Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Transcript Nancy Grace and Sheriff Brown

who's talking here?

**justme** 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

**justme** --- 18 years ago -

SHERIFF ED BROWN, ONSLOW COUNTY, N.C.: Nancy, I have just reviewed the report. I want to clear up something. GRACE: OK. BROWN: I was under the impression to start with that the mother was the one that called the sheriff`s office. It is in reverse. The sheriff`s office called the mother to get the necessary information in this investigation. We received the information in this investigation from a pen (ph) message from the hometown of Mary Lauterbach. That`s the mother. Hold on. We initiated the call back to the mother to try to obtain the telephone number for Maria and other information that the mother would possibly know that could give us. So we initiated the call into the Mary Lauterbach after receiving a pen message from her hometown, where she reported her daughter, Maria, missing. GRACE: OK, sir. Bottom line... BROWN: And at that time -- OK. GRACE: Let me make sure I understand what you`re saying. You`re saying that you returned a message to the mother. She called you. She contacted you through a pen message. Yes? BROWN: No. The police department there contacted us. GRACE: OK. BROWN: We, in reverse, contacted Mary to try to get as much information about her daughter as possible. GRACE: OK. Good to know. BROWN: And we actually initiated... GRACE: Now back to the original question. BROWN: OK. GRACE: You learned the suspect, Laurean`s, name January 7. The alleged rape happened back in April, many, many months before. Why the delay? Why did you just learn his name January 7? BROWN: It`s not likely to have all the facts when you begin an investigation. That`s the purpose for an investigation. And let me say this, because I know you`re going to have some folks on after me. And I`m going to offer you this invitation to come to the Onslow County sheriff`s office or send those professionals that you`re going to refer to after our comments to come here, and I`ll share the investigation with them. And by getting a report from them back to you, you`ll probably have a more professional opinion on the way we handled this case. GRACE: I`d like to go back to the original question. When did you first open the case regarding Lauterbach? BROWN: The 19th of December, four days after she was apparently murdered. GRACE: OK. All right. You opened a missing persons case, correct? BROWN: As a result of a pen message... GRACE: Right. That`s kind of... BROWN: ... from the hometown of Mary Lauterbach. GRACE: ... a yes/no thing. So you open it on the 19th. I`m still not clear on why you did not know that there was a rape accusation and the name of the alleged rapist until two weeks later. Maybe it`s the military`s fault for not telling it to you. But I`m asking you, did you go to the military base and investigate this? BROWN: Let me tell you, OK? We were not provided all the information. And when you get a report, if you have all the facts, you don`t need to investigate. I`m trying to make it clear to you there`s a lot of footwork and research done in order to get us to where we get the name of Laurean in this case. GRACE: It had been a matter of... BROWN: Hold it, hold it. GRACE: Well, sir, when you beat around the bush so much, I assume you`re through with your answer. My question is, when you found out about the missing person on the 19th, did you go to the military base, Camp Lejeune, that day to find out information? BROWN: Let me clear something up. GRACE: OK. BROWN: You asked me a question, then you won`t let me finish it. I don`t have to stand here and defend the professional way that the sheriff`s office handled this investigation. GRACE: If you can just answer... BROWN: I`m so sure of that, I`ve invited you and your staff to come here. GRACE: Yes, we heard it. BROWN: I`m not going to answer you unless you take my answer. OK. GRACE: Right. I`ll repeat it again. I`ll repeat it again. BROWN: OK. GRACE: Did you go to Camp Lejeune on the 19th? BROWN: Eventually, we went to camp Lejeune, when we... GRACE: Did you go on the 19th? BROWN: No, I didn`t go on the 19th, and I`m not going to stand up here and be a rhetoric for you and your show. Now, I had reservations... GRACE: You`re not going to... BROWN: ... about coming here to start with... GRACE: ... be a rhetoric? BROWN: I`m not going to stand up here and play like I`m... GRACE: Sir, I`m not playing a game! BROWN: ... you know, that something is wrong with this. GRACE: I`m asking you some questions... BROWN: Hold on just a minute. GRACE: ... and I`m not hearing an answer. BROWN: I told you, and I`ve told you three times, we did not learn about Mr. Laurean on the 19th. We did not go on the 19th. There`s a lot of investigations that go into this missing persons before you get to the 19th. Now, I`m sure that me and you have probably a different opinion about the way things are handled. I`m as much an advocate for the victim in every case as you are in every case. So we`re on the same side when it comes to the victim. You just handle it the way you do things, different than the way that I handle -- that I do things. GRACE: That is certainly true, sir. Now... BROWN: We`re professionals. GRACE: My next question is... BROWN: OK. GRACE: When you learned the suspect`s name on January 7, what did you do? BROWN: I knew about the suspect`s name on January the 7th, and we tried to get the suspect to give us a call. However, there was other -- another person that we needed -- that we needed that was in California. We -- I went personally to the highest command on the base, got total cooperation. I got the Marine back from California, who was a witness that needed to answer some questions. And I got Mr. Laurean at least giving us a promise to come talk to us. However, that promise -- hold on, hold on, hold on. That promise fell through on Thursday at 4:00 o`clock, when we got a call from three of the most respectful, good attorneys in this county telling us that Laurean was not going to talk to us. GRACE: Sheriff, why do you believe that Cesar Laurean was not arrested when the original rape allegation was made? BROWN: Nancy, I can`t defend what has taken place on the base. GRACE: Right. BROWN: I`m not here to defend them. And I`m really not here to defend the -- this investigation because it was very professional. And I`m not here to get into a conflict with anyone because we go at full speed bore in this case to try to learn where the victim was at. And honestly, I shared as much stress as I`ve ever shared in my 41 years in this job until Friday, when we learned of this information and until about 3:00 o`clock Friday afternoon, when the body was discovered. That time, my stress -- even though my horror was beginning to develop, my stress began to get down because we had located the victim. The major cause of an investigation is to try to locate the victim. And if you`ll go back and review the programs that have been on about this, the victim was downplayed of her honesty, and I think the general listening public until about Friday morning felt like most -- I did, even - - that she was going to be alive when we found her and it was going to be something where she had been with a friend. GRACE: Sheriff, one thing that I believe has been very confusing, very confusing to the public, is why nothing was done for so long. And what I`m referring to is the alleged rape happened in April. The guy was never arrested. He was never apprehended. He was never questioned. Nothing, until suddenly, she`s dead. Now, my question to you is, the rape itself was being handled by the military, not your office. Yes/no. BROWN: That`s correct. That`s correct. Yes. GRACE: So for all of those months, you and your office knew nothing about this alleged sex attack. BROWN: And that is not unusual, Miss Nancy, because the military base is a different government from the civilian base -- civilian side of the gate. We do not... GRACE: When did it become... BROWN: Hold on. Hold on. GRACE: ... your case? BROWN: It never became our case. And that`s what I think needs to be clear to the public. It never became our case until -- and really still not our case because our case is a missing person. Our case is not a rape investigation. GRACE: OK. Sheriff, why was the rape investigation handled by the military and the missing person case and the murder handled by you? BROWN: OK. The -- Nancy, the victim in this case and the instance of the rape in this case occurred on the base. The missing person, who is the same -- is Miss Maria Lauterbach, lived off the base in the civilian community, and therefore, anything happens to her in the investigation in the civilian community, we would handle. GRACE: Got it. BROWN: So we were handling the missing person thing unaware that in April, about eight months earlier, had there been anything -- unaware at all, and that`s not unusual because it`s two different case -- or same person with an incident happening on base and an incident happening off base. GRACE: I want to go now -- thank you, Sheriff -- to Dewey Hudson, the Onslow County district attorney. Mr. Hudson, thank you for being with us. Mr. Hudson, I`ve been taking a look at this timeline, specifically the day that Laurean allegedly took off. Now, his wife is being treated as a friendly witness. I find it highly coincidental that she wakes up and finds a note at 4:00 AM and he allegedly leaves town around 4:00 AM. Is there a possibility that he told her what happened and she let him get a head start? DEWEY HUDSON, ONSLOW COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY: Well, I can`t comment on the involvement of his wife. I think the sheriff would be in a better position. All I know is that what I understand, that she has cooperated fully with law enforcement officers and they feel like and after reviewing their findings that so far, she`s been very cooperative. We have no evidence that she`s involved in these crimes. GRACE: Right. Mr. Hudson, would this under any circumstance qualify as a death penalty case in your jurisdiction? HUDSON: Yes, this case certainly could qualify for the death penalty. And I`m not in a position -- I`m not in a position to make that decision without further facts. (COMMERCIAL BREAK) (BEGIN VIDEO CLIP) UNIDENTIFIED MALE: The murder victim, an active-duty member of the United States Marine Corps. The murder suspect, an active duty member of the United States Marine Corps. So far, the only public face of the investigation belongs to a civilian sheriff. So where`s the Marine Corps? What are they doing to bring in their fugitive corporal? And who gets him when or if he`s eventually arrested? (END VIDEO CLIP) GRACE: A lot of you have had a lot of questions, a lot of tough questions for Sheriff Ed Brown with the Onslow County sheriff`s office. At least he and the district attorney are here to answer your questions. The military has yet to answer questions. And clearly tonight, we learn with no question whatsoever that they had their hands on the rape case from the day it was reported in April all the time until she went missing, her charred remains now found in the suspect`s own backyard. Back to Sheriff Ed Brown. Sheriff, has there been a determinative DNA test completed to finally name that that is her? BROWN: Miss Nancy, there hasn`t been a DNA, but I think Dr. Garrick (ph) -- the results of the autopsy have been reported to us, but it would be improper for me to address it. But I do want to address something that I`ve learned tonight. And it`s probably going to shock some of the other folks because I learned it tonight. And it`s in the report. And I`m not one for not being straight up with you all, and that`s what I want you to understand. I don`t have anything to hide in the investigation. And it`s documented, so it`s public record. We attempted to try to get some information in the very beginning concerning the incident on base, and we didn`t get it. Now, I don`t have to defend what we`ve done. And -- but -- and I don`t have to defend the upper echelon of the military base. And I do not like to say that the -- are you... GRACE: Yes, yes, I can hear you. BROWN: OK. And I don`t think it is fair to place the responsibility or the accusation on what would be entitled the Marines. This was an individual in an individual unit. But from the very beginning -- and I -- you -- the report is public record -- are you with me? GRACE: Yes. (COMMERCIAL BREAK) GRACE: Welcome back. We are asking some very tough questions of the local sheriff and the elected district attorney in the jurisdiction in which 20-year-old Marine Maria Lauterbach was murdered, along with her unborn child. Back to Sheriff Ed Brown. Sheriff, I was going through the timeline, and I noticed myself, following up on what you just said, on January 9, you or someone in your office went to the base to try to get information, and that the higher-ups, the brass, didn`t even know about the incident. They had no idea -- I assume you`re referring to the rape or the missing person allegation. It seems as if this case had fallen through the cracks there at Camp Lejeune. BROWN: Well, Miss Nancy, looking at the report tonight -- tonight is the first time I`ve sat down and really digested the report. And I`m glad you have made it clear. It is not likely that the top brass, with all the other things going on, would be handling something at the lower unit level. I don`t know the operations of the military, but I don`t think top brass needs to get -- be the ones being looked at in this case. Are you still with me? GRACE: Yes, I am. I understand what you`re saying, that the top brass typically would not know about this incident. But what about her direct supervisors? We`ll be right back. (COMMERCIAL BREAK) (BEGIN VIDEOTAPE) UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER: Laurean`s neighbors say they`re shocked about the violence associated with this alleged crime. UNIDENTIFIED NEIGHBOR: He was like a typical American family, always quiet, out there spending time with his daughter. UNIDENTIFIED REPORTER: But they say Laurean did ask for a shovel several days ago, what at the time seemed like a harmless tool. UNIDENTIFIED NEIGHBOR: He said can he borrow it for, like, 40 minutes, and so (INAUDIBLE) to my husband so he came back and gave it to him and he said thanks, and that`s it. BROWN: The body was much charred. It appeared that the body of the adult was laying over on the side with the face down in the bottom of the pit. As I said, the fetus was in the abdominal area of that adult. One of the things that will probably stick with me for a long time and forever is that little hand, the way those fingers were turned, that it had been burned off the arm. That is bizarre. That is tragic. And it`s disgusting. (END VIDEOTAPE) GRACE: That is Onslow County Sheriff, Ed Brown, talking, and he is with us tonight. We are taking your calls live. I`ll get right to the calls. But I want to ask Ed Brown. Sheriff Brown, one more question on this timeline. The mother of Maria Lauterbach tells us that she contacted the sheriff`s department on December 19 and told the Onslow Sheriff`s Department that Maria had made a rape allegation. So that was on December 19th. Are you telling us that the military did not give you follow-up information until around January 7th on that, even though you requested it? BROWN: Nancy, let me put this report in perspective. GRACE: OK. BROWN: This is the way the report -- and when I read it tonight is the first time I`ve read it in detail. Now, Laurean`s name never -- has never been come up in the report now, even in the report I read today. The investigators came to me on the 7th because of a need to talk with Laurean and had not been provided that opportunity. I contacted the brass of the base. They did not know about it. After contacting the brass of the base and making them aware of it, I had the Marine brought back from California and had activity from Laurean. But let me go back to the initial report. According to the report, and this is what I want to make clear, when I learn of something I don`t try to conceal it, and you know that with the MPO that came out the other day. When I learn about it, I`m not going to stand up here and try to cover anything. I don`t have to. But on the 19th, according to the report, the police department pinned us a message, and the missing person investigator or the person who handles that contacted Mary for information about Maria and other, other information he would need to try to find out her behavior. Now, soon thereafter, when the report of the rape without a name was found out, which was in the report, after the officer called Mary, Miss Mary Lauterbach, the officer handling the missing persons made the attempts to contact the base. Now, this is not the brass but the unit level. Those attempts were futile and did not result in any callbacks. GRACE: Got it. BROWN: When that investigator who -- the criminal investigator was handed the investigation, because it appeared to be suspicious in nature, the same results -- no callbacks. GRACE: Let`s go out to -- hold on just a second. BROWN: Just a minute. Just a minute. GRACE: OK. BROWN: Just a minute. No results. The investigators came to me with a degree of frustration and -- because they weren`t being called back in their attempt to try to find out something about the rape from the unit level. That is when I called the command brass level and learned that they did not know about it. And that is when I met the top echelon and discussed it with them and immediately things began to happen that we needed to happen. And that is -- was on the 7th. And if you`ll notice, on the 7th, once things -- we got started getting some movement, it was only about five days later before we had discovered where the body of Maria Lauterbach is. GRACE: With us tonight Sheriff Ed Brown from the Onslow Sheriff`s Department, along with district attorney, Dewey Hudson.  

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground