Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: generic drugs acetaminophen versus tylenol

who's talking here?

Someone 1
IMSleepngbty 3
Tera 2
morgan 4
not right 3
Sasha 4
Marie88 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: generic drugs acetaminophen versus tylenol

Do you think there is a BIG difference between generic acetaminophen and Name Brand Tylenol?

yes Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
no Vote
 
 86.4% (19)
only buy name brand Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
never thought about it Vote
 
 4.5% (1)
don't care Vote
 
 4.5% (1)
only use advil Vote
 
 4.5% (1)
morgan --- 17 years ago -

Do you think there is a BIG difference between generic acetaminophen and Name Brand Tylenol? 

Marie88 --- 17 years ago -

No. Acetaminophen IS the active ingredient in Tylenol. 

IMSleepngbty --- 17 years ago -

No. Acetaminophen IS the active ingredient in Tylenol.  

Sasha --- 17 years ago -

I think she means like store brand (GoodSense/Wal-Mart) acetaminophen and Tylenol. 

Marie88 --- 17 years ago -

I think she means like store brand (GoodSense/Wal-Mart) acetaminophen and Tylenol.  Acetaminophen is acetaminophen. As long as they're present in the same amounts, then one medicine is no better than the other. Unless you're looking to target specific symptoms, like pain relief AND decongestion or something. 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

I have always thought they worked the same way until last night. I was at a friends and she had name brand Tyl. I buy generic brand. I have been using it almost everyday for a knee pain. (gets worse when weather acts up) Last night my knee was acting up really bad, she gave me two of the name brand tyl. My pain went away for the first time ever taking acetaminophen. Today I take more because the ache is back. Only a tad of pain has left most of it is still here. Dh is going to the store to get me name brand tyl. Reason for the pole. 

not right --- 17 years ago -

was it the same strength? Just because one was name brand and one wasn't, doesn't mean they are the same strength. If you normally take regular, and she gave you extra strength, then of course it's going to work better. Too much Tylenol/acetaminophen isn't good for you. 

IMSleepngbty --- 17 years ago -

I have been using it almost everyday for a knee pain. (gets worse when weather acts up) That is not healthy. See your PCM What is the cause for knee pain? Surgery? People who take Tylenol (acetaminophen) and other medicines that contain acetaminophen are largely ignorant of the safe dosages, a new study has found, and unaware that an overdose can cause severe liver damage. Of 104 consecutive patients at a Michigan clinic, almost 80 percent reported using acetaminophen in the previous six months, but about 63 percent were unsure whether they had been told about the dangers of high doses, and only 43 percent knew that the medicine could affect liver function. The survey results appear in the January/February issue of The Journal of the American Pharmacists Association. The maximum daily dose of acetaminophen is four grams a day — 12 regular 325-milligram Tylenol tablets or 8 500-milligram extra-strength tablets. Recommended doses are lower for people with known risk factors, like heavy drinking or liver disease. Studies cited in the article report that overdoses of acetaminophen are the most common cause of acute liver failure in the United States. Although reactions vary widely, large overdoses can be fatal. Keeping in mind that taking Tylenol (acetaminophen ) daily causes irreversible Liver damage. That is why I asked about the cause of knee pain. There's some evidence of liver toxicity of acetaminophen even at normal doses. Although acetaminophen may be used for extended periods, any use beyond a week or two should be discussed with your physician or practitioner. There are two reasons for this advice. First, you may have a serious, chronic condition that requires treatment with measures other than, or in addition to, acetaminophen. Think about it -- if you need acetaminophen every day for a long time, it is time to ask the reason why, and if possible, address the cause. Second, acetaminophen -- and many other drugs -- have two distinct toxicities. The first is acute toxicity, which is poisoning resulting from an overdose. Taking 3 or 4 grams of acetaminophen (and sometimes considerably less) in one day produces acute toxicity. The other toxicity is chronic toxicity. This is the kind of toxicity that results from long term exposure to a substance in quantities too small to produce immediate poisoning, but large enough to alter the normal physiology of the human organism. Acetaminophen is thought to have chronic toxicity as well as acute toxicity. There must be a good reason, therefore, to take acetaminophen for long periods of time. This should be discused with a health professional! Tylenol should be taken in daily doses LESS than 3-4 grams per day (2 extra strength 500 mg every 6 hours at most). Higher doses, especially combined with alcohol, or in people with underlying liver disease, can cause irreversible liver damage and death. However, in addition to causing liver damage, it can also cause peptic ulcer, nephropathy (rarely). Tylenol (Acetaminophen in the US = Paracetamol in the UK) inhibits the formation of prostaglandins, which play an important roe in inflammation (and pain.) By inhibiting prostaglandins, inflammation is subdued but since prostaglandins are also involved in 'housekeeping' functions of our bodies, they suffer. Gastric/duodenal ulcers, analgesic induced nephropathy (kidney disease) occur as a result. 

Someone --- 17 years ago -

I use IBprofin (sp?) 

Sasha --- 17 years ago -

I use IBprofin (sp?) Not the same properties but I prefer ibuprofen over aspirin too. 

IMSleepngbty --- 17 years ago -

Ibuprofen is a blood thinner the same as aspirin and you also need to be careful in taking it. If you have to choose take Tylenol. If you have or don't have any kind of health issues you should take Tylenol on an occasional basis. It is better than Ibuprofen and aspirin. (Also if you overdose it is easier to fix) Never take aspirin without asking your doctor first. In the case of an accident if you have been taking either of the two drugs you can bleed more freely and or bleed out. 

Sasha --- 17 years ago -

Aspirin doesn’t make your blood thinner, but it does prevent the platelets from being as ‘sticky’ so they don’t ‘clump’ together as much, hence lessens the chance of clots. This is something to be very careful about. Suicide by Tylenol can be the nastiest thing and one of the slowest and painful deaths or period of time until you get ‘cleaned out’. Aweful damage to your liver, there are better (sure things) ways to 'off yourself'. (sorry for the crudeness) 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

That is not healthy. See your PCM What is the cause for knee pain? Surgery? Yes I know it is not healthy. I only take 2 pills a day and those are the 500 ones. Cause of knee pain - I AM OLD!!!!!!. The doctor told me the only thing I could hope for is a transplant. Me into a younger body. haha 

Tera --- 17 years ago -

I have a blood clotting disorder and I take blood thinner shots everyday which intern prevents me from taking most of that stuff. The only thing the Doc lets me take is name brand Tylenol. I do think it works better then generic. Most of the time the main ingredient is one of the only things that is the same. 

Sasha --- 17 years ago -

You have a medical bracelet alerting EMS of this correct? 

not right --- 17 years ago -

morgan, have you ever tried Aleve? 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

morgan, have you ever tried Aleve? Yes, but to me it does not work. Now any narcs from docs work great. I don't want that route. The generic covers the most of it, but that name brand fast acting took the pain away completely. Maybe because it was the fast acting kind which has a different medium for delivery. I bet that is the reason.... 

not right --- 17 years ago -

Maybe because it was the fast acting kind which has a different medium for delivery. I bet that is the reason.... that really could be the reason. My PCM gave me napraxon (sp generic Aleve). It works pretty well for my knee pain. Dh got it for some wrist swelling and pain, and it worked great for him. 

Tera --- 17 years ago -

Yes Sasha I do, however Im not on coumadin that is the one that they worry about the most. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground