I can see both sides. She doesn't have anyone for her kids, but at the sametime she made the commitment fully knowing what could happen and failed to plan. That's not the amry's fault.
I'm glad someone else posted it, because I fell short on my first search, too. lol
It goes back to what I have said before, better topic titles would make searches so much easier.
I heard that too on the radio this afternoon (dang, I listen a lot of radio) and wondered I bet when her hubby comes home we will hear about them two going on a 'well deserved cruise' ... alone!
most likely shell probably get a hardships discharge. thats usually the discharge that is given in these type of cases if she absolutely cant find someone for her kids to stay with.
but at the sametime she made the commitment fully knowing what could happen and failed to plan. That's not the amry's fault.
It's not really her fault. She did her time and was inactive reserve - that's what everyone is after they get discharged after their first term. She did the same thing I did. After she got out she decided to start a family because obviously she didn't want to have kids while in the military. I think she was being pretty responsible. Now had she been regular reserve it would be another story and I would agree with you. On this situation though - I don't fault her. She's technically already been discharged.
People who get called back from inactive reserve are OFTEN released from being called back because they are college students, started their own business, have a sick family member, or whatever their case might be. She's not the only one.
It's not really her fault. She did her time and was inactive reserve - that's what everyone is after they get discharged after their first term. She did the same thing I did. After she got out she decided to start a family because obviously she didn't want to have kids while in the military. I think she was being pretty responsible. Now had she been regular reserve it would be another story and I would agree with you. On this situation though - I don't fault her. She's technically already been discharged.
I agree. I was discharged and I have one more year of inactive reserve. But if they call me back I have to go cause I'm married but if hubby is deployed I probably would be in the same boat as her.
Yeah you can't put the next four years of your life AFTER the military on hold for something that prolly won't even happen.
That is so true. Then we'd never move on. She did her duty as a service member and moved on. You can't fault her for that.
She paid her dues.
Yeah, but I don't see anything wrong with a person being called back. I just think her reasons for not being able to go are justified. There are plenty of Marines out there who have gotten out that are doing nothing and struggling to find jobs. There ARE other people to go.
Yeah, but I don't see anything wrong with a person being called back. I just think her reasons for not being able to go are justified. There are plenty of Marines out there who have gotten out that are doing nothing and struggling to find jobs. There ARE other people to go
O no dont get me wrong if I could I would go back I feel that it's my duty as a service member. I also feel that her reasons are justified and yes there are other people that would love to go back with the way this economy is.
"The Army tries to look at the whole picture and they definitely don't want to do anything that jeopardizes the family or jeopardizes the children," O'Donnell said. "At the same time, these are individuals who made obligations and commitments to the country."
It's not really her fault. She did her time and was inactive reserve - that's what everyone is after they get discharged after their first term.
Shoot, even after more than your first term. You retire at 20 and you've still got 10 years IRR.
I was recalled 2 times. You are told and have the knowledge that you may/ may not have to return and that you have that 4 or 10 year mark of waiting what may occur. It is understood, especially since you do sign the line right below that statement. NO matter what the outcome prepare the backup plan. Even if you don't have to use it. I understand you do your time then your done. But you still have that IRR and are made aware when given your discharge papers. There is a line you sign acknowledging that you are fully aware that this may happen at any given time.
The Army not always cares about the whole picture, as many may want to believe. What they are doing is just to save face. Since she did go and broadcast that she was reporting with her kids. Come on.
If you ask me she planned it knowing that publicity would get her the attention needed to be discharged. She obviously did her research.
Who cares that she has kids, career, college or a business after getting out. The bottom line is she knew that she may be recalled. An IRR duty and completion of that said IRR if activated comes first no matter what goes on in your life. There are many others that do not have anyone for their kids and they have to report. This does happen a lot. more than people know.
What a nice example she is setting for her kids about fulfilling her prior commitments. (Knowing that you may be recalled and signing that you fully understand is a commitment.)
There are many dual family members. Most have one parent recalled and they just suit up and do their job.
I thought she had one child while still in the Army?
Maybe I'm wrong.
On one hand... I agree, she shouldn't have to go back there are many others that could go in her place.
On the other hand... she DID make a committment.... and she KNEW there was a possibility (though slim) that she would be recalled. It even stated in the article posted the other day that SHE realized she could get recalled but pushed it to the back of her mind. Denial sucks.
On the other hand... she DID make a committment.... and she KNEW there was a possibility (though slim) that she would be recalled. It even stated in the article posted the other day that SHE realized she could get recalled but pushed it to the back of her mind. Denial sucks.
Denial is a sucker punch!
I think there is a lot more to her story than she is allowing to get out. I have had MANY friends and family members who were recalled, and most were able to avoid having to go back into the service by going through the proper channels.
For people who enlisted after 9/11, one would have to be nuts not to realize that there is a GREAT possibility of being called back up. She did not technically "do her time" since all are obligated to the active duty time AND the IRR time if they are needed.
Think recruiters ever mention the possibility of IRR recalls to prospective recruits? Not on your life.
They may not get deep into it, but they do tell you about IRR. If someone can't figure out that means they might get recalled then they're stupid.
Think recruiters ever mention the possibility of IRR recalls to prospective recruits? Not on your life.
They are required to. When my husband was a recruiter, they had to spend time making sure that the applicants understood what that meant. I mean, of course, they will tell them that it doesn't happen often, and when you look at the numbers, it really doesn't happen often.