Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

9 year old boy pleads guilty to murder? What are your thoughts on this?

who's talking here?

MrsH 1
HappyMomma 5
Q♠ 1
JussAmomOf2 2
♀ KrYsTaL♀ 1
yankeegirl05 2
Boobsy McNiceass 2
Quickstudy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

A 9-year-old Arizona boy made up his own mind to plead guilty to a single charge of negligent homicide, the boy's attorney, Ron Wood, said in an interview with ABC's "Good Morning America" today. The boy had originally entered a plea of not guilty on charges of double homicide for allegedly shooting his father and another man, but the deal allowed him to plead guilty to one count of negligent murder of the other man. The boy's mother was reportedly against the deal and claimed her son was not old enough to understand the agreement. "He has to make the decision of how he wants to proceed," Wood told "GMA." "As long as we're going to continue to prosecute children, they're going to have to make that decision. ... That's what my young client wanted to do." According to Wood, Arizona Superior Court Judge Michael Roca determined that the boy was competent to make the decision and his plea was accepted. The prosecutors decided to drop the charge against the boy for killing his father so he would have a "chance at a normal life," Apache County Attorney Michael Whiting told The Associated Press Thursday. "How is he going to deal with 'I pleaded guilty to killing my dad?'" Whiting said. The plea deal allows the boy to undergo psychiatric evaluation with the possibility that he could avoid incarceration. In the deal with state prosecutors, two charges of premeditated murder in the death of the two men were dropped in exchange for the admission that the boy shot and killed his father's friend. In return, Whiting wants the boy to undergo extensive mental evaluation and treatment. The plea agreement says any detention will be at the discretion of the court. The boy will also undergo diagnostic evaluations and mental health examinations at 12, 15 and 17 years old. The reviews are intended partly to determine whether the boy will pose a continuing danger to others. "There has to be a determination made that there will not be any future danger," the boy's other defense attorney, Benjamin Brewer, told "GMA." Brewer said the boy would receive education, but if and when he joins other children in a classroom has yet to be determined. Source 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

I personally, don't think he should be allowed to plead guilty. I wonder if he underwent any evaluation so that they could know if he understood exactly what he was doing? 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

And, according to another article, the mother didn't have a legal say in the decision?? She's his guardian. 

JussAmomOf2 --- 17 years ago -

he's 9 yrs old...I think in MY EYES that he may not know what he was doing. I think that there is more to this story that they aren't disclosing. I'm sure we'll see where this goes in a few months when he undergoes all these tests. 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

If one of the other articles, that's linked on the source link, says that they asked him if he did it because he was mad at his dad. He said Hmm and then said he was in trouble most of the time at home. To me, it sounds like he didn't fully understand the consequences of his actions. 

MrsH --- 17 years ago -

I think a plea deal is best in that situation. Say he doesn't plead guilty and they charge him with both murders...then what? I mean the kid did KILL two ppl! He deserves to be punished. 

yankeegirl05 --- 17 years ago -

I mean the kid did KILL two ppl! He deserves to be punished. Yup, and being 9yrs old he understands what he did...he may not understand the plea deal and the legality of things but he does understand killing 2people!! 

♀ KrYsTaL♀ --- 17 years ago -

He's 9 yrs old. 9 yrs old these days is a lot ore grown up than it used to be. he knew what he was doing was wrong. he committed the crime so he should be punished. 

Boobsy McNiceass --- 17 years ago -

I'd like to know the back story on it first.... Why did he do it? Was it some sort of "hunting accident" or did he just come up and shoot them. And once he shot the first how did the 2nd not tackle his little arse. The prosecutors decided to drop the charge against the boy for killing his father so he would have a "chance at a normal life," The kid killed 2 people, I am guessing his life wasn't normal before and probably never will be.... 

JussAmomOf2 --- 17 years ago -

come on..is it really POSSIBLE for a 9YR OLD to FULLY understand WHAT he did and if he really knew what he did was WRONG??? 

Boobsy McNiceass --- 17 years ago -

come on..is it really POSSIBLE for a 9YR OLD to FULLY understand WHAT he did and if he really knew what he did was WRONG??? I think so... 

yankeegirl05 --- 17 years ago -

come on..is it really POSSIBLE for a 9YR OLD to FULLY understand WHAT he did and if he really knew what he did was WRONG??? I have a 9yr old nephew and I can tell you he knows when he does things wrong...He def. would know that killing a person is wrong!! 

HappyMomma --- 17 years ago -

This boy probably isn't a normal 9 year old. To say that he was in trouble a lot but can't answer if he's mad? And, I'd think that in order for him to plead to it, the mom would have to okay it. He's technically signing a contract, and he's not of legal age to sign one. 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

come on..is it really POSSIBLE for a 9YR OLD to FULLY understand WHAT he did and if he really knew what he did was WRONG??? I think kids know things are wrong, they just don't understand consequences or the permanance of their actions. There's a bunch of studies that show the part of the brain that understands these things and deal with decision making isn't fully developed at that age. 

Q♠ --- 17 years ago -

I would like to know what drove him to commit such a crime. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground