Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: I forgot to ask........

who's talking here?

Chelle 5
3Kleebs 4
Jill ♥ 1
KΛΤIΞ♥™ 5
SAonaSM 1
♥ 1
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 1
FarmerA 3
~*Jolene*~ 1
**GO Yanks** 2
LovinLilA 1
~*LM*~ 6
Muse Heather 12
Ella Mafayo 1
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 1
?DLsMommy? 2
silverlightstar 1
dbal 1
MsSam 4
(jen′i fər) 1
billiejean Doop 2
Mermaid 2
*lovinMyfamily* 1
☆T.T.☆ 1
Delfine 2
~Bea~ 14
Marie88 1
mom2za 1
CupCake 5
Tikcuf 1
Patti the Tupperware lady. :-) 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: I forgot to ask........

so, yesterday morning I was talking with one of my kids at work and we were talking about babies and one convo led to another and she said "well, I know if I ever found out my kid was going to be mentally handicap I would abort it." (I lost a lot respect for her) and I asked her why and she said "thats no way to live your life, they must be so unhappy" I asked if she's ever spent anytime with anyone that is mentally handicap and she said "no" which goes to show her ignorance...but here's my question if you found out your child would have a mental or physical disability and you were able to terminate, would you?

yes Vote
 
 20.0% (14)
no Vote
 
 50.0% (35)
it depends on what it is (give an example) Vote
 
 30.0% (21)
Chelle --- 18 years ago -

so, yesterday morning I was talking with one of my kids at work and we were talking about babies and one convo led to another and she said "well, I know if I ever found out my kid was going to be mentally handicap I would abort it." (I lost a lot respect for her) and I asked her why and she said "thats no way to live your life, they must be so unhappy" I asked if she's ever spent anytime with anyone that is mentally handicap and she said "no" which goes to show her ignorance...but here's my question if you found out your child would have a mental or physical disability and you were able to terminate, would you? 

♥ --- 18 years ago -

I voted yes. 

FarmerA --- 18 years ago -

I voted it depends.... how olf was this "kid" 

Mermaid --- 18 years ago -

I voted it would depend. If the child was going to live a short life filled with pain and a lot of surgeries, I might abort. Something like Tay-Sachs. Mentally handicapped, like Downs.. no. Any of our children are simply a fall or car accident away from possibly having a physically or mentally disabled child. 

Chelle --- 18 years ago -

Oh, I'm sorry, I ment "baby/fetus" 

**GO Yanks** --- 18 years ago -

I agree with Mermaid, it would depend on what the baby was gonna have. 

Chelle --- 18 years ago -

Autism/Downs/Band Syndrome/ cerebral palsy 

**GO Yanks** --- 18 years ago -

Autism/Downs/Band Syndrome/ cerebral palsy if it is a mental handicap like that then no I wouldnt abort, only if it was something seriously life threatening or painful like Mermaid was saying. 

Delfine --- 18 years ago -

No, children are a gift and even the handicap can teach you valuable life lessons. 

Jill ♥ --- 18 years ago -

No, in fact I wouldn't even get an amnio when this baby had markers for downs because of the risk of miscarriage. The only reason we did the AFP test was so that if something came up we could be prepared. 

Chelle --- 18 years ago -

Ok, then is it just me that I thought her comment was ignorant then? The way I took it was all handicaps and they would be unhappy. I asked her when was the last time she heard a kid with Downs commit suicide....idk, I guess I'm just sensitive on the subject because I've cared for the mentally handicap and I used to nanny for a little guy with band syndrome....*sigh* I also had a foster sister with severe Autism....I just don't think I would. I know my life would be more difficult, but... I just don't think I could do it... 

FarmerA --- 18 years ago -

once again how old was this "kid" 

Chelle --- 18 years ago -

once again how old was this "kid" lol, oh, you mean my "kid" she's one of my associates and she is 22 

FarmerA --- 18 years ago -

ohh 22....well maybe shes immature? 

billiejean Doop --- 18 years ago -

Absolutely never. I declined the testing/screening all four times. 

Delfine --- 18 years ago -

Wow, I am 22 and I do believe her comment was ignorant. Like you I also took care of handicap children, I volunteered to do it, from severe state to mild. I learned a lot from them, I voted No. 

KΛΤIΞ♥™ --- 18 years ago -

Yes, but depends on how bad it is. BUT, I only say this because of a personal reason. And, I am not sure I want to tell anoyone on here. Only my close friends know. 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 18 years ago -

I agree with Mermaid. 

☆T.T.☆ --- 18 years ago -

I agree... mentally handicap no but something painful etc. it would kill me but I might 

Tikcuf --- 18 years ago -

I want to preface my answer by saying I realize my opinion is largely hypothetical because ultimately it's the mother's decision whether or not to terminate a pregnancy. I do feel the father's opinion should be heard and taken into consideration. Any decision in a marriage should be bilateral, including about children. Again, I know the final say IS the mother's in this case. I wouldn't even have the test done, therefore I wouldn't be in that position to decide. The reason I wouldn't have the testing done and don't want to be in the position to make a decison/form an opinion is because I know I'm not strong enough to handle having a child with a mental handicap. I've known and seen a lot of parents with special needs children, and I know what they go through. I don't think I could do it. So, if it were ever to happen, I guess I'd just have to suck it up and handle it, because I wouldn't know in advance. 

MsSam --- 18 years ago -

I don't know because I haven't been in that situation. That's like asking me who I'd save if I could only save one person in my family in a fire or something. Who can know that stuff before it happens to them? 

MsSam --- 18 years ago -

I wouldn't even have the test done, therefore I wouldn't be in that position to decide. I never did with my second, I had the first ultrasound and gd test and declined all others. 

~Bea~ --- 18 years ago -

because of my age, the first ob i saw at ft sam asked me that question before having amnio and other tests done. since i said i wouldn't terminate my pregnancy no matter what, we didnt do testing. 

CupCake --- 18 years ago -

I voted YES, because I can. :) 

silverlightstar --- 18 years ago -

I thought her comment was very ignorant, Chelle. For the record, I voted no. 

KΛΤIΞ♥™ --- 18 years ago -

Can I say, without it becoming an argument, because I elove all of you, I think her comment was NOT ignorant!! There are reasons people terminate pregnancies...... if it was a disability that can be handled, then I would never ever terminate the pregnancy, BUT in some cases, it is better to terminate it. Why would you want someone to come into the word that couldn't function AT ALL, that would live in pain? 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

I say yes. I would definitely terminate. Even if it was 'only' Downs Syndrome. I know people with handicaps are happy and what not, but I wouldn't be. I'd rather just terminate and try again. 

~Bea~ --- 18 years ago -

if it was a disability that can be handled, then I would never ever terminate the pregnancy, BUT in some cases, it is better to terminate it. Why would you want someone to come into the word that couldn't function AT ALL, that would live in pain? God has reasons for letting these children live. :-) 

Muse Heather --- 18 years ago -

God has reasons for letting these children live. :-) Operating under that assumption, he would have a reason for them to die as well. 

CupCake --- 18 years ago -

God has reasons for letting these children live. :-) He doesn't when you don't believe in him... 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground