Little J came home from school crying today because one of the boys in her class threw her earrings out.
She took them out because they were bothering her, and put them on her desk. Apparently the boy took the earrings off her desk and took them up to the teacher and said he didn't know whose they were. The teacher then told him to throw them out.
These were a birthday present and not cheap earrings. Should I expect them to be replaced?
These were a birthday present and not cheap eaarings. Should I expect them to be replaced?
Heck yes the teacher should be the one to replace them and she should have asked the class to whom do they belong to. I'd be furious.
I was always told by my kids teachers that they recommend not letting kids wear any sort of jewelry. I doubt they'll be replaced. That sucks though. :(
The question would be who would replace them? The teacher is going off the basis that they're unknown earrings and that could be unsanitary to keep around so she was right to have him throw them away. Maybe you should talk to the boys parents and ask if the boy actually knew they were your daughters and he lied about not knowing whose they were.
How old are these children?
She shouldn't have thrown them out, but I doubt you can make her replace them. It would come down to the fact that your daughter shouldn't have left them on her desk unattended.
How old are these children?
3rd grade. 8-9 years old.
I'm waiting on a call back from her teacher to make sure it happened the way J said it did before I get upset.
Wow, that was pretty dumb IF the teacher indeed said that. I would call her or go by during her conference and find out what happened. Now dont get mad but maybe your daughter lost them and that's the story she's sticking to.
The teacher is going off the basis that they're unknown earrings and that could be unsanitary to keep around so she was right to have him throw them away.
The teacher sure as hell didn't have any right to tell that boy to throw them away. She should have asked the class first and foremost. IMO the teacher is at fault no matter that your daughter took them out and left them on her desk. Plus that boy shouldn't have messed with them in the first place.
just playing devil's advocate here, but is there any way that your daughter isn't telling the truth? Not the whole truth anyway? Like maybe she lost them, and doesn't want to fess up? Or that the boy took them, and then lied to her (her believing they are gone but truly aren't)? Have you spoken to the teacher yet? That would have been my very first phone call, as soon as I was told what happened.
That stinks but I think asking someone to replace them is a little harsh. After all they were her earrings and even though she did the right thing by leaving them on her desk it is a good life lesson that people are evil and take what is not theirs even when they know it isnt theirs. I agree the teacher should of asked the class whoes they were and then kept them in a lost and found box...why throw them out? I feel bad for Little J.
3rd grade. 8-9 years old.
I'm waiting on a call back from her teacher to make sure it happened the way J said it did before I get upset.
She sounds old enough to let the teacher know they were hers before ar even after the teacher threw them away
Sounds like there's a lot more to this story
Now dont get mad but maybe your daughter lost them and that's the story she's sticking to.
Which is why I'm waiting to talk to the teacher before I get upset.
This is why I buy cheap Claire's earrings for my girls.
I have one child that can't wear those though, she gets an infection from them. :( DH bought her nice diamonds when she was about 5 and of course they are lost. (I found that stupid to begin with though to buy a child that young diamonds)
MOST teachers would have asked who the earrings belonged to.
Yup seems kind of weird to me too.
dmc I'm waiting on a call back from the teacher right now.
Well it does suck that they were thrown out but she did take them off and leave them unattended. It's just as much her fault as anybody else's. I agree with the others that the teacher may have felt it was unsanitary to keep a pair of earrings around that he/she didn't know who they belonged to. It could have been a pair of socks and I still would have thrown them away. Sucks that it was something more valuable than socks the same principle still applies. I don't think it's the teachers fault. Maybe she did ask around and your daughter just didn't hear her or was paying attention to something else. I'm sure from now on she will take better care of her things and has learned a valuable lesson!
This is why I buy cheap Claire's earrings for my girls.
Some people can't wear cheap earrings though. I wasn't able to wear anything other than gold. I can't even wear silver or nickel or even plated earrings.
I have one child that can't wear those though, she gets an infection from them
J is like that too... and these were earrings from claire's. They were the earrings she got her ears pierced with initially. :(