If a Law was passed allowing payment for human organs, what would you donate to a stranger, if anything, and how much would you charge?
And one more question: Do you think less people would die each year if your organs had a price tag?
Honestly it would have a real downside because A) who is to say that one person deserves to live more than another simply because they can afford to buy something and B) How many people would be dying in back alley clinics trying to get money for their organs
And one more question: Do you think less people would die each year if your organs had a price tag?
Yes/ I agree there would be less to die if you placed a price on it.
How many people would be dying in back alley clinics trying to get money for their organs
I don't see them going to back alley places if they are getting paid for it. But who knows.
Yes/ I agree there would be less to die if you placed a price on it.
It would save those who need the organ (possibly) but what about the people who donate? What if its a poor person who sells say, a kidney, to get money for thier family but then has complications & no health insurance? Whats the follow up on the doner side?
Not trying to argue with you - just devils advocate :)
I would sell an ovary and S would sell a nut. I don't know that less people will die. I think there will always be a shortage of organs. But I think the black market organ trade would increase.
A) who is to say that one person deserves to live more than another simply because they can afford to buy something
who is to say who lives or dies for any reason? lots of people do it everyday, whether get paid for it wouldn't make a difference.
Honestly it would have a real downside because A) who is to say that one person deserves to live more than another simply because they can afford to buy something and B) How many people would be dying in back alley clinics trying to get money for their organs
no, no, back alley clinics would be illegal. I mean if a law was passed, meaning, they could get it taken care of at a hospital.
And you're right about people not having the money to buy an organ but they end up dying anyways because not enough donors.
Maybe, they shoud have a charity for organ recipients, huh?
I would sell an ovary and S would sell a nut.
I know you can get 50,000 for a nut. lOL kid you not.
Not trying to argue with you - just devils advocate :)
I like devils advocate, sometimes I do that myself.
who is to say who lives or dies for any reason? lots of people do it everyday, whether get paid for it wouldn't make a difference.
Lots of people do what?
It would def make a difference if they were available to buy..2 people both need a kidney (its my fav organ..lol) one cant afford to buy one - gets put on a waiting list ends up dying- the other has the money & is able to buy one & lives- if it was my loved one who died I would see the difference!
My husband heard it was more than 50k, because he seriously wanted to do it. Fortunately he hasn't talked about it in a little while, maybe he forgot? lol
Now you make it if you donate a organ with out having a choice who it goes to and say///// you don't have to pay taxes for the rest of your life?? I am there in a sec.
My husband heard it was more than 50k, because he seriously wanted to do it. Fortunately he hasn't talked about it in a little while, maybe he forgot? lol
Mine thought about it. LOL But really do you think a man is going to let anything sharp near his balls? I don't think so.
Are you talking about a living person giving up organs? How many organs can be given up for a living person anyways? I know I want my organs donated when I die. What on earth can I use with them? Unfortunately some will have to go to labs, not people. For example I have a heart defect so it wouldn't be able to help anyone.
I think you can volunteer to be a bone marrow donor..I had a friend who went in to donate for a family member but didnt match. She was asked if she could be 'left in the system' for being a possible match for someone else
Lots of people do what?
Decide who dies. Juries, pregnant women, people at war (not just us, everywhere), doctors who decide who get an organ. Lots of people make that decision everyday.