Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

POLL: Tax?

who's talking here?

Someone 1
Hawkeye's♡Honey 3
dmc... 5
Muse 5
Erin Marie 1
Dolphin 1
COOKIE 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Tax?

So, do you think that it's a good idea to tax plastic surgery and/or video games? Call it a "Botax." Negotiators trying to find ways to fund a $1 trillion health care overhaul on Capitol Hill have floated a tax on plastic surgery as a possible revenue raiser, a senior Republican aide told FOX News. But what would amount to the ultimate personal luxury tax does not appear to be under serious consideration. Sen. Kent Conrad, D-N.D., a lead negotiator, told reporters he knew nothing about the pitch. "I've never heard one word about that in any of these negotiations," he said. Conrad did not rule out the tax, but laughed while discussing it and said he would need to hear the arguments both for and against. Likewise, Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, said she had not heard of it. The GOP aide did not know whether the idea originally came from White House budget director Peter Orszag, as reported in Congress Daily. Lawmakers have been trying to get creative in finding ways to fund health care reform. FOX News has learned from aides involved in the negotiations that there also has been talk of a video game tax -- to discourage inactive lifestyles. It is unclear how much revenue could be brought in from either tax.

Yes, plastic surgery Vote
 
 33.3% (4)
Yes, video games Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Yes to both Vote
 
 33.3% (4)
No to both Vote
 
 33.3% (4)
Undecided Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Muse --- 17 years ago -

So, do you think that it's a good idea to tax plastic surgery and/or video games? Call it a "Botax." Negotiators trying to find ways to fund a $1 trillion health care overhaul on Capitol Hill have floated a tax on plastic surgery as a possible revenue raiser, a senior Republican aide told FOX News. But what would amount to the ultimate personal luxury tax does not appear to be under serious consideration. Sen. Kent Conrad, D-N.D., a lead negotiator, told reporters he knew nothing about the pitch. "I've never heard one word about that in any of these negotiations," he said. Conrad did not rule out the tax, but laughed while discussing it and said he would need to hear the arguments both for and against. Likewise, Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, said she had not heard of it. The GOP aide did not know whether the idea originally came from White House budget director Peter Orszag, as reported in Congress Daily. Lawmakers have been trying to get creative in finding ways to fund health care reform. FOX News has learned from aides involved in the negotiations that there also has been talk of a video game tax -- to discourage inactive lifestyles. It is unclear how much revenue could be brought in from either tax.  

dmc... --- 17 years ago -

I don't understand how they are putting video games and plastic surgery together? I don't agree with taxing video games extra, they are only going after a larger population. 

dmc... --- 17 years ago -

to discourage inactive lifestyles. guess I should have read slower. It still doesn't make sense. Video games are used by many that are plenty active. Also for therapy. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

I don't know why they lumped them together. I think the only real similarity is that they are both up for sondieration when it comes to taxing to fund the healthcare plan. I don't agree with taxing either any more. I know they have to come up with the money somewhere but I don't think that's fair. 

Hawkeye's♡Honey --- 17 years ago -

Also what plastic surgery would be included? Everything, including fixing deformities or reconstructive surgeries? 

COOKIE --- 17 years ago -

Also what plastic surgery would be included? Everything, including fixing deformities or reconstructive surgeries? I was about to ask the same thing. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Hawkeye- that's the part that confused me. They shouldn't tax those who NEED to plastic surgery, kwim? 

Hawkeye's♡Honey --- 17 years ago -

Although even if they only taxed those who didn't NEED plastic surgery who gets to decide when it's needed and when it's not? I voted no to both, but I'm not for the health care plan anyway. Maybe if I actually thought the plan was a good idea I'd be more open minded to their ideas for funding it. 

Erin Marie --- 17 years ago -

They shouldn't tax those who NEED to plastic surgery, kwim? I agree. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

HH, that's how I feel. I'm not for the healtchare plan so I can't see raising taxes to cover it. 

COOKIE --- 17 years ago -

Hawkeye- that's the part that confused me. They shouldn't tax those who NEED to plastic surgery, kwim? There's lots of grey area there too though. Many people have plastic surgery for baggies on the eyes. One COULD say that it was necessary because it may effect their vision. Preventative measure, or manipulating insurance? I had reconstructive surgery on my face. I wasn't suffering any medical problems, it was just very unsightly scars. So...did I really NEED it? So....how do you decide? If you're only taxing for people who clearly don't HAVE TO HAVE IT, you may as well add in teeth whitening, and pedicures. After all, you only do it to look better, right? 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

you're only taxing for people who clearly don't HAVE TO HAVE IT, you may as well add in teeth whitening, and pedicures. After all, you only do it to look better, right? I voted no to taxing either. With plastic surgery, it IS a gray area and there will always be someone who argues that it's necessary. 

dmc... --- 17 years ago -

If you're only taxing for people who clearly don't HAVE TO HAVE IT, you may as well add in teeth whitening, and pedicures. After all, you only do it to look better, right? does insurance cover pedicures? :P 

COOKIE --- 17 years ago -

does insurance cover pedicures? :P Mine does ;) 

dmc... --- 17 years ago -

*makes note to never look at Cookie's feet* 

COOKIE --- 17 years ago -

*makes note to never look at Cookie's feet* Oh, they're beautiful! I have a special cosmetic insurance plan. It's called "Someone Elses Debit Card" I'm extremely pleased with it so far. No copay, no deductible, just swipe swipe and you're done! 

dmc... --- 17 years ago -

LMAO! 

Dolphin --- 17 years ago -

There is a difference between COSMETIC surgery and RECONSTRUCTIVE surgery. Cosmetic would include things like boob jobs (except for in the case of masectomies or other things that would cause the breasts to need to be reconstructed), tummy tucks, face lifets, etc. Reconstructive surgery would be things that a person needs in order to have a "normal" life. My guess is that they would only tax the cosmetic surgery. 

Hawkeye's♡Honey --- 17 years ago -

There is a difference between COSMETIC surgery and RECONSTRUCTIVE surgery. It didn't say just cosmetic, it just said plastic surgery. There is still a gray area, someone with a huge birthmark on their face may feel having it removed is necessary for a normal life even though it is considered cosmetic surgery. 

Someone --- 17 years ago -

I had "plastic surgery" when a dog bit my face and you could see my teeth through my cheek. I had to have it stitched back together and that was considered plastic surgery 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground