Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Confusion, car purchase taxes

who's talking here?

dmc21 18
Monkey Manners 8
brandy88512 1
jb24 1
newbernbears 1
cdubs 2
Maleficent 13
Along For The Ride 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

I had a car we bought in NC. I imagine that we paid the 3% hwy usage tax when we bought that vehicle.

A few years later we traded in 2 vehicles including the aforementioned car for a new SUV. Yes I'm aware that financially trading in vehicles that way isn't the best financial decisions etc etc but it was the best decision at the time.

Now when we purchased the SUV, we paid $184.60 in tax according to the paperwork. The vehicle was 28575.00 cash price and then you work in all the trade ins, down payment etc. I can not figure out how they got $185 as 3% of anything. Now the cars registration and tags and all that were transferred over to the new vehicle. Is that why we didn't have to pay the 3%? Because we had already done so when we purchased the car and the registration just transferred? Can anyone explain what the heck is going on?

Im asking because I am now running into problems registering my vehicle in other states. In the 2 other states I am trying to register my vehicle in (either my home state or where we are currently registered) I now have to pay sales tax on the vehicle to get it registered. I could deduct the cost of what I paid to another state but NC doesnt call it a sales tax so the other states wont let me deduct the 3% and even if they did, my paperwork doesn't show that I paid 3% it shows .6% which I dont even know WTF that is. Help? 

newbernbears --- 13 years ago -

Just call DMV in both states 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

because that 3% is a highway usage fee. It's nothing to do with sales tax. That is completely separate.

You pay sales tax to the dealership (where I assume you bought them).

you pay the highway fee to the state of NC.


If it's a private sale, you pay both the sales tax and the highway fee at the License Plate Agency when you register the vehicle. In that case, you pay tax and fee on what they value the vehicle at. Not what you actually paid.

ETA they also have a maximum you pay for that 3%. I don't know what that is, though. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

you don't pay the 3% vehicle fee if you purchase at a dealership.

sorry, meant to add that in.

At least not to my knowledge. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Hmm well I guess then we only paid .6% sales tax. There has to be something wrong with this paperwork. We did buy it at a dealer.

NC DMV is my call tomorrow but I already talked with both of the other states DMVs extensively. It'll be $1200 in one state and $2500 in the other. It just seems crazy to me. Oh well I guess. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

you have to pay sales tax, when you already paid it?

I've never heard that before. We've never had to pay that much when we've registered in other states. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Yeah you get to deduct the amount you paid to the state where you purchased the vehicle. Ex state A has 6% tax so I would only have to pay 3% except my sales papers show I only paid .6% tax. It's ridiculous and its only when you initial register the vehicle but I don't even know... Moving to NC we only had to pay like $200, Hawaii was like $20 so this is a bit of a sticker shock. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

it's been years, but when we moved NC to CA, it was dirt cheap to register our car.

Back then, though, military was exempt from that 3% fee. :( (the NC fee)

I can't believe you have to repay sales tax. That totally sucks. I could understand some sort of other fee (like NC with the highway fee), but it just seems ridiculous to charge someone sales tax again, when you pay that when you purchase, to the state you purchase. Just seems like double dipping to me. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

California let us skip out on the licensing fee which is about $150. $2300 of the $2500 is taxes. It doesn't make sense at all. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

Military isn't exempt from anything? Maybe that's why it was dirt cheap back then. Maybe, like NC, CA stopped letting them be exempt. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

did you use the online calculator to figure it out? I just did, guessing at numbers for our car and it only came up to about $300. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Yeah I used the online calculator. :/ 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

and it still came out that much? That's crazy! I didn't even see a line that charged sales tax.
I used a $40000 car, and it was only $300. If it's that far off, I'm glad we'll never have to move to CA. lol 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Screen shot. It's the non resident vehicle calculator because we dont get to use the resident one since the car was registered in another state previously. I was slightly off on my numbers above but close enough. The current vehicle license fee for $167 or whatever is the only one we dont have to pay because hes military.
0 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I'm going to redo what I did earlier. I don't know how to do a screen shot, though. lol 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

mine has $0 in that line where yours is over $2k. Weird, weird weird.

