How do you approach a teacher, without outright offending them, and ask about their grading practices?
My son brought home an assignment (after it was graded) where the point of the assignment is to correct misspelled words, improper punctuation, etc., in sentences. My son's papers (this is what I believe to be a week's worth of papers) only had punctuation corrected, and he received a 100. I asked my son what they were supposed to correct, and he said "everything".
So my question is, did this teacher even LOOK, or did she just see lots of words and give him an A for effort? This is the same child that is having problems with reading, spelling, etc as it is, and I just want to be sure he's not being swept under the rug instead of called out on what he's screwing up.
How do I ask the teacher, without outright accusing her of letting my child's problems slide?
What grade? I know when mine were in kindergarten and first it was kind of an A for effort thing even with misspelled words as long as they tried their best.
Ah. Yeah, they should I would assume have to spell properly. My son is in 3rd and they make him. I would just set up a meeting and show the papers and ask about em. I've done that before and never had a teacher get offended.
Wow, I can see your dilemma. Maybe I'm wrong but I would discuss it with the principal, that way maybe there will be some anonymity to it. I would just tell the principal why you brought it up with him/her because you didn't want to offend the teacher.
It *may* have been a completion grade. Even in 4th.
I would ask for a conferense just to see how she feels he is doing and you can bring it up there. I know on base we have quarterly conferences and the teacher pretty much takes control and explains the grades to me. If I still have questions I just ask.
It *may* have been a completion grade. Even in 4th.
Ew.. not okay with that.. alright, guess I'll be scheduling a conference, thanks. I think I'm gonna push for the testing we'd discussed at the 1st quarter, that has since been dismissed since he "seems to be doing better." If this is how he's "doing better", then I want to push the issue. Argh :( Thanks to those of you that responded!
I don't know proper parent teacher etiquette if there is any. Lol. My kids aren't even 3 yet. It would be good to bring it up with the teacher, and if she gets snotty or comes off rude then I would take it to the principal or assistant principal. I know I didn't get completion grades in 4th grade.
I wouldn't take it to the principle. That's a little too far. I'm willing to bet the teacher would appreciate a parent wanting to be involved and actually cares. She may have a simple explenation.
yeah that's why I figured to talk to the teacher first and see where it goes. If she was any kind of teacher she would appreciate the parent involvement. heck maybe she is secretly testing the parents to see if they even check up on their kids assignments and progress without parent teacher conferences. LOL
She won't.. I actually really like her, I was just kinda shocked at this packet of papers, and I don't want to offend her.. I'm not worried she'd be nasty, I'm worried she'll be offended.
I wouldn't take it to the principle. That's a little too far.
I just saw how I spelled explaination. Those 3 hours of sleep last night did not do me so well.
If it helps, I have 4 kids... some of them spell worse than others.. I've learned to figure out what's being said and miss most of the spelling mistakes unless I'm specifically looking for them ;)
I agree. It seems that the grading scale has gotten lower and lower. Now anything from a 90%-100% is an A. Where as several years ago you had to get a 95% or higher to get an A.
No joke, I had a class in high school where the teacher gave 5 points just for putting your name on the paper. Granted the assignment was worth 100, so you would fail whether you put your name or not and didn't do anything else. Lol
I've heard (don't know if its true) that you get so many points for putting your name on the TAAS (now the TAKS) test. That's the Texas standardized test.
For us 90-100 was an A, 80-89 was a b, 70-79 was a C and 69 and under was failing. They might have considered 70- 74 a d but I don't remember.
I remember my senior year in VA, they changed the grading scale so that in order to get an A you had to get a 94% or higher. I guess it depends on the state.
Are you sure the students didn't grade each other's papers? My son had a paper with obvious errors not marked wrong, but I could tell the check marks were made by a child's hand.
I would just send her a note or an email asking what the object of the assignment was. If it was a punctuation exercise, spelling might not have been the focus. My son is fourth grade age and I am a homeschooler so take it with a grain of whatever you want, but while spelling may be important to me, if we are doing a punctuation exercise and he gets the concept we are discussing I don't tend to nit pick other stuff. That doesn't mean I don't care or that I am not focusing on those issues at more appropriate times. If my aim was to gain his understanding of a concept, I don't want him to lose confidence because he rocked the concept but he misspelled something.
So, just ask for clarification about what the learning objective was and what her grading and teaching philosophy is.
MKG- I do understand what you're saying, and I do intend to ask for clarity on the assignment, thanks :)
ncnative- The papers are all stapled together with a blank page being stapled to the outside, and it just has a 100 circled on the front.. no checkmarks inside, and in fact he didn't even complete one of the pages... We'll see I suppose!
Kids are being passed to the next grade even if they fail (meaning, they make Fs in more than one subject.)
He's being swept under the rug. They all are.
Education in this country is a fat fcking joke
ugh..totally agree...If I wouldn't have fought for my son to get the extra help he needed and I had to fight the principal to hold him back last year...he would have just been passed over. The principal wanted to pass him to 3rd grade even though he was reading on a 1st grade level!
I agree. It seems that the grading scale has gotten lower and lower. Now anything from a 90%-100% is an A. Where as several years ago you had to get a 95% or higher to get an A.
Huh? I started school in the late 70s and 90-100 was always an A.
Sadly I agree about the poor education or should I say, lack of caring about our children's education's (some, not all).
I am not impressed with my daughter's teacher....AT ALL!! She has had the same homework each week since school started, which is complete 4 spelling word activities by Friday of each week. It is getting old and my daughter is getting bored with it...time to move on with something new. And I am disgusted with the completed work she brings home on Fridays. No professionalism at all.
Cinde..if I were in your situation, I would email the teacher and just relay your thoughts. Don't make a huge deal out of it because there may be a reason why it was done the way it was. You'll never know until you ask.
I'd send her an email with the basics of your problem and ask for a face to face meeting. That way she knows what to expect at the meeting.
I agree that many teachers and schools are downright lazy when it comes to education, but so are a lot of parents. It seems like a good deal of parents act like learning and education is only done at school and only the job of teachers. I'm a firm believer that if you think your childs school isn't up to your standard you need to pick up the slack at home yourself.
**this is not directed at any person on this thread**