Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

The Rebel Flag Good or Bad

who's talking here?

Irish~Freckles 4
mommy2 3
shorty6pac 1
Fuzzy Black Cat 3
Crabby 14
Staci 1
do you really care who i am 11
R6girl 1
IMSleepngbty 3
sobbingsandy 4
DouG 6
CollieGirl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

sobbingsandy --- 19 years ago -

There is so much division in thoughts in america about the rebel flag what are your thoughts on it. 

Staci --- 19 years ago -

I'm not really sure what I think. The flag is associated w/the southern states and some associate it with slavery and racisim, because the southern states were fine with slavery being a part of their lives. Others (people who have lived in the south their whole lives)just see it as a symbol of the southern states. It doesn't mean their raceist or agree w/what their ancestors did years and years ago, they just see it as part of their heritage, what their ancestors went through. Me though..I just don't know. Do I think it should be flying with our American Flag? No. If I saw one on someones car though I wouldn't immediatly think they were racist, I would assume they were from the south though and took pride in that. I don't think that it always means they're really taking pride in their past and what their ancestors did, they're just showing were they came from. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederate_Flag 

Irish~Freckles --- 19 years ago -

It makes me sooo mad when I see the KKK fly that flag...that wasn't the purpose of that flag!! 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

KKK info The real flag of the KKK 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

I think it infuriates me to constantly in this day and age to see people automatically accused of racism. This is a very controversial subject and it shouldnt be. The Confederate Flag is a flag of southern support, not slavery. Yes Slavery was in fact a part of the south but the Civil War was not fought based on Slavery. Also not only Blacks were slaves, white women were too. Not all Slaves were treated badly, some were treated well. Not saying that I am a supporter of slavery, but I am a supporter of knowing the full truth about history. And yes some slaves or blacks in general were not treated equally once upon a time, does that give some blacks the right to accuse me of slavery or racism. (me as a general white person) and NO I AM NOT RACIST SO DONT EVEN START! The real truth 

R6girl --- 19 years ago -

I am back and forth on it all, I don't particularly like the flag just bc I have family memebers (unfortunatly) that do fly this flag in there front yard or have on there vehicles and they are in fact RACIST and that makes me NUTS! I am furtherest from that..I was told flat out as a teen (bc rumors were going around school) that if I was in fact "dating" this guy Trevor (we were best buddies and played basketball together) I would be killed by my own step mom. That is just a simple taste of my wonderful family. So I CANNOT stand seeing that flag, bc it just reminds me of racism..I understnd not all are that way, but for me it makes my skin crawl. 

sobbingsandy --- 19 years ago -

elvnmo by saying not all slaves were treated badly isnt that a contradictory statement? isnt being enslaved by someone in itself bad? What was the Civil war over then? Who were white women enslaved by? The Civil war was americans fighting against americans how can we be proud of that. 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

read your history 

do you really care who i am --- 19 years ago -

The Confederate flag is a symbol. Unlike concepts like "Truth" or "Dishonesty", a flag is symbol - it provides a visual focal point for a nation/organization/concepts behind it. While the nations behind a nation's flag are unambiguous, the concepts and ideals that it symbolizes to the person looking at it vary with the person looking at. So it is with the Confederate flag. Some folks see the confederate flag as a symbol of the belief that black folks are worth less than white folks. Fortunately, this view of the flag is in the minority. Unfortunately the folks that see it representing this are very noisy ( Whether they are from the KKK side, or NAACP side). Others see it a symbol or rebellion. Bikers, truckers, and drug gangs see and use it this way (Yeah, I'm over generalizing). Oddly enough this group takes very little trouble from either of the other sides Maybe they don't care. Maybe nobody wants to mess with them. Others, like I and most southerners, look at the confederate battle flag and think fondly of the outnumbered "grey's" whipping the "blue's", of the right of the people form their own government, of courage in the face of privation, of chivalry, of skill, and of daring. One of Scotland's unofficial nationals anthem begins: O Flower of Scotland, When will we see Your like again, That fought and died for, Your wee bit Hill and Glen, And stood against him, Proud Edward's Army, And sent him homeward, Tae think again. Scotland is now a part of EnglandBritain, but many scots are proud of being scottish. It's the same thing with Southerners. We are American's now (and proud of it too), and we are also proud of have "whupped" the yankees on numerous occasions against ugly odds. Just mention Lee, Jackson, Stuart, or Forrest, and a southerner's face will light up, just like a "true Scot's" face would light up at the mention of Wallace or Bruce. Next time you hear a "debate" on the flying of the southern flag, remember that for all practical purposes the sides could be arguing about totally different flags, because to different people, the flag represent very different concepts. It's true, some confederate leaders were total racists. (By the same token, so were many Yankees. That does not excuses the southern ones, of course.) There are bad things in almost every nations history. Learn from and avoid the bad; be proud of and repeat the good. We don't hide the US flag because of what happened to the indians. We say, "that was stupid of us, won't do that again", move on, and hang the Stars and Stripes out on the front porch in honor of our freedom and in memory of those that died to keep it for us. So it is with most of the people flying confederate flag. (Though my parents with from the "North", and I have one or two soldiers in blue in my ancestry, I was born in the south, raised in the south, and live in the south. Therefore I am southern. These are southern opinions and I can't vouch for the opinions of "Yankee's". Any Yankees around? Let me know what people in your area think) Posted by Daniel at August 6, 2003 11:04 AM 

do you really care who i am --- 19 years ago -

Kinda long sorry 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

If Emacipation Proclomation occured in 1862 and the war started in 1861, how could that be the main reason, it was a goal, not the reason. I also never stated that I was pro or con over the Civil War, just as I never stated that I am pro or con the iraqi war. If your asking who were white women or white people enslaved by, then it makes me wonder what they are really teaching in todays history classes. 

