I have a situation...and am wondering if you all run into this too.
How do you feel about the old school variety of discipline/parenting?
(applies do tweens and teens)
I am talking about things like:
"Quit crying or I will give you something to cry about"
"I will wash out your mouth with soap"
(and actually doing it!)
Making a kid wear a sign when they outside to play that says "I am a liar."
"I am getting the belt"
Telling your child's friends that your child (boy, between 8 and 12) that he is a baby and still wets the bed in order to shame him into stopping while NOT taking him to the doctor to see if if is something else.
Do any of you still use these parenting styles? Do you think they are right or wrong?
What about routinely using grounding?
What ages is that appropriate for?
Obviously my personal opinion is that I don't agree with this type of parenting. (grounding is ok but if your child is grounded all the time...like they get grounded again before the first grounding is up...dontcha' think you would try something else??))
Thoughts, anyone?
The shamming, no I don't agree with.
yeah thats pretty harsh
i have video taped aaryn throwing a hard core fit and then play it back or i have put her infront of the mirror while shes crying so she can see herself LOL
have video taped aaryn throwing a hard core fit and then play it back or i have put her infront of the mirror while shes crying so she can see herself LOL
I think that is brilliant! How old is she?
I agree with most of the old styles and I have used them. The shamming, no I don't agree with.
Ditto.
Whenever I was a kiddie, & I would be snotty or whatever, my mom would jerk my pony tail. Ha. I hated it!!! But, it got my attention & didn't hurt, necessarily.
The shaming? Do you mean the bedwetting or the sign....?
I think they are both shame based.
The bed wetting because there could be a bladder problem. But the dunce cap is a good idea IMO. I think if you lie there are consequences.
I'm not one of those self-esteem movement nutjobs, but I also don't think it's necessary to humiliate someone in order to discipline them.
"Giving you something to cry about" always seemed vague, to me. What, exactly? Is this a physical threat? What are you saying? (General "you")
I had my mouth washed out once. I learned a lesson, but that lesson was "Don't use that language in front of one particular 'friend' who enjoyed tattling and throwing me under the bus."
I got grounded for bad grades and when my sister and I got busted making crank calls. (My babysitter taught us how to do it, and she let us...but WE got grounded. Nice.) I think it's appropriate, but I haven't grounded my kids for anything. I don't think it's appropriate until they are older...maybe after 12 or so, only because when they're younger than that, grounding becomes boredom that the PARENT has to deal with. Who's getting punished more...you or the kid? LOL!
My husband is a nitpicker about things and occasionally pulls out the humiliation card. We've butted heads a number of times.
I'm a spanker/time-outer.
When I was a child I had my mouth washed out with soap, had hot sauce put on my tongue when I said a swear word once, and have been spanked with all sort of objects.
I had my mouth washed out once. I learned a lesson, but that lesson was "Don't use that language in front of one particular 'friend' who enjoyed tattling and throwing me under the bus."
LOL Sounds like my story. It was my cousin and I was repeating a story my friend told me that involved a swear word. I even whispered it in her ear...she immediately went and told on me. That was the hot sauce incident.
Maybe "work" could be a good punishment instead of grounding. Now it's your job to unload the disher (or whatever chore on top of your regular chores).
If we complained about dinner, it was our turn to cook the next night. Of course my mom was in the kitchen, too. & she was helping & teaching. But, maybe the cooking dinner idea is a good thing -- "punishment" & a life skill, too.
LOL Sounds like my story. It was my cousin and I was repeating a story my friend told me that involved a swear word. I even whispered it in her ear...she immediately went and told on me. That was the hot sauce incident.
I remember it very clearly. I was on the front porch with a couple of friends...I was maybe 6 or 7, and I pointed out some "bird$hit" on the ground to crack my friends up. You know..."I know a dirty word, let me pull it out in front of my friends to shock and impress them." My one friend laughs and then says, "I'm telling your mom," and she promptly knocked on the door and threw me under the bus.
I didn't quit cursing. I just quit cursing in front of HER. ROFL!!!
"Giving you something to cry about" always seemed vague, to me. What, exactly? Is this a physical threat? What are you saying? (General "you")
Yes, it seems like a (lazy) automatic response that is kinda pointless! It is just something rude/sarcastic to say, and in your next breath you are yelling at the kid for being rude/sarcastic too!
I am not a huge self esteem guru either but when you are dealing with teens, you should at least attempt to be an example for your kids. Think. React. In that order.
i remember i was 14 and smarted off to my mom at the store about something. she swatted me right there. yeah its pretty embarassing for your mom to spank you in public at 14!
things have changed tho...i guess thats considered abuse now
I spank, and use timeout, and the corner. If needed. I will also send her to her room, but that ends up being more work for me. DBal posted a picture once of her daughter's room, L's room after a time out looks like a crime scene.
I've mumbled "Boy you better quit crying or I will give you something to cry about" But that's it from the list above.
I don't have teens or tweens though.
I'm a grounder, a no tv for an hour, and a toy taker. All I have to say is pass me your Nintendo ds and I get the deer in headlights look and they stop immediately. If it's a problem at school with behavior I follow the same, take away something precious. They get the idea and it works for us.
oh crap aaryn is in time out right now for losing half her classes valentines. i made her sit on the couch with her hands on her head and i kinda forgot about her...whoops