Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: spinoff of spanking thread

who's talking here?

Chelle 2
Ellie May 1
*~LittleMissPerfect~* 7
Boomer 1
♥ cjpzjmom ♥ 2
j2as=amaya 1
*SaSiCaSsI* 3
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 2
~*Jolene*~ 1
Brandy 3
Sunshine 2
MsSam 2
M&M 2
*Michelle Lynnette* 1
billiejean Doop 1
SeriouslyInaneBabble 1
♠ Manson's Mistress 3
wifemommyme 2
*MustangSallie* 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: spinoff of spanking thread

After having this conversation for the last two days...I got curious. How many people spank/swat your children as a form of discipline. Doesn't have to be your main form...I am just curious to see the ratio of people who agree and don't agree.

Okay with swatting or spanking Vote
 
 93.3% (42)
Never spank as punishment Vote
 
 6.7% (3)
Sunshine --- 18 years ago -

After having this conversation for the last two days...I got curious. How many people spank/swat your children as a form of discipline. Doesn't have to be your main form...I am just curious to see the ratio of people who agree and don't agree. 

Sunshine --- 18 years ago -

I will be the first to say I am okay with a swat on the rear 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

Nope nope nope. Not saying that anyone who does is wrong, it's just not my style of parenting. I do not and will not use physical force on my child. 

~*Jolene*~ --- 18 years ago -

I will swat on the butt. Pretty much just my youngest. My oldest never really gets in trouble. 

billiejean Doop --- 18 years ago -

I'm thinking about swatting one right now. When does school start?? lol 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 18 years ago -

When does school start?? lol Not soon enough! LOL 

j2as=amaya --- 18 years ago -

I'm in between personally. I was swatting her behind and such, but since doing the daycare I'm not ALLOWED to even spank my own child during daycare hours. SOOOO..I had to come up with a different form of discipline. It's been working quite well these last couple of months (so was swatting...) We will still spank her (outside daycare hrs) if need be..but so far it's fine with the other form I have chosen to use on her. I would NEVER swat/smack her on the mouth or ear or any other part besides the behind. 

wifemommyme --- 18 years ago -

my kids have to do something very horrible for me to spank them! My 5 year old son has been spanked by me maybe a total of 5 or 6 times his entire life. I was spanked as a child and my stepdad did it and i got spanked so hard one time i had bruises on my butt and couldn't sit down...from that time on i swore i'd only spank my child for something extremely horrible 

♠ Manson's Mistress --- 18 years ago -

Discipline does not = abuse. And people wonder why todays society is the way it is now... kids can get away with murder. 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

Discipline does not = abuse. And people wonder why todays society is the way it is now... kids can get away with murder. Many people out in public that I have seen, spank out of frustration and anger. They always fall back on, the "discipline" excuse. I know some parents do truly reserve the spankings for actual disciplinary action,and that is fine if that is their parenting style, but more often than not "spanking" is taken advantage of by frustrated parents. 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

JMO of course... 

*SaSiCaSsI* --- 18 years ago -

My son has been spanked maybe 5 times in a year he has to be really disrespectfull and bad to get one and its never from me Hubby does it but both my kids get swatted when its called for But I also let them throw fits its a normal part of their devolpment to get upset show anger and frustration and then get over it when they do throw fits they arent emabrassing me they are embarassing themselves and I make sure they know that 

Boomer --- 18 years ago -

we try and reserve the spankings for severe situations, like running out in the road or in the parking lot, or things of a mokre drastic nature, and not "ignore" bad behavior, but pay it less attention as to not promote the bad behavior 

Chelle --- 18 years ago -

my stepdad did it and i got spanked so hard one time i had bruises on my butt and couldn't sit down... thats abuse. 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

But I also let them throw fits its a normal part of their devolpment to get upset show anger and frustration and then get over it when they do throw fits they arent emabrassing me they are embarassing themselves and I make sure they know that Well said. 