Irish~Freckles --- 19 years ago -

The purpose of the Confederate Flag was to represent the 13 states that came together to fight the north..and it was not the first flag of the Confederate States... slavery was an issue back in the day but also the north was shutting down their ways of transportation so they could not prosper and they were suffering...so they joined together against the north ... i do not feel that the conferedate flag should be used for racist purposes..that is not what it represents...it represents the 13 states that joined together to form the Confederate States of America.. that is just my opinion 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

I am a Yankee, 3rd generation American. My great-grandparents came over here from Europe. I think that the confederate flag will be debated until the end of time, I understand someone may have ill feelings for it, I just wish those people viewed other peoples opinions for it. When I was in college, the question was asked "If you displayed a confederate flag outside of your Northern state dorm room and it created controversy, would and should you take it down?" I commented that I shouldnt have to if I were a southerner yet would if it created controversy. I do however feel that it creates controversy from people who are not fully aware of history. It would be based on how it were displayed as NCKid stated. 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

Ameless, I agree. 

mommy2 --- 19 years ago -

Hey elvnmo as someone who has a kid that will be starting next year as a freshman, they're unfortunately not learning anything it seems as we did. Its really a shame. 

mommy2 --- 19 years ago -

exactly Ameless! 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

that really is a shame, history is a vital part of life. We all need to know what this country 9or world for that matter) was built on. I am incredibly saddened to hear that they do not teach true history. My husband wanted to become a history professor when he retired. We are incredible history buffs. 

mommy2 --- 19 years ago -

I was born and raised right here in this town. I have rebel flag stuff in my home.My husband and I have friends of all races and genders that have been to our home and not one of them has ever said a thing. They know we aren't making a racist statement with it. 

do you really care who i am --- 19 years ago -

I have My flag i have displayed my flag but i have and will respect others opinions towards it i do what i do to prtect thier right to have such opinion. I respect my wifes opinion not to display it out in the open of a diverce comunity to prevent contrevercy. Some would say there is no pride in that, so be it i disagree. It is nothing more than respect. In todays society the respect be respected idela are nonexistant so to prevent contreversity i hang mine were i see it and those who know me and have no problem wiht it sees it. Dose that make sence ? 

sobbingsandy --- 19 years ago -

elvnmo i didnt mean for you to take it personally. i asked who were white women enslaved by cause i didnt know. who forced white women from where they lived and forced them to perform services for them for free? i think the problem is unforturnately many people from the old days that were affiliated with the confederate flag were racists. thats why today so many people think of it that way. i mean you cant have something that was used for many years as a symbol of racism and then now say oh well now it just means the pride of the south and expect everyone to say ok. Just as if i rode down the road with an iraqi flag flying the majority of americans now would symbolize it to terrorism and think i am a terrorist. again not trying to argue just trying to get different points of views on issues facing americans today. and i respect your views 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

yes it makes total sense, just as I was saying about my college question. I would remove it based on respect. If someone was offended, fine. 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

SObbingsandy, thanks for stating that, I do not see it as a historical sign of racism though. It was never used that way. I think that now a days people use it for that fact based on that the south had slaves at that time but it was not made for a symbol of racism. Just as the swastika is widly misunderstood. White women slaves have been in history for quite some time. As sex slaves or whatnot. They have been enslaved or mistreated for ever. Women segregation other than the obvious restroom establishments, not able to vote, walk behind their man, not able to leave the home, things like that to say the least. The Islamic women is a great example of it happening today! 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

I do feel that some people in general, whether the KKK or other racial group misuse it and for that, yes I agree with that. 

sobbingsandy --- 19 years ago -

yes i thank you all for you input my conclusion is the flag holds different meanings to different generations from the south. but whatever your views on it there is a bad perception being given of the flag from the few racist idiots still left out there 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

bc it just reminds me of racism..I understnd not all are that way, but for me it makes my skin crawl. R6girl, and for that reason, I understand why someone would hate it. I am sure though that if you saw someone else flying it that they may be flying it out of pride for their heritage. My family has comments about other cultures, I was raised hearing bad things about certain people yet I overcame my familys' impressed upon racism. They hear about it when they say things around me now. :) 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

I think that there will always be racial idiots. Some blacks are racist against whites, religions are racist againts others and so forth. Unfortunetly it is a part of our world. Just understanding that people have different views and hearing their opinion is half the battle. It is my job as a mom to make my children aware of social equality. 

IMSleepngbty --- 19 years ago -

I have My flag i have displayed my flag but i have and will respect others opinions towards it i do what i do to prtect thier right to have such opinion. Some would say there is no pride in that, so be it i disagree. The Rebel Flag is a symbol of southern heritage not necessarily to be taken as racism. People have to respect others not in agreement per say; but out of respect that this is a free country and this is our right. I agree with NCKID. I have hang my flag in my profile and on our cars. I am proud to have been born and raised in the south. GRITS baby!!! 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

GRITS baby!!! LOL, that is something that I have never been able to eat...now you can say sweet tea and I will be happy to visit the south :) 

IMSleepngbty --- 19 years ago -

GRITS stands for: Girls Raised In The South I am in agreement with you on the sweet tea. :) 

Crabby --- 19 years ago -

GRITS stands for: Girls Raised In The South LOL, thats cute 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help
lejeune
men

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground