Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Let's have an academic discussion, shall we?

who's talking here?

Jules 2
supercalifragilistic 1
Ella Mafayo 3
~Bea~ 1
Marie88 1
CupCake 1
Truth Offends 4
mssam2 3
Susie Homemaker 1
It's the Tikice Capades! 4
For Realz Yo 1
QuickBlubbersMcGee 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

This was last week's discussion question in my Minority Relations class. (In other words...I've already done the work and I'm not here to get you to provide me any answers! LOL!) I thought we could use some intelligent conversation in the midst of all this other crap. Keep in mind, when answering the question, the following definitions: Prejudice: thoughts or beliefs about a person based on his/her membership in a racial/ethnic/gender group (or thoughts / beliefs about an entire group) Discrimination: the act of denying rights / privileges to a person or group of people based on their membership in a racial/ethnic/gender group. Here's the question: Which of the following courses of action do you believe would be the most effective way to improve relations between groups: attempting to eliminate prejudice first in hopes that this will eliminate discrimination, or attempting to eliminate discrimination first in hopes that this will eliminate prejudice?  

CupCake --- 17 years ago -

Eliminate prejudice in hopes of getting rid of discrimination. 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

I'd say attempt to eliminate prejudice first in hopes that this will eliminate discrimination. 

It's the Tikice Capades! --- 17 years ago -

You'll never eliminate prejudice, so shoot for eliminating discrimination. 

Truth Offends --- 17 years ago -

Is it possible to eliminate prejudice though? They are thoughts and beliefs. How can you eliminate the way one thinks of believes regarding a specific race, gender, etc? 

supercalifragilistic --- 17 years ago -

I would say eliminate discrimination first. You can legislate actions, but you can not legislate beliefs. 

Truth Offends --- 17 years ago -

Great mind karma....great minds. *hands karma an MGD* 

Truth Offends --- 17 years ago -

Truth be told, I don't think anything can be done to eliminate either prejudice or discrimination. If you try to legislate actions, you're likely to breed more hate and resentment towards said group. And, as was said before, you can't legislate beliefs and thoughts. 

It's the Tikice Capades! --- 17 years ago -

*hands karma an MGD* Awesome! Thanks! **Opens humidor and offers Truth one of Rocky Patel's finest to go with the ice cold brewski** 

Truth Offends --- 17 years ago -

You people suck! No one else has an intelligent thought to share! Blaaaaah LOL Sorry J-amy, I tried.... 

mssam2 --- 17 years ago -

I think we just have to learn to understand what prejudice is. People are "pack" animals. We have our own groups, and now we are living in times where geographical location doesn't just mean that evryone will look the same. I think we automatically see someone different and feel something and we don't know what it is. I identify it with some primal "group" thing. Like "you aren't in my tribe". I don't know another way to explain it, lol. I think the media plays a huge, huge role in stereotypes. Like...all black people are good at basketball. Or good at singing. All white people suck at dancing. And like mayonaise...or something. People are people, and since we no longer live in a time where looks could tell you something about someone else (besides the obvious "he's charging at me with a knife")...the way of thinking has become obselete. If we understand that, we can work through it. At least, that's my take on it. 

~Bea~ --- 17 years ago -

Now where does ethnocentrism come into play? Do you think that leads to some prejudice? 

mssam2 --- 17 years ago -

Now where does ethnocentrism come into play? Do you think that leads to some prejudice? Yes. Even if it doesn't have anything to do with ethnicity...I think we are just geared to notice people different than ourselves. I think the media does too, maybe even more so. 

It's the Tikice Capades! --- 17 years ago -

People are "pack" animals. Nuh UH! Never heard of such... **Walks away whistling innocently** 

mssam2 --- 17 years ago -

**Walks away whistling innocently** Whenever people do that, I actually picture someone walking away whistling innocently. lol. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

I believe you need to get rid of prejudice first, and then discrimination. They go hand in hand. Without the prejudice, it might be harder to discriminate against. 

It's the Tikice Capades! --- 17 years ago -

Whenever people do that, I actually picture someone walking away whistling innocently. I actually did it. Got some weird looks from the guy down the hall, too. :p 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

My answer was that you make efforts to eliminate discrimination, which can (over time) lead to lessening of prejudicial attitudes. With enough exposure to others, in workplaces and schools and public places where it is illegal to discriminate, we begin to foster kinder thoughts about each other. It's actually been proven in many studies. As was already stated by someone else, you can't 'legislate' beliefs, but beliefs CAN be changed. Positive beliefs can be changed into negative ones by circumstances such as economic conflict. But the reverse can also be true...by spending enough time with people who hold a positive belief about a particular group, someone who is ambivalent or has mainly negative beliefs can be converted. Prejudice is a LEARNED, socially influenced trait. I'm not a Pollyanna about it...I don't think you can fully eliminate either one because, as someone else said, we're 'pack animals' deep down. We look for any way to establish dominance over each other and that's part of our programming. But as humans, I believe we are capable of suppressing those tendencies, whereas animals are NOT. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

Prejudice is a LEARNED, socially influenced trait. That's why I think that this needs to be gotten rid of first. As long as people are prejudiced, they will continue to discriminate against others. There might be laws against discrimination, but as long as people continue with prejudiced attitudes, there will always be varying degrees of discrimination - and they'll find loopholes and ways around doing so. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

What if it WEREN'T learned, though? I just read something else from Gordon Allport, famed psychologist, who suggested in his book The Nature of Prejudice (1954) that prejudice stems from natural human instincts. We learn by categorizing, and by generalizing our experiences we have 'reference' points stored for next time we encounter a situation. Therefore, although we use it in evil ways, what if the general tendency to have prejudice WAS indeed inborn? 

For Realz Yo --- 17 years ago -

My husband applied for college at Old Dominion and they told him he would most likely get in since he's a minority. He's full blooded redneck. 

QuickBlubbersMcGee --- 17 years ago -

attempting to eliminate prejudice first in hopes that this will eliminate discrimination, or attempting to eliminate discrimination first in hopes that this will eliminate prejudice? I'd say neither. Both are things that need to be eliminated by ones own personal behavior. 

Marie88 --- 17 years ago -

It's impossible to ever completely eliminate both. Progress can be made on both fronts, but you will never live in a world without prejudice or discrimination. It's in our nature. Yes, some prejudices and ways of thinking are learned. But the very basis of choosing/preferring/being comfortable around one group of people vs another, that's nature. It will never go away. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground