My daughter is 14 months old and she takes a pacifier at night only is this too old to use one? My husband thinks she should be completely off of it but its not like she has it in her mouth all day just to sleep. My oldest didn't take one at all so is this to old to have her still taking it or is it fine?
My husband thinks she should be completely off of it
Personally, I agree with your husband but my kids never took a paci so I'm no expert on the subject.
My answer is the "meany poopy pants" answer, but I say before they are a year old.
Mine never used them long - some never even took them.
In MY OPINION, they pacify the parents more than the child.
At 14 month, I think it's time to toss it. Like months ago.
My oldest had his untill his 3rd Bday. I wanted it gone way earlier but he had a major love and attachment to it. I had him give them away on his 3rd bday and he was fine, but we did have 3 hellish days after and he NEVER took nother nap in his life.
IMO if it hasn't been taken away before they have communication and understanding (like 9 months tops) then wait untill they're old enough to talk to and give them a reason whjy it has to go and let them GIVE it away. kwim?
Nothing in the world more revolting to me than seeing a toddler walking around with a binkie in it's mouth.
My neighbors kid is 3 or 4 yrs old and still walks around with a binkie and diaper! Poor kid has such lazy a$$ parents!
yeah i would toss it... and cold turkey toss it... she might cry but just let her cry it out:) be patient.... and in a couple days or less no more issue :)
In MY OPINION, they pacify the parents more than the child.
I thought the SAME thing. That's untill I had a SEVERLY colic baby who didn't like any of the 20 binkies we tried. I spent 2 months standing in front of his swing (while it was swinging) with my pinkie in his mouth (Oh, nail down, HAD to be nail down lol). So when I did find a binkie he liked, well it comforted him and allowed me atleast a few hours of sleep out of every 24.
yea i wasn't going to let her have one at all but when she was a few days old she would cry for hours at a time and my mother in law talked me into getting her one and it was instant quiet she only takes it long enough to sleep once it falls out at night shes okay i tried to take it away once before then we moved here and that upset things from the normal routine so i just took it away during the day
My neighbors kid is 3 or 4 yrs old and still walks around with a binkie and diaper! Poor kid has such lazy a$$ parents!
See, I find that offensive. If the kid is 4 well that's kind of ok to (in your own mind) judge, but 3, eh, you don't know the situation. Like for us, my son had horrendous colic and acid reflux, the sucking of the binkie helped with both and that didn't go away untill he wqs 16-18 months old, by then I think it's bad to just snatch it away. It's better to wait a few more months so you can tell them why THEY need to GIVE it up.
Lori, if it's just to sleep go ahead and try cold turkey, it may go great. If it doesn't go great don't feel bad about giving it back, just don't post about it ;) lol
i tried to take it away once before then we moved here and that upset things from the normal routine so i just took it away during the day
Same here! When we moved here (and the 5 months of related upheavel, a whole other story) he really got attached to it, like a full hearted LOVE for it, so I wasn't going to take away his security in such an insecure time. kwim?
thanks for all the advice ladies this has helped so much i just wasn't sure what to do because the only people i have for advice are my mom and his mom and mine is totally against the pacifier and his is totally for it so its been a big debate i just wanted other opinions thanks so much!!!
Hey.. didn't the Lejeune Nanny 911 episode feature 4 year olds who still used binks?
If a kid can say 'I want my bink"..he or she is too old for it :) Obviously, there are special circumstances, but if you don't have any of those, i'd think the sooner the better.
10 months I take my kids away. MY oldest did it herself. (it took us like a week to notice she wasn't taking it anymore. lol)
So when my seond turned 10 months they all went inthe trash and that was it. One night of crying and it was done. I plan on doing it the same time with this baby.
I hate them, so DD never did have one and when DS came along the doctor suggested that I give him one for the sucking action since I was nursing him and the doctor said to get rid of the pacifer between 3-4 months old and there should be no problem. At 4 months I tossed it and never had any problem, but then I do not believe in a kid walking around with those sippy cups either. I used those when they were sitting at the table or needed a drink of water and did not want to take the chance of them spilling.
I say they go when the bottle goes. So, when you wean them from the bottle or breast to a sippy cup, then the 'bink' goes, too. Now, I haven't been through it yet, but I will take it away cold turkey. Some with the bottle. (I was lucky with the breastfeeding, my daughter weaned herself at six months, I guess it was boring) Now she has a cup she plays with to get used to it when the bottle goes, that way there will be no WTF is this shock.