Hmmm... well... I don't disagree with a polygamist lifestyle. And I have to admit I haven't been keeping up with the entire story, but if there was ANY kind of abuse going on... I'm glad they got the kids out of there.
Its hard for me to comment on such, I lived in a situation similar to theres when I was little. I feel for them. It takes a lot of rehabilitation to make them and their mothers unafraid of the outside world.
Seriously, their lifestyle says that it's OK for young children to be in arranged marriages and raped (since a child can't give consent) by old men.
They hide behind their religious beliefs as justification for their actions.
I don't disagree with polygamy either when it involves consenting ADULTS.
Not 13 year old children forced to bear children for eldery men.
Jules I completely agree... that's why I said the child abuse thing. Because IMO, what you stated IS child abuse. I've known many trios that are polygamists, and function very well as a family. But they also aren't trying to marry off their children to the highest... or *ahem* oldest perv.
I think its disgusting that irls as young as 12 are pregnant by their fathers. They use their religious beliefs as a crutch and to justify the rape of young children. I don't have roblem with their religion per se. I do have a problem when a child is made to practice it.
I read an article the other day saying that authorities are investigating the possibility that the initial call by a teenager named "Sarah", the one that prompted the whole search, may have been made by a 33-year-old woman in Colorado named Rozita Swinton. They don't know as of yet what her connection may be to the ranch but it does make you wonder.
don't disagree with polygamy either when it involves consenting ADULTS.
Not 13 year old children forced to bear children for eldery men
I agree completely with this. Freedom of religion is a good thing-but these are children who are either being told to lie or they really do not know who their biological parents are. The fact that they are doing DNA testing on these children to determine paternity, and fathers are not stepping up.. I have a problem with that.
Ick. Does that mean the mothers of these children had multiple partners and THAT is why the fathers are not stepping up, because they actually do NOT know who fathered the children? Ick
Seriously, I would guess it's because they (the old men) don't want to be charged with raping children.
The Texas has a HUGE mess to clean up with this one.
Shadow, whoever it was, bravo to them!
Absolutely...it will be interesting to find out more about her and what her story is...was she once a part of the ranch, etc. Although, the article went on to say that this woman has been arrested before for making false police reports.
The plot thickens...
It's quite disturbing. I watched interviews of them yesterday and they are extremely evasive when it comes to questions of money, rape and marriages of children. They also said there is no rhyme or reason why they all wear their hair the same either.... RIIIIGHT! It's because their brainwashed into submission, and whoever their "leader" is think their big up-do, boofont lookin, thigs are sexy, and "the way a woman should look".
I don't agree with that lifestyle at all. It's horrible to hear about. And what those children went through. Kinda makes your little trivial worries seem kinda small. I"m glad someone called and that the authorities stepped in.
JaneDoe, I don't think their dress/hair has anything to do with being sexy, at least not by our society's definition.
From what I understand, they aren't even allowed to be undressed fully when they procreate.
I think it's all about submission, domination, and control.
Dress code
All members of the church are required to abide by a strict dress code. In general, women are forbidden to cut their hair or to wear makeup, trousers or any skirt above the knees. Men are usually seen wearing plain clothing, usually a collared shirt and trousers. Men and women do not have any tattoos or body piercings. Women and girls usually wear solid-color homemade long-sleeved dresses, between ankle and mid-calf, and long stockings, keeping their hair coiffed.[41]
Birth defects
The Colorado City/Hildale area has the world's highest incidence of fumarase deficiency,[53] an extremely rare genetic condition which causes severe mental retardation. Geneticists attribute this to the prevalence of cousin marriage between descendants of two of the town's founders, Joseph Smith Jessup and John Yeates Barlow; one local historian reports that 7580 percent of the double-communities' roughly 10,000 inhabitants are descended from one or both of these men[citation needed]
The ranch I grew up on is still there. I'm not going to say what goes on there is perfect but its nothing like this compound. But its still bad now that I look back at it. I guess I am sort of brainwashed from it in a sense. I still have my clothes and I have so many pictures from there, but they are in storage. I'll have to get them all out and show them to you guys.
I saw a few of the women on today show the other day... It was sad how stupid they sounded. I dont mean to sound harsh, but I really dont think they are properly educated. I will find a video of it if I can.
i dont knock polygamy, but the "marriages" of anyone under the age of 18 is abhorrent, much less the subsequent rapes. also, "arranged" marriages of any kind, no matter the age involved is archaic.
They are educated but in a different way than we are. There is a school on the compound. Well at least on mine there was. I don't condone the marriage of young women to older men, on our compound it was arranged for you but you had to be of age.
This is a little out of sync... and I realize they may have had technical problems but you cant deny how "off" they are. I think it is really sad. They are stripped of any independent thinking, it seems.
Obviously, I feel the marriage and forced procreation of these young girls is disgusting. Those that know me (and the majority of us on here) know that goes without saying. However.....
Some of the things I've heard aren't all wrong either. No tv....nothing wrong with that. Also, they're probaly healthier than our children (physically)....they lived off the land. Aside from the obvious, it kinda sounds like they may have avoided the kind of corruption possible for our own kids today. Although, I think it's sad that those poor children don't know what a Crayola is.