My younger brother is going to Johnson and Wales University next year, so for his high school graduation, he told us that he wanted a mini fridge. No problem.
My husband's sister is also graduating high school, but is not going on for school. We asked her what she wanted, and she said the classic 'I really don't need anything, blah blah blah'. I feel like that is asking for money...which I am not comfortable giving to her. So, I really don't know what to get her. Any ideas?
Why are you uncomfortable with giving her money? If you don't mind answering but you don't have to.
I was gonna say money until you said that. :P
Can you ask your husbands mom or anything what she likes?
If it were me, I'd give her the same amount I spent on the fridge in either cash or a gift card. I wouldn't care what she did with it.
Of course, I got my apartment furnished, a garnet ring, and $500 for graduation from various family members.
I'm not answering for tb, but I do know there was a thread some time before and some said they didn't do cash, or much of anything, for a grad who wasn't going on to college. Or didn't have a 'set' plan, college, military, etc...
His sister is an adult, what she does with a monetary gift/card is up to her (she has to learn to handle money wisely at some point!!) She's still graduating HS and that is what the GRADUATION gift is for, not if she's going to do something with her life. Your brother just wants a specific item as his present vs. she doesn't.
I think a gift card for the same amount you spend on your brother from the same store would be appropriate.
so she's not going on to school, what is she doing?
She has NO idea!
Can you ask your husbands mom or anything what she likes?
haha, oh boy, we have nothing to do with anyone in my husband's family except for his sister.
Why are you uncomfortable with giving her money?
I really don't have a specific reason, I'm just not thrilled with the idea. I like to know where my money is going.
$50 or $100 gas card?
THAT would be a very good idea, I know that he car isn't in very good condition, so I could do that with an oil change and tune up.
I'm not answering for tb, but I do know there was a thread some time before and some said they didn't do cash, or much of anything, for a grad who wasn't going on to college. Or didn't have a 'set' plan, college, military, etc...
I couldn't have said that better myself. That's exactly how I feel!
She has NO idea!
that's scary, maybe you can find her a plan and buy that for her? :P
I only said that because you already liked the gas card idea. I can be silly now. :P
The gas card is a great idea! A Target or Walmart card is also always a great idea as they can get what they want such as music, electronics, clothes, food or if they move out into a place of their own, stuff they need for the place. If they go to college or into military, they can always use the gift card for things they need for themselves.
Money's a gift not a loan. If I give money, I like to know the person bought something they need or simply want. maybe she's embarassed to tell you what she needs. Maybe she could buy an outfit/blouse for a job in the future? It's not like she's a druggy or alcoholic. She's a high school grad.
Why are you uncomfortable with giving her money?
I really don't have a specific reason, I'm just not thrilled with the idea. I like to know where my money is going.
When you give some a gift, it's a gift, it's no longer your money or item. So why care?
I'm not answering for tb, but I do know there was a thread some time before and some said they didn't do cash, or much of anything, for a grad who wasn't going on to college. Or didn't have a 'set' plan, college, military, etc...
I couldn't have said that better myself. That's exactly how I feel!
Well that is absolutley ridiculous! A graduation gift is a gift celebrating the accomplishment of graduating! It is not an investment on what they might do next.
I don't think you should give her anything since it's not coming from the heart.
Well that is absolutley ridiculous! A graduation gift is a gift celebrating the accomplishment of graduating! It is not an investment on what they might do next.
I totally agree, just giving another point of view. I had never heard of such a thing until that thread I linked a few posts above.
Well that is absolutley ridiculous! A graduation gift is a gift celebrating the accomplishment of graduating! It is not an investment on what they might do next.
I totally agree, just giving another point of view. I had never heard of such a thing until that thread I linked a few posts above.
I've never heard that either. I have heard my mother in lae complain about giving graduation gifts, and have seen her give $20 for graduation (which I think is so cheap). I've heard of people not liking and not giving gifts for college graduation parties. I agree with that.
I gave my BIL $50 for graduating HS. I gave my brother nothing because he quit in the middle of his Senior year and got his GED.
I have sent him money for other crap when he needed it though.
When he went to college he needed help with his apartment deposit so my mom, Grandma and I agreed to help. I was reserved about it so I told him if he went the whole year, he could consider it a gift, but if he dropped out then it was a loan and it had to be repaid. He got pissed and told me to eff off. My Grandma and mom were out $500 when he dropped out after failing his first semester(he got away from home and started just hanging out and partying, did not do his work). Then he asked me to cosign on a motorcycle... I laughed at him. I love him to death, but damn!
Did she apply herself in school??
If it were me and I was "obligated" to give a graduation gift, yet the student didn't do homework, barely passed, skipped many classes, etc... I don't think I'd give anything. They did the bare minimum and shouldn't be rewarded IMO.
The gas card/vehicle maintenance is a great idea, she might not have even thought twice about an oil change, and will need a way to get to job interviews. :)
If it were me and I was "obligated" to give a graduation gift, yet the student didn't do homework, barely passed, skipped many classes, etc... I don't think I'd give anything. They did the bare minimum and shouldn't be rewarded IMO.
That's why she's not going to college, she couldn't get in anywhere because of her poor grades.
It's not like she's a druggy or alcoholic. She's a high school grad.
She isn't a 'druggy' but she definitely does her fair share of drugs.
that's scary, maybe you can find her a plan and buy that for her? :P
Ugh, if only it were that easy, haha. We've tried to help her out, we offered to pay for her books if she did go to school, paid for her college application fees, even offered to pay if she wanted to take one of those short courses for medical/dental assisting.
When you give some a gift, it's a gift, it's no longer your money or item. So why care?
I understand that, but I know how irresponsible her whole family is with money. And I care, because I can...right now, it IS still my money.
When you give some a gift, it's a gift, it's no longer your money or item. So why care?
I understand that, but I know how irresponsible her whole family is with money. And I care, because I can...right now, it IS still my money.
Then keep it.
A Target or Walmart card is also always a great idea as they can get what they want such as music, electronics, clothes, food or if they move out into a place of their own, stuff they need for the place.
When we thought that she was going to college, we were going to get her a gift card, so that she could get a mini fridge, supplies for her dorm, or put it towards a new computer, etc. But now that idea is out, she lives with her boyfriend, who sponges off her...I feel like giving her a giftcard, I might as well hand it right to her boyfriend.
But now that idea is out, she lives with her boyfriend, who sponges off her...I feel like giving her a giftcard, I might as well hand it right to her boyfriend.
Get her a gift card for victoria secret :P
Buy her some household stuff... When I graduated my Uncle Brian gave me my first charcoal grill and a gift card for $30 to buy food for a house warming party for my friends and I. :)
Sometimes just giving cash is less expensive in the long run then buying a gift. So what if she is not going to college, she still could use some cash to start living her life, is she a drug addict?