Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Woman sues after hospital gives her wrong baby to breastfeed

who's talking here?

dmc... 4
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 7
Jules 1
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 1
billiejean Doop 1
Kappy 6
The Original LM 3
♥ Mama 2 Many ♥ 1
Kadie's Mommy 1
Muse 4
Amel!A 1
Jingle Bell Rockin 1
Susie Homemaker 2
Boobsy McNiceass 1
Quickstudy 2
Wesley James Moo Moo Cow 1
Maureen 7
soccermom 1
StudentNurseMidwife 1
Mary Katherine Gallagher 1
nicole 5
ilovemymarine85 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Maureen --- 16 years ago -

Link to story EVANSTON, Ill., Feb. 13 (UPI) -- An Illinois woman who says she was given the wrong baby to breastfeed while recovering from childbirth in hospital has filed a lawsuit, court records indicate. A day after Jennifer Spiegel, 33, gave birth to her son in January 2008, a hospital worker told her "Your baby wants you," and handed her a newborn to nurse, the Chicago Sun-Times reported Saturday. But it wasn't her son, she says in a negligence lawsuit filed against Evanston Hospital. A nurse who discovered the mix-up said, 'The baby you're feeding isn't yours,'" Spiegel recalled. "It was just an awful, internal feeling." Although no one was injured or sickened, Spiegel says the hospital bears responsibility for the mix-up. The suit seeks at least $30,000 in damages, the Sun-Times said. "And we hope this doesn't happen to anyone else," said Spiegel, a teacher. A spokeswoman for the hospital had no comment, the newspaper reported. © 2010 United Press International, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Any reproduction, republication, redistribution and/or modification of any UPI content is expressly prohibited without UPI's prior written consent. 

Amel!A --- 16 years ago -

and she needs $30000 for this? That is just sad. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

I would think the mommy of the baby has a better suit. She knows how good her milk is, the baby's mommy doesn't. 

Maureen --- 16 years ago -

I think it's ridiculous. I would be more mad that my baby went-a-suckin on someone else but at least it was getting fed. I personally wouldn't do it but I have heard of people having breast feeding circles or something. Like if you are babysitting someones baby who is around the same age as yours you just feed it instead of her pumping. I would feel weird about it but it's not like its dangerous or anything. (unless that mom is doing something she shouldn't) 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

idiot. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

I'd have gladly BFed somebody elses baby. 

The Original LM --- 16 years ago -

Frivolous... 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

personally wouldn't do it but I have heard of people having breast feeding circles In earlier times, mom's who were in the peerage didn't breastfeed their own kids most of the time. They had wet nurses to do it for them 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

I hate how we are a sue happy nation. I don't even understand WHY she is suing. I'd have gladly BFed somebody elses baby. Me too. That stuff is liquid gold for a reason. 

Kadie's Mommy --- 16 years ago -

I would think the mommy of the baby has a better suit I agree. My sister was born like 4 months early and the nurses gave her breast milk from someone else in one of her bottles. My mom flipped and wanted to know everything about the other woman's medical history, but would never have sued! People are so money hungry these days! 

Quickstudy --- 16 years ago -

Eh ya know I don't know about this one. She only fed the wrong baby, but that's only a step shy of going home with the wrong baby. BUT the fault also lies on her (depending on that hospitals procedure) because you are supposed to compare the babys bracelet to yours whenever they come in and leave the room. I think the lawsuit is ok though so that the people responsible are fired or retrained and to insure it NEVER happens again. I think the mother of the baby should sue too though. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

Umm that breast milk is pasteurized and tested before giving it to the babies of preemies,etc. 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

I think the lawsuit is ok though so that the people responsible are fired or retrained and to insure it NEVER happens again. I think the mother of the baby should sue too though. I don't think anyone should sue or be sued. Today the civil courts are packed with money hungry idiots. I don't think the nurses should be fired either. They are not perfect. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

I wonder what type of newborn security they have in place? 

Maureen --- 16 years ago -

I think the lawsuit is ok though so that the people responsible are fired or retrained and to insure it NEVER happens again. I think the mother of the baby should sue too though. The lawsuit won't get them fired though. The attention given to the hospital might but you can achieve that by going to a news paper instead of suing if that's what you really want. Suing is just about money. 

Jules --- 16 years ago -

How do you not know it's your kid? 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

All hospitals should have the newborn room in with their mother. That would have never happened if that were the case. 

Quickstudy --- 16 years ago -

I don't think the nurses should be fired either. They are not perfect. Their job is one in which they need to be as close to perfect as perfect gets! What if they take the wrong baby to get medication or surgery? What about the nurse that gave those twins a 100x more heprin (I believe) and they almost died? There is no room for error when dealing with things in hospitals, especially for newborn babies. I don't think anyone should sue or be sued. Today the civil courts are packed with money hungry idiots. Like I said, I don't know if I would call these people money hungry, and surly not idiots. When dealing with medical mistakes sometimes the only action you can take is monetary. You can't sue them asking for better training. You can sue them for dollars and cents which then they usually retrain or keep a better eye on things so as to not lose more money. Money, unfortunatly it's the bottom line and what makes the world go round nowadays :( 

Maureen --- 16 years ago -

All hospitals should have the newborn room in with their mother. That would have never happened if that were the case. I agree but I enjoyed that time my oldest was in the nursery. I got to sleep a little before we brought her home. My second roomed with me at Trippler and I didn't hate it but I wish they had a nursery. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

Is she sueing because she nursed the wrong baby or because she was given the wrong baby? 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

Their job is one in which they need to be as close to perfect as perfect gets! What if they take the wrong baby to get medication or surgery? What about the nurse that gave those twins a 100x more heprin (I believe) and they almost died? There is no room for error when dealing with things in hospitals, especially for newborn babies. They still aren't perfect, but you're comparing something life threatening with something that could have been a simple room mix-up. And yes, unfortunately this country thinks money is everything. 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

I agree but I enjoyed that time my oldest was in the nursery. I got to sleep a little before we brought her home. My second roomed with me at Trippler and I didn't hate it but I wish they had a nursery. C-man roomed in with me, and I would not have had it any other way. Even if I did get the chance to sleep, the nurses and corpsmen sure the hell kept me awake. *fist shake* I wouldn't want to rely on someone to take care of my baby. It would worry me way too much, I think. 

dmc... --- 16 years ago -

Is she sueing because she nursed the wrong baby or because she was given the wrong baby? who knows, because this was said: A nurse who discovered the mix-up said, 'The baby you're feeding isn't yours,'" Spiegel recalled. "It was just an awful, internal feeling." So basically, had that nurse not said anything, she never would have even known. 

♥ Mama 2 Many ♥ --- 16 years ago -

How do you not know it's your kid? Exactly! How about your fault check the bracelet and know your baby. It was a mistake..sh*t happens. 

Hippie_Momma(Sharon) --- 16 years ago -

society has given people hang ups about breast feeding many yrs ago that woman probably would not have thought twice about what she did. 

Maureen --- 16 years ago -

I wouldn't want to rely on someone to take care of my baby. It would worry me way too much, I think. I was more paranoid with her being in with me. I was always worried I would do something wrong or not notice something. I wanted the pros to watch her when she wasn't with me. I had a nurse at home to help with her when we brought her home so I was confident there with my first. I was a wreck with my second since it was just me and Mike and Maley. One time I thought she was sleeping with us in the bed but I had put her in her bassinet at some point and forgot. I woke up looking for her and screaming that she was lost but don't move cause you might squash her. Finally I turned on the light and saw her all safe and snuggled in her bassinet. That was honestly the scariest moment of my life. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

That's just ridiculous. The mother of the baby has a better lawsuit, and that's not saying much. 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

I woke up looking for her and screaming that she was lost but don't move cause you might squash her. Finally I turned on the light and saw her all safe and snuggled in her bassinet. That was honestly the scariest moment of my life. OMG, I can't even begin to imagine that scare. I think we adjusted to Colin fairly well, but my mom was here for a few days. It was nice to have her there to reassure our tactics. I hope we adjust just as well to our next one. 

billiejean Doop --- 16 years ago -

and she needs $30000 for this? I agree. How do you not know your baby? Even here they have to verify both hospital bracelets before you get the baby, and even then...you'd think you would kind of know your baby, unless you didn't even see him/her after the delivery. 

The Original LM --- 16 years ago -

Both of my kids had such distinct facial features even at birth, I'd have known if someone tried to hand me a different baby. I'd say the mother of the baby has a better suit if she wanted to persue it, what if the one who fed her baby had been HIV positive? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground