Ok so, I have this friend, shes 20 and has a 2 year old and a 1 year old. When Tim got custody of his daughter, meme a couple months ago she told me she would try to help me out with her (threw advice and such) well she has given advice but the problem is shes kinda getting on my nerves, the advice turned into critique anytime I say anything about meme. Either that or she will one up me, trying to say oh my kid does that, but worse. She does it with EVERYTHING. Like if I have a problem, say my mother was getting on my nerves, she would tell me how awful her mother is. I really don't even know why I'm friends with her.. I think just because I've known her so long and shes not ALWAYS a b!tch. I don't know, anyways I would explain the situation but I think showing the conversation would explain it better lol she kinda interrupted me a few times, so it might be a little confusing.
me- meme is being a total brat lately
me- last night she refused to eat her peas
her- yea well mine went through a screen door down the back stairs and out with the dogs while i was in the bathroom
her- god forbid we refuse to eat something
her- mine refusing daily
her- sometimes the whole meal
me- so tim put her in time out and after that sent her back to try again, still wouldn't and it was a half hour past bedtime so we sent her to bed without her blankie for not listening
me- yea well her mother let her get away with murder, and the attitude isn't gonna fly here
me- we have to be strict
her- yea
her- i am strict if she does not eat she doesn't get anything else
me- yea i do the same
her- but the routine stays the same as they need that structure
me- yea tim got home late last night so dinner was late too, we didn't realize how late it was
her- yea
me- usually she goes to bed at 8 exactly lol
her- midnight for chey last two nights
me- damn
me- meme is in time out right now for not eating her cereal
her- why
me- she ate the banana drank the milk and ate some cereal but not much
her- so what if she doesn't want it take it away and then wait till the next meal no snack
her- doesn't need a time out
me- she needs to listen, and she eats this every day for breakfast, shes just being a brat about it
her- if you did not want to eat your cereal as you already had enough would you put yourself in time out
me- i know how much she eats in the morning, she hasnt eaten nearly enough to be full
her- they go off food when they grow
her- and you don't want her to be afraid of you, and over eat
me- trust me she isn't afraid of me lol she has no problem telling me no or throwing a fit about something, and i have no problem telling her she is not to tell us no, and she she still does it, i tell her if she tells me no one more time, shes getting a time out, her dad does the same.
me- and she doesn't over eat, if shes done she says all done
me- that's how i know shes done
me- when shes being a brat she just sits there and takes forever to eat or just refuses to eat
her- yea well sorry to say but you sound like garbrielle (not sure what she meant by that, gabby is her SIL)
me- and the brattyness isnt gonna fly
me- thats fine
me- i'm not going to allow her to run the house
me- shes 2
her- i understand that
her- but seems she is in time out for a lot of different things and time out pretty soon will be a way to get your undivided attention
me- a 5 minute time out wont kill her, she gets one when she doesn't listen after being warned many times, its not like i throw her in there for every little thing, i do it when shes giving attitude and not listening, i know me and tim are new at this but audry let her get away with murder, so we cant just let things go, she needs to realize those days are over and she needs to know we make the rules not her, so if she is refusing to eat something that she has no problem eating everyday, and i know shes not full and I've told her 20 times to eat her cereal, and gave her a warning, said if you don't eat your getting a time out and she still refused, i think a time out is appropriate. i'm not gonna say ok you don't have to finish your food because then she thinks she was won. usually a time out will change her attitude and she will eat when shes done with the time out, sometimes not.. so i don't know what to tell you but i'm doing the best i can with her, but every time i say anything about her you criticize me so i'm sorry if i am kinda getting sick of it
her- whatever
her- i am not critizing just giving some pointers
me- no, i'm sorry, you are criticizing. i know the difference.
her- do what you want and don't tell me when your roommates kid is in time out then
me- go back and read what you wrote and tell me that your not criticizing
her- i'm sorry its not on here
her- and you don't have to repeat it whatever
then she signed off.
Am I over reacting? I parent meme how tim wants me to, and since she did not have a mother who set a schedule and stuck to it, or gave her the right kind of food, and let her do whatever without consequences, we have to be strict. She throws fits about food a lot since she got junk and she doesn't get junk anymore. Shes gotten better since shes been here so obviously were doing something right. Shes healthy and happy, so I don't understand why she always has to criticize every move i make with her. sorry i know that was long lol..
Everyone has to parent how they see fit. As for time out for not eating cereal, I think that was a little much. There's nothing wrong with bananas and milk for breakfast. Maybe she doesn't like cereal. Not all kids like all foods at first. If she had no structure and ate junk food, let her ease into healthier eating. My son still won't eat cheese or eggs. He has four different breakfast meals that he likes so I stick to that. Be patient with your daughter. As for your friend, just ignore her.
I think she just thinks your doing the wrong thing. I dated a guy who's child wouldnt eat anything you put in front of him only chicken nuggets. I put him in time out and he sat there and cried until his POS dad came and got him and gave him what he wanted. But in a way she is right if you sit her in time out nad she continues to fight with you it is just a way for attention. I just wouldnt feed her anything else till the next meal was ready. No snacks or junk food in between.
shes not my daughter, i guess i should have explained better. she is my roommates daughter, her mother had custody of her untill 2 months ago, and tim didnt get to see her much. she called him and said some get her i cant deal with her anymore, so he did and she gave him full custody. this was about the time me and my husband split, so we agreed that i would watch her for him while he was at work and in the field, and he would pay my half of the bills.
and she does like the cereal, she loves it actually and usually has no problem eating it, like i said shes just doing it to be a brat today. also it was kind of a breakfast and lunch deal, since it was at 11, and she also has a big appetite, so i know that just a banana dn milk doesn't cut it for her lol anyways i told her she can get down but shes not getting her blankie until she decides to listen and eat some more cereal. i don't feel like arguing with her all day over cereal. she cried about the blankie for like a minute and got over it.
I don't think you should have put her in time for not wanting to eat the food. You said she eats the same thing for breakfast every day? Maybe she got tired of eating the same thing all the time. Try something new.
That's how I see it. She's 2. Do you really think she knows what she is doing?
I think she just thinks your doing the wrong thing. I dated a guy who's child wouldnt eat anything you put in front of him only chicken nuggets. I put him in time out and he sat there and cried until his POS dad came and got him and gave him what he wanted. But in a way she is right if you sit her in time out nad she continues to fight with you it is just a way for attention. I just wouldnt feed her anything else till the next meal was ready. No snacks or junk food in between.
see thats the thing, tim doesn't allow it either, i'm not sure she does it for attention, i think she just gets in these moods and decides shes not gonna do what i tell her to... shes probably pissed because shes not getting her way all the time anymore. as for snacks she doesnt get any junk or soda, ever. she gets milk mixed with some drinkable yogert, apple juice mixed with water and sonny dee and thats it. and for snacks she gets 3 or 4 of the following foods:
graham crackers, ritz bite things with PB, string cheese, a granola bar, fig newton, a neutra grain bar, cut up apple... we have more stuff i cant think of.. i try to keep it as healthy as possible.
she loves bananas n never has a problem with those, she has 2 different cereals i switch between.. I don't really know what else she would eat for breakfast lol
i think she just gets in these moods and decides shes not gonna do what i tell her to... shes probably pissed because shes not getting her way all the time anymore.
The "kid" is 2 goodness. To top it off, this kid has been thrown into a completely different environment. You can't expect a 2 year old to do it "your" way all the time within 2 months of living with you.
The kid is TWO. Put her tail on a schedule and don't let her sleep until 11. That's not healthy.
Quit talking to your "friend". YOU have the mentality that she's "one upping" you so she probably has the same mentality. You guys are GROWN.
The "kid" is 2 goodness. To top it off, this kid has been thrown into a completely different environment. You can't expect a 2 year old to do it "your" way all the time within 2 months of living with you.
yup.
She needs a little more variety.
She's only been alive for 2 years. She doesn't know about proper food choices. Don't punish over food or you'll create a whole ball of wax: eating disorders.
I agree that putting her in timrout for not eating all her cereal was a little overboard. She ate all her banana and drank the milk plus a little cereal. MAybe she was full.
And you've called this poor 2 year old a brat quite a few times . I think that's kinda horrible. She's 2.
IMO 5 min time outs for a 2 yr old is crazy, also using her blankie against her is awful, that is her comfort thing, she is in a new situation and she needs her comfort so taking it away for not eating is dumb in my opinion, Putting her in time out for not eating is absolutly insane, If she ate some of her food then lve it at that and make her wait for the next meal but dont force her to eat everything at every meal, Kids appetites ALWAYS change, you cannot expect her to have the same appetite every single day, she may be getting sick or somthing.
OK i will stop there because IMO your friend seems more with it then you do. I do understand you dont want a 2 yr old running the house but for god's sake she is 2 and I PROMISE you it will get worse before it gets better, she does need to be on a good scheduale but remember she is only 2 and she will be no where near perfect in behaviors.
Also time outs are supposed to be equal to the childs age. 2 years = 2 minute time out. I dont think putting a 1 year old in time out is fair or necessary just because she won't eat what is offered.
And you've called this poor 2 year old a brat quite a few times . I think that's kinda horrible. She's 2.
Two year olds can be brats.
Yep, they sure can be but coupled with comments from Tater before- I don't think she really likes the kid. And that will affect how she takes care of her.
IMO 5 min time outs for a 2 yr old is crazy, also using her blankie against her is awful, that is her comfort thing, she is in a new situation and she needs her comfort so taking it away for not eating is dumb in my opinion, Putting her in time out for not eating is absolutly insane, If she ate some of her food then lve it at that and make her wait for the next meal but dont force her to eat everything at every meal, Kids appetites ALWAYS change, you cannot expect her to have the same appetite every single day, she may be getting sick or somthing.
how is a 5 min time out crazy? what, is she supposed to get a 30 sec time out? shes not in a new situation, she has been here for 2 months now, and never asks for her mom. she likes it here. and i think you need to watch yourself, because i don't appreciate being called dumb for disciplining her. if i didnt tell her to eat, she would be so unheathly and would hardly ever eat. she picks out what she wants in a meal and leaves whatever is green and healthy, or whatever. so yes we do make her eat at least some of everything. we never force her to eat EVERYTHING, i never said that, but i said she needed to eat some more before being done, as she only had a little bit of the cereal. I know what that girl can put away, and shes gonna be hungry in 15 minutes.
jesus christ i am new at the "mom" thing, I'm not perfect!
so i am supposed to just let her not listen to me because she is 2?
No, however, IMO, you're being a bit of a bully. Her blankie being her security should not have been taken away. She needs a schedule. Maybe feed her milk and bannana and if she's still hungry then feed her cereal. Time outs are too long. She needs a balance of discipline and atta girls. You have a huge responsiblity right now. The way you raise that little girl now is going to impact her forever. You want a well balanced child.
how is a 5 min time out crazy? what, is she supposed to get a 30 sec time out?
They are supposed to get one minute for every year they are. So she should get 2 minute time out.