*SaSiCaSsI* --- 18 years ago -

Thank you 

Brandy --- 18 years ago -

I will do a pop on the hand or very rarely a single pop on the butt. My kids mostly get in trouble for hitting each other so I cant hit them for hitting each other, it doesnt add up. I use time out and take away things that mean the most like her barbie DVD's and lovies. My son gets pops on the hand for touching things he shouldnt, just to get his attention. but if he hits his sister he says sorry, gives her a hug and sometimes goes to time out but Im not sure he fully understand the time out thing yet. I did spank my daughter when she was 2-3, I regret it now because I see her hitting her brother when she gets mad or he does something she knows he shouldnt, I really want to kick myself for it. 

Chelle --- 18 years ago -

I think the worst form of punishment is embarassment. I know if I was in danger of being embarassed I would start behaving pretty quickly. 

wifemommyme --- 18 years ago -

my stepdad did it and i got spanked so hard one time i had bruises on my butt and couldn't sit down... thats abuse. oh i know that. But we use other forms of discipline. Ie standing in the corner, seperate rooms, no toys, no outside etc and it always works 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

My mom made me watch the weather channel as punishment. I would cry like I was being murdered hahaha. 

♠ Manson's Mistress --- 18 years ago -

I've never gotten "beat" by my parents. I remember spankings, but they were rare because we would know better than to do it again. Well, I did anyways, my brother was more the rebel in any case. My moms parents would have her go pick out her own stick growing up!!!! If you did that today, who knows what your neighbor to the left and right might do! I think it's absolutely ridiculous! Anytime someone Spanks their child there is frustration and anger behind it. That is inevitable if you ask me, but there is a difference between the child doing something to deserve a spanking, and a child getting spanked for no reason. 

*SaSiCaSsI* --- 18 years ago -

regret it now because I see her hitting her brother when she gets mad We always take time to calm ourselves down before we spank them that way they know we arent doing it out of anger but because they werent behaving and we tell them that so they can understand 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

Anytime someone Spanks their child there is frustration and anger behind it. No that is not true. I have seen a couple spank their child bc he/she kept going to a light socket, or the stairs or whatever, and would have gotten hurt if they didn't stop repeating a dangerous action. There was no anger, frustration involved. My neighbor's mom would make her pick a switch when I was little. I would cry when her mom made her go do that, it was like a horror movie. 

*Michelle Lynnette* --- 18 years ago -

I spank. period. 

M&M --- 18 years ago -

My two are teenagers now but they got spanked when they needed it, which luckily was not very often. It was only with our open hand and on the butt, NEVER anywhere else. Now my SIL has never spanked, she grew up in a very ABUSIVE home. But let me tell you she has the psychilogical game down pat,, she can play her kids like a fine tuned piano. I have NEVER seen anyone come even close to what she does. 

♠ Manson's Mistress --- 18 years ago -

I have seen a couple spank their child bc he/she kept going to a light socket, or the stairs or whatever, and would have gotten hurt if they didn't stop repeating a dangerous action How do you know there wasn't the slightest bit of frustration behind it... I'm not in any way trying to be mean with this, but you don't know what they were feeling on the inside even if they appeared to be calm on the outside. =) JMO 

M&M --- 18 years ago -

I did spank my daughter when she was 2-3, I regret it now because I see her hitting her brother when she gets mad or he does something she knows he shouldnt, I really want to kick myself for it. Honey that is not from spanking,,, that is just kids being kids. I have seen kids that have NEVER been spanked hit eachother for the use of a toy. It is part of thier personal development. NOT because you spanked her for playing with the outlet. 

Brandy --- 18 years ago -

Ive never seen a parent spank because they were happy. of course its out of anger or frustration. not all parents will show it but Im sure children will associate spanking with anger reguardless. 

♥ cjpzjmom ♥ --- 18 years ago -

I think the trick is to teach your children discipline when they are very young. By the time my kids were 3 or 4, they knew what was expected of them. I rarely have to get onto my older kids. My two year old is another story. LOL He is giving us a run for our money. 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 18 years ago -

How do you know there wasn't the slightest bit of frustration behind it... I'm not in any way trying to be mean with this, but you don't know what they were feeling on the inside even if they appeared to be calm on the outside. =) JMO They weren't angry they were afraid their child was going to get hurt. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground