Does the punishment fit the crime?
Mary Cooper does not think so.
Her son, Sherman, a senior at Northside High School, has been barred from Friday's commencement by Principal Albert James for taking part in a school prank.
Sherman dropped 10 $1 bills from a stairway down to friends on June 3, Cooper said.
"He said he did it because it was the end of the year and he knew he wasn't going to be seeing that much of them," she said. "Mr. James called it endangerment and sent him home ... (Sherman) never denies dropping the money but said he did it just for fun and not as a prank, and I believe him."
As a result of the incident, James informed Cooper that Sherman will not be allowed to walk with his class at graduation or receive his diploma on stage along with his classmates.
Cooper feels the punishment is too harsh for her son's actions.
She said James told students pranks were OK, as long as they did not damage school property, no one got hurt or they did not interfere with or disrupt school operations.
However, James said "permission was not given to students to perform school pranks," in a faxed response to an e-mail sent by The Daily News.
"I did announce and warn the students that if a prank was pulled, that it could not interrupt the school climate," the fax read.
He said board policies relating to student records prohibited him from answering other questions on the matter.
Earlier in the day James pulled Sherman aside to warn him to "keep his nose clean" and not take part in an incident involving marbles Sherman had gotten wind of but one that never happened, Cooper said.
She said two other students, juniors, were involved but received no punishment other than a warning from James that they had better not get in any trouble next year.
"How is it that Sherman is barred from his graduation, yet the other students did not get suspended or punished at all, only received warnings?" she asked. "They got a second chance. Why can't my son?"
She has a petition with more than 100 student and parent signatures in support of Sherman being allowed at his commencement.
"My phones are just ringing off the hook with people who want to try and help," she said.
Two other students who let 10,000 crickets loose in the school's hallway on June 4 are also barred from commencement.
"How can the principal compare the two incidents?" Mary asked. "My son never had a discipline problem and did not disrupt school."
She said she received a call Thursday from James offering to perform a "private ceremony" to deliver diplomas to the three banned students before the actual graduation.
"Our family has decided not to take part in that," she said.
She said she planned to mail the required certified letter and hand deliver a copy of the letter requesting an appeal Thursday, even though an appeal hearing would come too late.
Board of Education chairwoman Margaret Brown said she was looking into the matter.
Earl Taylor, of the schools' Department of Community Affairs, said members of the staff met with Cooper on Wednesday to discuss the issue.
"Ms. Cooper met again (Thursday) morning with the staff member at our office," Taylor said. "Ms. Cooper has not filed an appeal at this time. Appeals to the board review panel are scheduled every other Thursday as needed. Ms. Cooper has met with the school principal on several occasions."
But those meetings have not given Cooper what she wants.
"First (James) tells me it is really not that big of a deal, and my son won't be missing that much, he'll get over it," she said. "But I read in The Daily News they are going to live stream graduation because it's important for families overseas ... to be able to see their children's graduation ... Well my family wants to see my son's graduation just as badly, and it's just as important for them to be able to see my son graduate."
JDNews Link
Depending on the incident, like if there were a lot of kids around and it potentially causing a riot-like scene, I'm on the fence. I feel more that it maybe was a little too harsh of a punishment. Maybe the boy could have done ISS or detention or something his last few days of school, since he "never was disruptive" in school.
On a random note, Mr. James was my elementary school Principal, lol!
Depending on the incident, like if there were a lot of kids around and it potentially causing a riot-like scene, I'm on the fence. I feel more that it maybe was a little too harsh of a punishment. Maybe the boy could have done ISS or detention or something his last few days of school, since he "never was disruptive" in school.
I agree with that.
we did pranks every year and NO ONE was ever banned from walking... my freshmen year the senior let pigs loose in the courtyard... sophomore year they trashed a car in front of the school and put a portajohn on top of the school...junior year they t.p the school and my senior year we all camped out on the football field...
Sherman! Bawhahahaha!
Shermanator... A sophisticated sex robot sent back through time to change the future for one lucky lady.
I am the Shermanator. You have been targeted for Shermanation.
Sherman! Bawhahahaha!
Shermanator... A sophisticated sex robot sent back through time to change the future for one lucky lady.
I am the Shermanator. You have been targeted for Shermanation.
lol
WAy too harsh. But I agree with not letting the cricket pranksters walk. They did that my sophmore year...it was really really gross, tons of dead bugs everywhere.
Two other students who let 10,000 crickets loose in the school's hallway on June 4 are also barred from commencement.
LMAO.....that will go down in history....
Two other students who let 10,000 crickets loose in the school's hallway on June 4 are also barred from commencement.
LMAO.....that will go down in history....
Students could have been crushed if a riot HAD occurred. We don't know if this kid was trouble all school year.
I only skimmed the article but pretty sure it said he hadn't gotten in trouble for anything else before.
Unless the bills were attached to bricks, this is ridiculous.
And regardless of the principals denial of giving permission, "I did announce and warn the students that if a prank was pulled, that it could not interrupt the school climate," amounts to approval of pranks that don't interrupt the school climate. I don't see how dropping 10 $1 bills would be much intteruption of the "school climate" whatever the hell that means. Any time in the last week of school, the "climate" was pretty crazy when I was in school, and hearing stories from my kids has pretty much confirmed it's still the same.
Sh*t, if that dumba$$ principal thinks this kid was out of line for what he did, he would've HATED my senior class! Our last day of school was barely controlled chaos.
Wow, the exact same punishment for dropping a few pieces of paper as for unleashing cricket chaos? If the next kid puts a cherry bomb in the toilet, I suppose he'll get the same punishment. Whatever happened to individualized punishment based on the seriousness of the offense? And how fair is it for one minor act to be allowed to override four years of hard work and appropriate behavior? I'm ready to put some crickets in that principal's boxers!
Well, it would be a waste of perfectly good fishing crickets, now that I think of it. Anyone know where I might score a couple of Tasmanian devils? I'll save the crickets for the bream.
That's ridiculous! He dropped $10 in dollar bills and got banned from walking in the biggest ceremony so far in his life?! Wish I had the school's number, I'd call and raise Cain myself.
What a crock of sh!t...
I hope the kid goes on to college, majors in education, makes it to superintendant of schools...and fires that turkey of a principal just a week shy of retirement. He can hand the guy ten 1.00 bills as he's cleaning out his desk. Sweet karma.
I have a feeling there is more to the story than what is reported. It just seems like there is something misreported or something.
Yes, I think the punishment is extremely harsh, BUT if it was a "prank" and the students were warned NOT to do such things and told the consequences, then I think anyone involved in any pranks should face those consequences.
I know people who have worked for that principal. At that time, they had nothing but wonderful things to say about him and the way he ran their school (at that time, he was principal of Jacksonville Commons Middle School). He did a lot of mentoring program and helped get some seriously at-risk kids on the right path. So, I can forgive him for being a little overly zealous on this.
WTH. when i was in high school my principal was a magistrate on top of a principal. He was a tough principal but even he let us pull off lil pranks our senior year
Im so confused. I dont even see how dropping money is a prank? What is funny about it?
This is dumb! Now when we had some seniors spread manure around our school and I mean EVERYWHERE, that was a prank! I could see why they didn't walk.
Dumb dumb dumb!
When my brother graduated in 2002, his friend at the time showed up at graduation wearing a DRESS. It was his prank. They sent him home and told him not to come back. He went back anyway wearing a decent outfit and they kicked him out, LOL.