I'm asking this question with the caveat that I do not support or denounce any particular candidate. This issue DOES have to do with the beliefs of one of the Democratic candidates, yes, but I'm not asking this in an attempt to defend him / her personally. What I intended here was a discussion that does not include rallying for or denunciation of anyone specifically.
The question is....why is it considered politically unacceptable to want to sit down and talk with those who we consider 'enemies' of the US? One particular candidate is running on a platform of reaching out to those with whom we have disagreements with and sitting down to talk and try to reach an understanding. This is being bandied about by opposing candidates and a lot of the news media as a bad idea...and I just don't see why.
Current policy either just flat out says 'no, we won't talk to you' or it lays out all sorts of bossy pre-conditions that create a stalemate before anyone even gets out their calendar to set a date. How is being obstinate and holier-than-thou a good way to reach out to someone?
Yes, certain leaders in this world are complete shytbags. But perhaps a lot of their attitude is fostered by this big BULLY attitude coming from American gov't? Perhaps if a leader were to say 'ok, we'll come to the table, as equals,' some sort of progress might be made?
Think of it this way...you're in a fight with a neighbor. Your neighbor says, "I'm willing to talk about ways to solve this problem." "You say, me too, but we're going to do this MY way or no way at all...first you have to paint your house blue before I'll even set foot on your porch. Then you have to plant this certain flower in your flowerbed. And there's no way in h*ll I'll talk to you unless you switch your toilet paper brand to Cottonelle and you make everyone in your family shave their hair into a mohawk."
Your neighbor's going to tell you to go f*ck yourself, right? Isn't this sort of the same thing as our American diplomatic policy right now? You can't go bossing people around, telling them you don't like the way they run the show but then refusing to sit and work things out unless they do everything YOUR way.
So, without saying "I like this or that candidate," tell me...what's wrong with the idea that leaders should make attempts to break stalemates by maybe giving an inch. Isn't that what good diplomacy and negotiations are all about? It can't possibly fail any more than current policies, right?
(And let's take things like personal security out of the equation, and assume that meetings like this would happen on neutral territory where everyone is completely safe from harm. That's a given we don't need to waste time on.)
I don't think it is a bad idea. I think negotiation is different than talking and uh... OMG I'm losing my mind... where each gives a little.
Oh forget it... LOL maybe I'm not quite with it today for this discussion.
I don't see a problem with it at all. I fully support it, actually, and think that this kind of willingness to talk could do wonders for our international relationships/reputation.
OMG I'm losing my mind... where each gives a little.
compromise? hehe, i HATE losing words! i'll be in the middle of a rant, and completely lose a simple noun.....
This question has been burning in my brain for several weeks now.
I think we are too arrogant for our own good, and it will be our downfall.
My favorite quote of all time -
America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we falter and lose and freedoms, it will be because we destroyed ourselves. Lincoln
It would be in our best interest to have a serious heart to heart with our enemies - with no expectations and no demands.
Although, I'm thinking Amy wanted a more "maure" response!!!
I read that and my infintile mind automaticly made it manure. And thats pretty much what our current regime has been tossing around.
why is it considered politically unacceptable to want to sit down and talk with those who we consider 'enemies' of the US?
If your 'enemy' is trying or threatening to kill you, how can you talk to them? Daniel Pearl had hurt no one, but his 'enemies', cut off his head...Daniel just happened to be Jewish...The only thing that 'killers' understand is a ballbat...you need to swing at them first, and knock them out, before they pitch to you...
If your 'enemy' is trying or threatening to kill you, how can you talk to them? Daniel Pearl had hurt no one, but his 'enemies', cut off his head...Daniel just happened to be Jewish...The only thing that 'killers' understand is a ballbat...you need to swing at them first, and knock them out, before they pitch to you...
I can see where you are coming from...it's hard to reason with a people who do not care if they die, or anyone else they care about!
I can see where you are coming from...it's hard to reason with a people who do not care if they die, or anyone else they care about!
Some people blame a woman who is dressed 'scantily clad' as the reason she got raped...If only the cookie jar hadn't been full, the kid wouldn't have taken one....LAME excuses...