Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: If you are in your parents' home...

who's talking here?

HappyMomma 6
~*Jolene*~ 1
Jules 1
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 1
Nurse_Misty 1
~Bea~ 1
Blue 1
Muse 1
mrs. p 1
Riddle :D~ 1
Tiki, Tikcuf, dirty old perv! 1
JerseyGirl 1
Krystal in NC 1
*what the chuck, norris?!* 1
Tia! 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: If you are in your parents' home...

If you are in your parents' home and your child needs disciplined, do you think it's okay for your mom/dad to tell you how to handle your child?

Yes Vote
 
 6.2% (2)
No Vote
 
 78.1% (25)
Other (please explain) Vote
 
 15.6% (5)
HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

If you are in your parents' home and your child needs disciplined, do you think it's okay for your mom/dad to tell you how to handle your child? 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

Background story: T was throwing one of his fits at my parents' house. He was hitting, swearing, and doing one of the fits he had done previously. When he gets like this, I have learned how to restrain him, until he calms down, and then he gets grounded (this has been an issue in the past, and with his therapist, we have found something that works). Well, I restrained him and my dad started telling me that I shouldn't be doing that. In the end, I got into an argument with my dad, my mom got into an argument with my dad, and so did my sister that was there. I don't know if I was overreacting in the way I took my dad but I'm just so frustrated with T and then my dad has NO clue what I go through with him but tells me how to parent him. 

Tia! --- 17 years ago -

I dont have kids, but my answer is no. Unless it was just advice, but if I asked for it only. Fortunately my parents never get involved in my business unless I ask their opinion. 

JerseyGirl --- 17 years ago -

When I was at my mom's house while C was deployed she didn't get involved when I disciplined K. And I didn't get involved when she disciplined her. If we didn't like how the discipline was going we talked about it in private amongst just ourselves. As far as your situation no I do not think that you overreacted. 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

Oh, it was definitely unwarranted and not in private. He told me if that was the way I wanted to be with my son to get the hell out of his house (because T was being physically restrained to keep him from hurting himself or anyone else). So, I left. My sister just text me. Everyone is pissed at my dad now, at my mom's house because they know how T is and how I have to restrain him. He doesn't get like this often but when he does, he's really bad. 

Tia! --- 17 years ago -

hmm yeah, he had no right to say that to you! He is your kid and plus it is not like you were hurting him... what a though situation :/ 

Riddle :D~ --- 17 years ago -

I would take their advice and put my pnishment and their thought of punishment together and find a means in the middle. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

How did you restrain him that got your dad worked up? I live by the old adage: My house, my rules. 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

I held him with his arms tight. The way I was taught from the psychiatric hospital, when he was in last year. He wasn't being hurt at all. T was yelling though (which he does in his fits) and that got my dad worked up. My mom was fine with it. My dad would rather no punishment. Seriously. My nephews don't get punished (they live there). 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

I should add, my dad gets worked up very easily. About everything. Like, one of the kids can fall and get a cut and he'll act like they need to go to the ER, even if it's like a very small cut with no blood. Seeing blood, that's so much worse. 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 17 years ago -

If they know how I discipline her, then yes. If they don't like the way I discipline, they can ignore it. My kid, my rules. 

~*Jolene*~ --- 17 years ago -

Nope it's not ok for him to do that at all. MY mom doesn't asy anything when I discipline the girls there and if she disciplines them I don't say anything unless it was something I didn't like.(which has never happened) 

Blue --- 17 years ago -

Grandfather was just concerned. Really, how many times has a person seen a child restrained whether it's mandated by a doctor or whether that's the way the parent has found to calm the child down. As you've stated, your father has no clue what you go through with your child so how was he suppose to know that it the norm for you to retrain him. IMO this was a situation that got blown out because of hot headness. I think it's okay for a grandparent to advise their children how to discipline their children. 

Tiki, Tikcuf, dirty old perv! --- 17 years ago -

Offering advice, away from the child, is one thing. Trying to tell you how, especially during an on-going situation, no way. I never minded my parents or in-laws reining my kids in or correcting them when it needed to happen, but it also needed to be within OUR guidelines/rules. Never had any problem with either set stepping outside of that, but my MIL once countered something I told one of my kids. THAT one went over like a bridesmaid doing a lap dance for the groom at a wedding reception. 

Krystal in NC --- 17 years ago -

Yes and no. I think they can give advice, but it's not their place to discipline them. My parents do it all the time when I go home. It irritates me, but in the end they are right. And if they needed to discipline my kids even though I said it's not their place, they are the only ones I would allow to put their hands on my kids if I am not around. 

*what the chuck, norris?!* --- 17 years ago -

thank god my parents and i have the same style of discipline...my mother in law on the other hand...shes too soft and it annoys me 

Nurse_Misty --- 17 years ago -

I allow my parents to discipline my children...my kids stay with them for weeks during the summertime. Also though my kids have never really acted up for my parents to have to discipline them either. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

My parents used to behave in this way. I had my son while I lived with them so to THEM, it's like he was another child there. I struggled with this because they wanted to tell me how to raise him. Eventually, I put my foot down and told them not to undermine what I say to my child. He is mine, afterall, and I will have the authority over him in all places- not only my own home. 

~Bea~ --- 17 years ago -

I voted no but if my son is doing something wrong, I wouldn't mind if she disciplined him. 

mrs. p --- 17 years ago -

im ok with them disciplining them but, i cant stand for them to let them act up. 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

See, I don't have a problem with my parents disciplining the kids. I do have a problem with my parents telling me how to raise my child. Well, my mom doesn't tell me how to, but my dad sure did. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground