For putting him to sleep. You've had him for 4 years, he's UTD on shots. So he killed your cat, that sucks... but obviously there was a reason for it. You had the dog for 4 years, is this the first cat he killed or has he done it before?
Then why didn't you start trying to find him a home that does not have other pets then? Seems a little drastic to just put him to sleep now. Animals aren't disposable.