Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Can't graduate if you're too fat?

who's talking here?

Someone 2
Q♠ 1
~*Jolene*~ 2
Muse Heather 2
Ella Mafayo 2
Nay-Nay 1
Marie88 1
Blue 2
Erin Marie 1
Susie Homemaker 3
Quickstudy 3
littleduck90 1
Krystal in NC 2
charlys 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ella Mafayo --- 16 years ago -

College mandates fitness class for high BMI students Whattya think about this? Students have to submit to a BMI test and, if their numbers put them into the obese category, they have to take a fitness course in order to GRADUATE. If they assign you to the category and you refuse the class, you DON'T GRADUATE. I happened to think, "Well, it's radical, but maybe it's not such a bad idea," until I got to the part where students could 'test out' of the mandatory fitness class. In other words, we don't really CARE if you take it, but you have to hand over the money for either the course or the test to get the credits. THAT part leads me to put on my cynical hat and say, "They're overstepping their bounds...and this is just a veiled way to squeeze more money out of students."  

~*Jolene*~ --- 16 years ago -

I think its ridiculous. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

"They're overstepping their bounds...and this is just a veiled way to squeeze more money out of students." That's exactly what I thought, too. If they took that option out, I wouldn't think it's a bad idea. 

Krystal in NC --- 16 years ago -

lol I didn't read the article but just from the title of this thread I think it's ridiclous. They are in college, not the military for crying out loud. 

Marie88 --- 16 years ago -

I think it's ridiculous. It's not the a school's place to tell someone they are too fat. That is between a doctor and a patient. Besides, what about people whose BMI is too low? Do they force THEM to get healthy before graduation? 

Erin Marie --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Marie. I think its ridiculous. 

~*Jolene*~ --- 16 years ago -

And Ive known a few people who LIKE being big . I think its stupid . Dont most colleges make you take a gym class anyway?? I know I had to take on and my SIL is also going for her RN and she has to take one too. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

Dont most colleges make you take a gym class anyway?? Coastal does. And Ive known a few people who LIKE being big . I just can't believe that people like being obese. They just look very uncomfortable. Depends on your definition of 'big', I guess. 

Krystal in NC --- 16 years ago -

I think I am kind of big and it bothers me but then I look at other people and I am grateful that I am the size I am and I know I can do something about it myself instead of having to depend on surgery to fix it. I think you can be big and still be comfortable in your skin, but then there is crossing the line. 

Blue --- 16 years ago -

As long as the student is dishing out the money to pay for their college courses the colleges should not care what a persons weight is. IMO that would be discrimination and I think it's a bunch of bull poo-poo. 

Ella Mafayo --- 16 years ago -

Dont most colleges make you take a gym class anyway?? I know I had to take on and my SIL is also going for her RN and she has to take one too.  Most places do. And I don't object to THIS...it's the "you have to submit to have your BMI measured, and we have to determine whether you're 'fit' enough to graduate" that I have a problem with. It's an extra requirement thrown in, based on the intrusive measurement of an individual's PRIVATE health. 

Blue --- 16 years ago -

based on the intrusive measurement of an individual's PRIVATE health. Yup, yup. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

it's the "you have to submit to have your BMI measured, and we have to determine whether you're 'fit' enough to graduate" that I have a problem with. It's an extra requirement thrown in, based on the intrusive measurement of an individual's PRIVATE health. Yep, agreed. I think colleges should make all students take a physical fitness class though. 

Quickstudy --- 16 years ago -

No different than not being able to graduate because you're too black, or too gay. Wrong! 

Muse Heather --- 16 years ago -

For students who do not have a LEGIT reason to be fat, they should start that sh*t in the 6th grade. 

Quickstudy --- 16 years ago -

For students who do not have a LEGIT reason to be fat, they should start that sh*t in the 6th grade. Is liking french fries legit? 

Muse Heather --- 16 years ago -

Is liking french fries legit? Lol, no way. 

Quickstudy --- 16 years ago -

Is liking french fries legit? Lol, no way. Shart! I'da never made it out of 6th grade! Oh wait, I didn't ;P 

Q♠ --- 16 years ago -

Ummm...who are they to require this? These people pay for their education. Absolutely ridiculous. 

Nay-Nay --- 16 years ago -

Ummm...who are they to require this? These people pay for their education. Agreed! It would be one thing for someone who gives out a grant/scholarship, to put out restrictions like this (because it's their money that they're giving out), but when people are paying for their own schooling, it's absurd to put restrictions on it. That being said, I think they should add an extra 2 hours on to the school day, and make that P.E. throughout the day....we need to focus on keeping our children fit, childhood obesity gets scarier every day! 

charlys --- 16 years ago -

Considering the price of the MANDATORY meal plan at the college my youngest is attending, I think it's stupid....they tell us to spend enough that she can eat whenever and wherever but then they might say she's too fat when she does use up her money (they carry a balance, what they don't spend by the end of the year, the college keeps) to buy food??? Give me a break. 

Someone --- 16 years ago -

I've been procrastinating on the PE class for college because I can't get my heart rate up because of a heart condition and I can't do non-aerobic exercise/stretching that requires leg work because my knee didn't heal properly after surgery to remove a tumor 

littleduck90 --- 16 years ago -

I've been procrastinating on the PE class for college because I can't get my heart rate up because of a heart condition and I can't do non-aerobic exercise/stretching that requires leg work because my knee didn't heal properly after surgery to remove a tumor At CCCC? I think you can do one that's only health if you have a reason not to do the physical activity portion. And yeah, most colleges (I'm speaking from NC State college/university knowledge) require a physical fitness course. At some it's a health/pe type course and some you can choose from a myriad of things (yoga, swimming, etc). All of my friends at different schools have had to take one. The part I don't agree with is the BMI portion. IMO it should be an option (which it is at most schools). Just require a physical course and leave it up to the student to seek out the usually FREE fitness assessment. 

Someone --- 16 years ago -

No not CCCC, at the 3 colleges I went to back home and at whichever one I end up going to finish at in DC 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground