Yes, absolutely. I think if you keep pumping out babies born addicted because you can't find birth control, then you ahould be mandatorily sterilized. Most of the time, someone else raises the child, so why should this person keep reproducing?
I'm the first person to argue against culling freedoms from citizens of a free nation, but...
In cases of severe criminals...convicted child rapists or other extreme sexual offenders...yes. Unlike drug addictions or food addictions, the compulsion to commit sexual assualt cannot be eradicated with 'treatment.'
Not sure where to draw an acceptable line with 'chronically institutionalized.' If you're talking about those so severely mentally retarded or otherwise incapacitated that they can never live an independent life outside an institution, I'd have to ask 'what's the point?' Not many people in this severe condition are having sex, as far as I know. (I could always be wrong...)
That's a tricky one....there are lots of conditions pertaining to individuals and I don't think you can make a blanket statement for any category of institutionalization or criminality.
I think so. They aren't giving the babies a fair chance at life, they shouldn't be allowed to keep on doing that. I also think they should be prosecuted if they bring a crack baby into the world. For negligence at least.
Throw their azzes in prison and they can't get pregnant. Giving birth to a crack baby is attempted murder in my opinion. No different than if you gave crack to a child that is born!
'chronically institutionalized.'
I mean people who are constantly in/out of mental facilities throughtout their lives. Not terminally institutionalized, which means they are there without getting out. Goes for prison too.
I guess I should point out that I don't think mentally disabled folks should be sterilized unless they've shown they cannot take care of the kids they already have. I don't think sterilizing a child molester will solve the problem.
I don't think sterilizing a child molester will solve the problem.
Since they wont kill child molesters I think they should all be sent to a deserted island somewhere and never be allowed to leave!
I mean people who are constantly in/out of mental facilities throughtout their lives.
That's where it gets touchy. I mean, a person who can't help their mental status is still a free citizen of this country and therefore still has all the rights and privileges that you and I have. After a crime, it's a different story (in my opinion), but I'd have to argue that even the mentally unstable have the right to reproduce. They SHOULDN'T, but I don't believe the gov't should get to decided that for them. Yes, it strains social services in our society...but that's the catch when you have a free society.
I mean people who are constantly in/out of mental facilities throughtout their lives.
I took her statement to mean chronic drug abusers, not the mentally ill, as your describing.
I don't think sterilizing a child molester will solve the problem.
I'll have to go look it up before I run my mouth, but it seems to me that I've heard that castrating (not just giving a vasectomy but removing the testicles) removes the element of the testosterone and therefore the sexual urge. I've heard of remorseful criminals who say they can't control themselves VOLUNTEERING for it. But let me go find some proof before I go further with the argument. :-)
I am agreeing with Capt S.H.I.T.'s Wife as well. I do believe in it for punishment for repeat sex offenders. I will wait for her to do the research, but I also believe I read somewhere that there is a procedure that can remove or hinder the sexual urge.
My dumba$$ cousin married a guy that had just got out of prison for molesting a child. She got pregnant almost immediately. The State told her that as soon as the baby came she would either have to leave him or give the child to her parents. She gave Kelly to her mom. 3 weeks later, the guy had a heart attack and died. She continued to date guys that just got relaesed from prison and her daughter still lives with her mom.
I'd have to argue that even the mentally unstable have the right to reproduce.
I suppose, that in a society that views reproducing as a right, that is a good point.
Ok, what I've read so far is that there's a half-n-half split about the effectiveness of castrating to prevent molestation / rape. Most popular modern way is Depo-Provera shots for offenders being released from prison. Eurpopean studies show it to be VERY EFFECTIVE, but U.S. studies are not so definitive.
Chemical castration
I just really have a hard time believeing it's all hormonal. I think the urge is there regardless.
That's the argument from some of the anti-castration circles...that rape is not a sexual crime, psychologically, and therefore removing sexual urges and hormones has nothing to do with preventing rape. Rape is a power crime, they say, (and I believe this), and aside from the fact you use your sex organs to commit it, it isn't about satisfying a sexual urge.
It'd make a good research paper, but I just finished a 16 page paper this weekend and have no desire to go at it again! LOL!