The only difference is it required me to put in a city. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Oh and that's if we can get away with not having it registered in CA from the time we got here in June since it was registered in NC during that time. If they want his orders and see we've been here since then we get to tack on these charges:
Current Registration Penalty: 30.00
CHP Penalty: 30.00
Current Vehicle License Fee Penalty: 74.00
Use/Sales Tax Penalty: 222.00 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I just don't understand why yours is so much more than mine. lol 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

I have no idea. Im at a loss. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

ok, when I tried to print screen, it all screwed up. lol So I reloaded it and had to input new numbers and stuff. This time it comes out to over $3k.

Again, glad we will never have to move to CA. lol

Good luck!

I'm going to still play around with that site, though. ha ha 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

lol ugh CA. Giving me heartburn. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I did it again, and it was back to $300. Now it won't load. ha ha I broke it. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

I give up. lol

yeah, way too expensive and it just doesn't seem right.

I'm guessing military was exempt when we went there. The car was mine from before we had even met and I remember putting it into my husband's name to save money. 

Along For The Ride --- 13 years ago -

I was curious, so I looked on the CA DMV website. I think they are getting you for sales tax if the car was purchased within a year of registering it in CA. 

dmc21 (Mod) --- 13 years ago -

that makes perfect sense! lol 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Hmm.... If that's the case the. I will wait until the 21st of March to do it. My car was purchased on the 20th of March 2012. Tags expire the 15th which I don't like the idea of going over but if it will save me from paying a ridiculous amount I can jut so at home for a week. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

Holy ess word. I can not thank you enough for figuring that out. I put in the operative date for the 21st and look what it did. Subtract the licensing fee and it will only be $96!!! THANK YOU!!
0 

Monkey Manners --- 13 years ago -

Holy Mother Of God


WTH?

I'm so confused lol

If you buy a vehicle out of state and then take it to another state sometimes you have to pay the difference in sales taxes on your tax return at the end of the year. (Out of state purchases) Like if I am a resident of NC and I go to SC and buy a vehicle and bring it back home to NC to use, I'd have to file that on my tax return showing that I bought that vehicle in another state and paid state taxes elsewhere. (could be why the state you're talking about gives you a credit for taxes paid to another state so long as they're categorized as sales and use taxes and not something like property taxes.)


We will be moving to Cali this summer but plan to take our 3 vehicles and leave them registered in NC since this is where I claim residential status and that will not change and we do plan on coming back here afterwards and once he retires NC is where we will be. 

Maleficent --- 13 years ago -

If you buy a vehicle out of state and then take it to another state sometimes you have to pay the difference in sales taxes on your tax return at the end of the year

Oh wow I never knew that! We bought a vehicle right before we came to NC when we were in HI and didn't have any problems like this. I thought paying $200 in NC or whatever we paid was ridiculous. lol boy was I mistaken! In Hawaii it was always $20 to register a vehicle, titling was another $20. That's it. My home state makes you pay taxes on the value of the car regardless of when you bought it. My husband recently bought a 91 camaro and it's only $144 to register his car in my home state because its only worth $800. In the long run it will be better to register everything in my home state because renewing it is cheap but for now CA ended up cheaper than them. 

Monkey Manners --- 13 years ago -

My home state makes you pay taxes on the value of the car regardless of when you bought it.


NC is that way as well, annually we have to pay PROPERTY taxes on vehicles registered in this state by NC state residents.

My scenario I mentioned was more for a non military family.
Let's say a resident of NC goes to SC to buy a car because it's cheaper. This resident lives in NC though and that's where he will maintain that vehicle. When he files his tax return he must show that he made that purchase in SC for an NC registered vehicle.

I think when I bought my Highlander from my dad in 08 I had to pay taxes in NC based on the purchase price, so that would be sales taxes. I remember my dad trying to find a way for it to be cheaper for me to register it here in NC, but since I was paying off his loan it showed the full amount I purchased the vehicle for, no way around it.

We plan on leaving our vehicles registered in NC while we live in Cali on this next PCS though.

I just need to figure out what happens with inspections and such. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground