data from the North Carolina ESC.
A Marine corporal with four years of service and one dependent makes $20.60 per hour, including basic allowances for housing and subsistence; $7.91 of that sum is tax-free.
Even if a service member lives in base barracks and takes his meals at the chow hall, ESC veteran supervisor Larry Woods said, those benefits still should be seen as part of earnings.
In the civilian world, we call that benefits-in-kind, he said. We do need to assign a value to that in the civilian world, because benefits-in-kind are taxable.
Of course, there are many aspects of military life, such as hazardous duty, difficult hours and long absences, that most civilian jobs do not entail. But when troops leave the service, Woods said, they should expect a decrease in earnings, too.
I dont know any 22-year-old thats going to come and make $20 to $25 an hour, he said.
Woods and ESC director Ralph Leeds hold weekly Transition Assistance Program classes for troops reaching the end of their military service. They use a PowerPoint spreadsheet to break down hourly earnings and benefits and help troops understand how much they would have to earn in a civilian position to maintain comparable living standards.
For years, weve had people under the assumption that theyre going to walk out of the main gate and someones going to be there with a bag of gold waiting to give them a high-salary job, Leeds said. One of the things that they teach in (the TAP class) is to tell people things arent as rosy as theyve been told in the civilian sector.
Deciding how to make up the difference in pay plays a role in whether or not troops decide to stay in Onslow County or move, Woods said. A corporal with an honorable discharge from the Corps will rate unemployment worth up to $10,000 over six months. If she leaves to apply her GI Bill to a state school and works part-time, the former corporal can make nearly what she was earning active-duty in the short-term, he said.
Woods said about 15 percent of transitioning troops initially decide to stay in the area, though, primarily because of a buyers housing market: today, the average Marine sergeant can afford payments on the average priced house in Onslow County.
Jacksonville resident Doug Barmore left the Marine Corps as a corporal in 2002. He chose to stay in the area and finish his education, working first in an administrative clerical position with the VA and then taking a civilian job on base in the Learning Resource Center. While pay at both jobs was similar to what he made in the Corps, it did not include any of the military benefits he had enjoyed.
In order to afford to live here, especially when I was going to school, I had to live in some pretty ghetto places, Barmore said. I stayed in a trailer for like three years. I had to buy all my own food and didnt have health insurance for a long time.
Cpl. Matt and Alison Schuman, of Jacksonville plan to move to Michigan when Matt Schuman reaches his end of active service in August. Now a forward observer, Schuman has secured a government contracting job with better pay than what he makes now.
Although the couple will have to make do without the military benefits and housing allowance, Alison Schuman said the trade-off is worth it.
I still have to deal with him leaving and coming back, but its not like hes going to a war zone or anything, she said. Of budgeting for costs they didnt have before, she said, Weve kind of got to learn to deal with it. Well figure out expenses month by month.
The gap between civilian and military pay may widen next year: An across-the board pay raise between 1.4 percent and 1.9 percent for troops is now under consideration by the House and Senate.
So, people should stop whining?
which people should stop whining?
Cause I'mma keep whining since I'm civi and probably make about what a friggin PVT makes. (which is why I need a PFC)
(after typing that I went to a pay chart & actually make between E-6 & E-7 pay ONLY Basic Pay included nothing else, no BAS, no BAH JUST BASIC PAY and then of course I pay for insurance, retirement and blah so if I just go by take home pay it's between E-3 & E-4 pay.)
why should anyone have to stop whining? They have a right to (more so if they served, according to some).
What they should do, is prepare to separate from the service better (not all, but some-would hate to say most-but some for sure). If they know they are only going to do 4 years, get as much education in those 4 years as possible. Save as much $$ as possible to live off one when first separated. Especially if deciding to stay in the Onslow County area for a short time after getting out.
Know that just because you have served, it won't necessarily help you get a job later, nor will it ensure you have a 'decent' income.
It's just supposed to be a helpful article. Whether you agree with their findings or not, it is still good advice.
And take the TAPS class. lol
I'm certainly not complaining about the pay my husband makes or the benefits, especially insurance. Yes I had bad doctors in Jacksonville but up here I'm getting probably thousands of dollars in care every month. I'd say probably at least 1000 a month that we pay nothing for and at most a few bucks at the pharmacy.
I just don't think that the 2 are easily comparable even if you don't think about deployments/training. I've known Marines who only work a few hours a day which would equate an even higher per hour amount. My husband used to work 60-80 hours a week which would be about 1/2 the amount per hour, and I've known a Marine or two who worked even longer hours than my husband. Or how about DIs who probably work more than 100 hours per week rarely seeing their families at all.
My last paragraph aside, it's good for people to see that the pay isn't as crappy as some think.
Or how about DIs who probably work more than 100 hours per week rarely seeing their families at all.
are there DIs in Onslow County? This comparison was for Onslow County only.
I've known salary employees who work upwards of 80+ hours per week who were not military. There will *always* be those who throw off surveys, one way or the other. This article was speaking in averages, not every individual Marine or civilian counterpart.
I guess part way through writing I forget it was specifically Onslow County. So I guess turn my DIs into whoever trains at SOI, I would guess some of them work long hours.
I'm sure somewhere out there there might be a clerk who is salary but most of the jobs they compared were hourly type jobs.
All I meant was that of the Marines I personally know, very few worked a 40 hour week. Most of the Marines I know worked more and many worked much less. I realize it's still an average, I'm just saying I don't personally know any who are average.
There's also the fact that they get 30 days a year off, most of the civilians I know get 1 or 2 weeks.
My point wasn't to say that Marines are getting better or worse pay than civilians, just that it's not the easiest thing to try and compare.
There's also the fact that they get 30 days a year off, most of the civilians I know get 1 or 2 weeks.
yet another plus for the military
My point wasn't to say that Marines are getting better or worse pay than civilians, just that it's not the easiest thing to try and compare.
no, but there has to be a comparison in order to get pay raises. If there wasn't a comparison some years ago that showed military were well *underpaid*, there never would have been some of the larger pay raises. By larger, I mean larger then some of the civilian sectors.
Most of the Marines I know worked more and many worked much less.
again, that's where an average comes into play. :) Most of the Marines I've known didn't work much over a 40 hour work week (make sure to subtract the 1.5 hour lunch break most military get, yet civilians do not).
The wives who complain that their husbands don't make enough, but they've only been in about 2 years. :)
well, that's because they have champagne taste on a beer budget. ;)
again, that's where an average comes into play. :) Most of the Marines I've known didn't work much over a 40 hour work week (make sure to subtract the 1.5 hour lunch break most military get, yet civilians do not).
We just know different people. For example my husband's old office typically worked at least 50 hour weeks. My husband also typically couldn't even get an hour off to go to the gym (in place of lunch) because he was so busy. And every civilian I know who works at least 6 hours a day gets a lunch break and most of them get 30-60 minutes and it's paid for. For the people I know, part time employees can take 30 minutes and get paid for it or take longer and clock out, but any full time employee I know gets an hour paid for. Shoot, even when I worked part time making 7 something an hour while I was in school I got a 45 minute paid for lunch break.
Most businesses I know of make you clock out for your lunch break because you don't get paid for it.
I used to get an hour lunch break, paid. My dad gets paid for lunch, too.
they were all in Onslow County? All those civilians you talked about? I've never known anyone who got a paid for lunch. My mom works full time on the base and only gets 30 minutes. She has to clock out for lunch, too. I did when I worked in Onslow County, too.
And that's exactly the point. We know different people. Therefore, the point of the article is that *typically*, or *average*, military in Jacksonville get paid more, overall, then civilians do.
So you think the military in Onslow County get paid less then civilians? Overall, on average? Not just the specific people you know?
All the businesses I know where I'm at and a few in Jacksonville do not allow their workers to stay on the clock while on lunch break. Why should you get paid when you are not working, pertains to hourly employees? Different businesses have different policies and it also depends on who you know too.
I used to get an hour lunch break, paid. My dad gets paid for lunch, too.
was that in Onslow County? I cannot think of one person who doesn't have to clock out for lunch. Not those that are hourly employees. Obviously salary employees do not have to.
was that in Onslow County? I cannot think of one person who doesn't have to clock out for lunch.
Yep, it was. The job I had in MO was the same way.
also depends on who you know too.
LOL. I don't know anyone 'important' in Onslow County. We all didn't have to clock out for lunch.
Yep, it was.
I would bet dollars to donuts that those are fewer then those required to clock out (I almost typed log out lol). I most certainly could be wrong. ;)
I just do agree that, for younger people, military do get paid decent in Onslow County.
I would bet dollars to donuts that those are fewer then those required to clock out (I almost typed log out lol). I most certainly could be wrong. ;)
You're probably right.
We all didn't have to clock out for lunch.
Were you on salary or getting paid for 9 hours a day?
10 hour days. 9 hours of work and the hour for lunch.
10 hour days. 9 hours of work and the hour for lunch.
so while you didn't have to clock out for lunch, you didn't get paid for it, right? That's basically the same as having to clock out.
You had said this:
I used to get an hour lunch break, paid. My dad gets paid for lunch, too.
But if your day was 10 hours and you only got paid for 9, it wasn't a paid lunch.
never mind, I read it slower. you got paid for 10 hour days? sorry. oops! I really need some caffeine. lol
I woke up too early today, dmc. I probably typed it out confusing. LOL. Yep, I got paid for 10 hours, though.
My dad doesn't work for Onslow county. He's a civilian contractor in MO.
He's a civilian contractor in MO.
some of the civilian contractors get screwed on CL. They may get their hour, paid, for lunch, but they get hit other ways. I know a few who are considered 'self employed' so they don't get employer help with their taxes. They pay 100% all on their own. I'm sure some of them would gladly give up that hour to get tax help. I have a friend who took a different job making about $4 less an hour because she would make more by taking less. It got her off the 'contractor' status, though.