I just wanted to say I think it is absolutley ridiculous to send a child somewhere for 3 days with no contact with a parent at all. I just talked to my daughter and she said she had her phone taken away until the end of the trip. Granted I knew the rule but didn't want to be unable to contact her for 3 days. She told the teacher she was texting her mom and she said something like,...You knew the rule, you have made a bad descision!
I am just mad that the school really beleives that we as parents should understand that we cant contact our children for 3 days because they are on a field trip! UUUGGHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Um, maybe you should have taken that up with the school BEFORE the trip. You knew it was a rule so IMO you shouldn't be surprised or upset.
It was the same way when I was there. If there was ever an emergency or even desire to speak to a parent during Crossing Carolina a chaperone or teacher would allow the students to use a phone.
yea, those kids could be using those phones to sneak off together after hours.
I have no idea how old these kids are or even if it's a co-ed field trip, but I'm sure there are reasons such as this one for taking the cellular devices away.
Soccermom, I emailed Ms. Williams about the no cell phone thing too because I didn't want our daughter without hers. She said it could be used in the rooms after they return from their activities but to NOT have it out during the day on the bus or on the trips. While her phone isn't an iphone, it looks just like her ipod touch. Both are loaded full of games and music; and the ipod is allowed to be out.
As for sneaking off - their rooms are taped shut at night with chaperones checking the tape every few minutes. If the tape is broken on a door; supposedly all will be sent home.
I guess I'm on the other side. People have been sending their kids cross country and more before cell phones came into existence. I think we are starting to become too dependent on them nowadays. I went on a school trip for a week and had no way to call home unless I charged it to the hotel room. (*we as in general)
I guess I'm on the other side. People have been sending their kids cross country and more before cell phones came into existence. I think we are starting to become too dependent on them nowadays. I went on a school trip for a week and had no way to call home unless I charged it to the hotel room. (*we as in general)
: )
I agree with whoever said it should have been taken up with them BEFORE the trip, like Mermaid did.
Well I don't know if it is the same for other schools, but NBMS has been notorious for the last 3 years of not arriving back when they say they are going to. On trips when our daughter hasn't had her cell, we (and other parents) have sat at the school waiting for over an hour and even once almost 2 hours. The trip she went on last week, her bus was about 15 minutes later than the other two; and they were ALL about an hour later than what they said they were going to be. Teachers had the kids with phones call their parents instead of one teacher trying to call 80 parents.
In this day & age with school shootings, drunk bus drivers (happened to my nephew) and such, I don't feel bad at all for being an overprotective parent by providing my child with a way to contact me in an emergency.
Mermaid, I don't think you sound overprotective. I think for a concerned parent you did exactly the right thing in communicating and being proactive with your child's safety. It's a great example for your kids too.
I sincerely doubt you'll have zero contact with your child. Even if she didn't have a cell to begin with, they're in a hotel room, with a phone.
I agree with DA.
As for sneaking off - their rooms are taped shut at night with chaperones checking the tape every few minutes. If the tape is broken on a door; supposedly all will be sent home.
That's a good idea.
A school trip I went on my junior year probably would have gone better if they did that. A bunch of us snuck to another floor where another school was having a party. One guy didn't come back til the bus was about to leave. Needless to say, we got in huge trouble.
Uh....I made it through many a field trip without a cell phone. Back in the old days, we kids didn't HAVE our own cell phones, ya know, and we LIKED IT!
I agree, as long as one of the chaperones or two has a phone in case they need to call out, I think it's GREAT, the kids can concentrate on the FIELD TRIP!!
Uh....I made it through many a field trip without a cell phone. Back in the old days, we kids didn't HAVE our own cell phones, ya know, and we LIKED IT!
lol
How'd our parents know when to pick us up?
Oh wait, my mom never let me do extra things that cost money so I'm pretty sure I don't have to worry about that.
On our field trips they were always told what time we would arrive.. if we were late then they would wait in the parking lot, if we were early, then we would wait on the buses. lol
I had to call my mom from the school phone and wake her up at 3 am when I got in to come get me. lol
or stand in line for the payphone. Either at the school, or the last stop. lol
I would send my son's phone with him, too. But yeah, I would have addressed it with the school before they left. My son also would have had strict rules to not take it out during the activities.
They have a no cell phone rule at my son's old schools. All the kids had them, all the teachers knew. Most of the teachers didn't care as long as they weren't pulled out during class and became a distraction. So yeah, I would have told him to adhere to the school's rules already.
I remember when my alarm on my pager once went off in class during a math test. lol (Yeah I know, off subject) Luckily my teacher just looked at me and silently mouthed, "Put it away."
For us it was "Cool" I remember in 6th grade to make sure you pager was "seen". If you didn't have a blue, pink, purple, whatever color clip hanging out of your pocket, you were so not talked to. And oh buddy if you had one of those cool silver chains attaching it to your pocket? Oh hell you were mega cool! lmao
Well, like I said above the NBMS busses have never arrived anywhere near on time from our experience. I'm not going to sit in the parking lot for an hour or two just wondering why the delay and waiting for them to arrive.
As for having our daughter call us once they arrive; not happening. It's not like the school is 1 mile away from the house because we're in the school zone. NBMS is a magnet school; kids come from as far away as Swansboro. I also don't want to have to inconvenience a school employee to have to sit there and wait because I'd be the last one there to pick up my child.
As for this trip, I haven't called/spoken to nor sent a text to our daughter. She was told the rules and knows to keep it put away. It was to be used only for emergencies. That is ALWAYS the rule that she has to follow when she has it at school, or anywhere else it would be inappropriate to have it out & in use.
Her safety is top priority with me. Having grown up in a small city where we had 2 serial killers (they were cousins working together & got 2 of my sisters friends and 1 escaped, that's when they were caught) & another one in the same vicinity at least once to dump part of a body you'd better believe I'll at least give our daughter a chance to make contact if something were to ever happen; even if it is just by the tracking on the cellphone. Do I think something like this would happen while she's on a field trip? Not necessarily, but I'm sure Natalie Holloway's mom thought she would be coming back home to her after her trip.
I just don't see why this has to be a debate. Do what you want with your children & I'll do what I want with mine.
For us it was "Cool" I remember in 6th grade to make sure you pager was "seen". If you didn't have a blue, pink, purple, whatever color clip hanging out of your pocket, you were so not talked to. And oh buddy if you had one of those cool silver chains attaching it to your pocket? Oh hell you were mega cool! lmao
Haha! I wanted one so bad in middle school but what on earth would I actually have done with it?
I had to wear a heart monitor for a few weeks at a time a few times in middle and high school and the recording device was about the size of say the older zunes. It had a clip so I would put it in my pocket but clip it so it wouldn't fall out and tug at the cords attached to my body. I got in trouble so many times for having a pager or other electronic device on me, until they realized what it was of course.