Article
Camp Lejeunes commanding officer violated a base civilian employees free speech rights in 2008 by banning his anti-Islamic emblazoned car, a federal judge ruled Wednesday.
Retired Marine Gunnery Sgt. Jesse Nieto filed a lawsuit in U.S. District Court two years ago after base officials determined he could no longer drive his Toyota with decals and bumper stickers displaying anti-Islamic symbols and language onto any military installation. A civilian employee since 1994, Nieto had displayed the bumper sticker messages including a decals that reads Islam = Terrorism and the image of a cartoon boy urinating on the picture of a Muslim since 2001.
Senior United States District Court Judge Malcolm Howard recognized the lawsuits main defendant, base commanding officer Col. Richard Flataus broad discretion in restricting a wide range of expressive activity aboard base, but ruled he could not use traffic regulations to discriminate against Nietos opinion.
While military officials are entitled to great deference in restricting speech to further the militarys needs, they may not do so in a manner that discriminates against a particular point of view, Howard ruled.
Since base officials have violated Nietos right to free speech with the use of bumper sticker restrictions, the base cannot use the regulations to limit free speech in the future, Howard stated in his 16-page ruling.
Defendants, their employees, agents and successors in office, are hereby permanently enjoined from enforcing Base Traffic Regulation BO 5566.2M, Chapter 2, paragraph 7 in a manner that discriminates against speech based on the viewpoint expressed, Howard stated.
The restriction carried over to Arlington National Cemetery where Nietos son, Marc, was buried after dying in the 2000 terrorist attack on the USS Cole that also killed 16 other sailors. Nieto, who served two tours of duty in Vietnam War as an infantryman, was not allowed to drive the vehicle into the cemetery, according to the order from base traffic court officer Lt. Col. James Hessen, who was also named as a defendant in the lawsuit.
By testifying that they would allow positively-perceived bumper stickers about the Islamic faith, base officials demonstrated they were being selective in their restrictions, said Nietos attorney, Robert J. Muise, Senior Trial Counsel for the Thomas More Law Center.
"During testimony base officials said they would permit bumper stickers with messages that said 'Islam equals peace,'" Muise told The Daily News late Wednesday in a telephone interview from Michigan. "By allowing messages representing something Mr. Nieto does not believe in, but banning him from expressing something he holds true, the base violated his Constitutional rights."
Muise, a former Marine officer of 13 years who was assigned to Camp Lejeune twice, said Nieto was in Texas for the rest of the week, but he would be back to work aboard Camp Lejeune on Monday and will be displaying his bumper stickers.
Nietos local attorney, Jacksonville lawyer Wally Paramore called Muises success in the case a protection of our freedom of speech.
This victory means a great deal to (Nieto) and his commitment to free speech and our country was one of the key reason I joined in this effort, Paramore said.
Base officials did not immediately return e-mails concerning the ruling.
A Virginia-based free speech watchdog group honored Camp Lejeune with a Muzzle Award in April 2009 for what they said was a violation of Nietos freedom of speech.
The decision to target Nietos opinions seemed purely content-based and arbitrary, the Thomas Jefferson Center for the Protection of Free Expression announced last year.
I'm all for freedom of speech, but I still think the guy with the anti-Islamic bumper stickers is an idiot.
About 2 weeks ago I was at the library on base and saw a truck with a tacky saying across the back window.
In large letters it said, "There's GAY...Then There's ARMY GAY".
Real nice.
Another of those situations where having the right to do something doesn't mean you have to.
I'm all for freedom of expression, but this could open a can of ugly worms.
Part of the reason the judge ruled in Nieto's favor was that base officials said they would allow pro-Islamic stickers.
Let's make the easy transition to race. What if someone wants to display a Klan or other white supremacist sticker? You know damn good and well base officials would allow an NAACP sticker, or any other pro-black sentiment.
No, I am NOT saying we should allow KKK or other racist idiots to display their hate on base (not that any of them would have the balls to do so publicly and without their hood). I'm just saying the precedent has been set that if you'd allow X, you have to allow its opposition.
Of course I also feel this guy is just displaying his ignorance. While we see and hear a lot about Muslim terrorists, the ENTIRE Muslim faith isn't composed of terrorists, so to say Islam = terrorism is just ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, I love making smarta$$ jokes about it, and I've been known to lump it all together in moments of anger, but you wouldn't catch me plastering stickers on my car about it.
Of course I also feel this guy is just displaying his ignorance. While we see and hear a lot about Muslim terrorists, the ENTIRE Muslim faith isn't composed of terrorists, so to say Islam = terrorism is just ridiculous.
Exactly.
The Confederate flag offends some people but it's still allowed on base. If that's the case, don't allow any stickers. =/
Actually, I've seen the MP's turn away a guy who had an actual Confederate flag on his truck.
I dont think it's ingnorance. I think it's pain on his part.
I'm sure his actions are driven by pain, but it's still ignorance, pure and simple, to associate all Muslims with terrorism.
Ive seen some pretty terrible things on base...vehicles, shirts...not to mention what you will just hear walking around -
*shrugs* it is ignorance, but in the end it just makes him seem like a crotchety old racist
And that crap about the government violating constitutional rights is hilarious in light of what they doing now-a-days.
How would some of you feel if your son was killed by Muslim terrorists ?
The point is this man had been driving his car on base for a few years and no one had a problem with it until a marine wanted to complain about it to the MP's because they were offended by his sticker.
There's plenty of offensive stickers on cars today but they're allowed to go through the gate.
The bottom line is they singled this man out.
And no he's not a "crotchety old racist", he far from that.
And yes I know him personally for years.
He's allowed to be racist all he wants. That's his RIGHT. If he'd like to display it on his car, that's also his right. If he wants to use the "N" word or any other racial slurs, that's his right. It's part of the Constitution. I'm not saying I condone being a racist, but he most definitely has the right to be one if he so chooses.
And he was singled out for having his beliefs, whether the vast majority of people agree with his sentiment or not. I've seen plenty of tasteless stickers on cars, and seen some pretty ridic shirts as well. I might shrug or roll my eyes, but I also recognize that people have the right to display those stickers and wear those shirts.
Apparently the judge feels the same way about htis man since they ruled his freedom of speech was violated.
I'd hate it, but I wouldn't hold it against Islam as a whole.
You wouldn't, but some people do. As a retired Gunny, he swore to uphold the Constitution. A Constitution that includes freedom of speech and expression. Exactly what he was doing. So in other words, they want him to uphold that Constitution, but God forbid he wants to take advantage of one of it's Amendments.
He doesn't really blame it on Islam as a whole. One would have to actually talk to him to understand where he's coming from.
I don't know how I would react if that were my son, it's hard to say.
But the bottom line is he's expressing how he feels and his freedom of expression was tromped on by the base commander. Plain and simple.
Mac I've never said I disagree about it being his right to display the sticker. None of my comments have even been directed toward that.
I know goddamn good and well it's within his rights. I may not have retired (not sure why that's relevant) but I upheld the same Constitution he did.
Maybe not, but that's the message his stickers send.
Well I guess people will just have to deal with it now. I'm quite sure we'll see his car going on base real soon.
How would some of you feel if your son was killed by Muslim terrorists ?
That really doesn't signify. How many of us have had family members murdered by a Christian or an Agnostic or an Athiest? It's ridiculous to spout religious tolerance when you're one faith but then turn around and judge another.
Not all muslims are terrorists. Not all christians are good. Not all athiests are bad.
He's allowed to be racist all he wants. That's his RIGHT. If he'd like to display it on his car, that's also his right. If he wants to use the "N" word or any other racial slurs, that's his right. It's part of the Constitution. I'm not saying I condone being a racist, but he most definitely has the right to be one if he so chooses.
And he was singled out for having his beliefs, whether the vast majority of people agree with his sentiment or not. I've seen plenty of tasteless stickers on cars, and seen some pretty ridic shirts as well. I might shrug or roll my eyes, but I also recognize that people have the right to display those stickers and wear those shirts.
Apparently the judge feels the same way about htis man since they ruled his freedom of speech was violated.
Like I said, I believe in freedom of speech. He's free to express his beliefs, and I'm free to think he's an ignorant douchebag.
How would some of you feel if your son was killed by Muslim terrorists ?
How many people have lost someone in Iraq/Afghanistan? I've lost people close to me, so has DH. I don't blame the entire Islamic religion, I blame the extremists.
How many people have lost someone in Iraq/Afghanistan? I've lost people close to me, so has DH. I don't blame the entire Islamic religion, I blame the extremists.
I've already said he doesn't blame the entire islamic religon.