Forgive me if you already read this on the PU. I attended a 'town hall' meeting here on Quantico MCB last night, and was made aware of a new rule they're going to start enforcing:
Housing has declared that the only flags you can hang are the U.S. flag, the Marine Corps flag, and international officers can hang their home country's flag. No sports flags, no season flags, no holiday flags. They're going to start enforcing on March 1st.
Maybe I'm putting an over-dramatic spin on it here, but I see it this way....Marines are out in 2 different war zones right now, fighting (ostensibly) for the rights of people to be free citizens. But they're going to tell families of Marines what they can hang on their flagpoles?
Sure, they can tell Marines what to wear and how to cut their hair. They signed up for that. And I'm even willing to allow for the fact that I don't own this house, and therefore my 'landlord' can place certain restrictions on me. But their rationale, straight from the horse's mouth, is for the sake of "uniform appearance" and conformity, and I just don't think those are worthwhile reasons to be go all communist dictatorship about this one. "We don't want you to be an individual...we don't want you to distinguish your house from your neighbor's."
Does LeJeune have such a rule? What do you think of Quantico's ruling (if you're bored and feel like discussing)?
you live in what's basically a HOA. If you don't like it (general you), you need to find a non HOA area to live in. HOAs tend to have crazy rules, and most of them want all their houses to look 'uniform'. While I think decorations are a silly thing to get all up in arms about (housing, not tenants), that's their rule and they have the right to make it and enforce it as they see fit.
I don't even hang flags, so I'm not sure why I'm so strongly against this. Maybe it's because I just read Animal Farm? LMAO!
It's that whole 'conform or we will harass you' mentality that disturbs me the most. Dog rules are for the preservation of the property that they own. I get that.
The way it was presented last night just smacked of something right out of an old communist regime. "We just decided that it's better if everyone maintains a uniform appearance, so we're going to start looking around and if you're displaying an unauthorized flag, we're going to knock on your door and make sure you remove it." Kinda made my skin crawl, frankly. Oh well, I'm outta here in June!
you live in what's basically a HOA. If you don't like it (general you), you need to find a non HOA area to live in. HOAs tend to have crazy rules, and most of them want all their houses to look 'uniform'.
I get that...I just think it's ridiculous to take away a "freedom" from people whose job it is to go out and ensure freedom for everyone else. LMAO!
Well, Quantico is really heavy with international students, and I think most of them are "officers" in their home countries. No, the rule itself does not apply to "just officers." It applies to all of base housing.
"We just decided that it's better if everyone maintains a uniform appearance, so we're going to start looking around and if you're displaying an unauthorized flag, we're going to knock on your door and make sure you remove it." Kinda made my skin crawl, frankly.
horse's mouth, is for the sake of "uniform appearance" and conformity, and I just don't think those are worthwhile reasons to be go all communist dictatorship about this one.
I don't think it's "communist" or "dictatorship" and I can't stand when people make those statements about base rules.
If Turkey flags, Easter egg flags, or Dallas Cowboys flags are that important to people let them go live somewhere that doesn't have rules about appearances of the community.
you live in what's basically a HOA. If you don't like it (general you), you need to find a non HOA area to live in. HOAs tend to have crazy rules, and most of them want all their houses to look 'uniform'.
While it's not that "big of a deal" that I couldn't fly a state flag. I STILL don't like the fact that someone is telling me I can't. That's probably just the redneck in me though. lol
I don't think it's "communist" or "dictatorship" and I can't stand when people make those statements about base rules.
I'm all for rules that have a basis in safety and necessity. I'm arguing that this rule is arbitrary and based on opinion, and in a place where people sacrifice for the freedoms of others, I think it's bullsh*t. I'm as entitled to this opinion as you are to yours. I just bought it here for the sake of a conversation.
I'm all for rules that have a basis in safety and necessity.
But we can't pick and choose what rules we like and only follow them.
I'm arguing that this rule is arbitrary and based on opinion, and in a place where people sacrifice for the freedoms of others, I think it's bullsh*t.
The dress code isn't keeping anyone safe, yet we are SUPPOSED to follow it. That one could also be based on opinion, the opinion that flip flips, sweats, and booty shorts aren't appropriate public attire.
I'm all for rules that have a basis in safety and necessity. I'm arguing that this rule is arbitrary and based on opinion, and in a place where people sacrifice for the freedoms of others, I think it's bullsh*t.
Ditto.
It's little rules like the flag one that are just dumb and pointless. I honestly think the housing people have power trips and need to feel important at times.
The dress code isn't keeping anyone safe, yet we are SUPPOSED to follow it. That one could also be based on opinion, the opinion that flip flips, sweats, and booty shorts aren't appropriate public attire.
The dress code, IMO at least, is just common sense for being presentable in public. I wish it would prevent the 250 pounders from wearing booty shorts, but it doesn't.