Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

POLL: Black Only Field Trip

who's talking here?

*~LittleMissPerfect~* 6
Jules 2
BlueEyes 6
Mater 1
Nurse_Misty 1
The Original LM 3
Blue 1
MsBellaMae 1
Muse 18
swing72350 1
Jingle Bell Rockin 1
Susie Homemaker 17
ncnative 1
mrsroboto 6
Boobsy McNiceass 1
Afrina Watkins 9
TaterFRIGGNsalad 1
littleduck90 3
Krystal in NC 2
charlys 1
Maureenie 15
LdyDi 1
TheDivineComedy 1
notyme 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Black Only Field Trip

Doy ou agree with the Principal's reasoning behind his defense of the black children only field trip? Link

Yes Vote
 
 7.1% (2)
No Vote
 
 92.9% (26)
Maybe Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Other Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Muse --- 16 years ago -

Do you agree with the Principal's reasoning behind his defense of the black children only field trip? Link The Michigan school district investigating whether an elementary school field trip that excluded white students was illegal has disbanded the black-students-only academic support group that participated in the outing two weeks ago. “We have essentially put it on hold while we wait for the final determination on the investigation into possible violation of the State's Proposal 2,” Ann Arbor School District spokeswoman Liz Margolis told FoxNews.com. Thirty members of the Dicken Elementary School’s AA Lunch Bunch, a support group designed to bridge the gap in test scores between white and black students, were taken on a field trip two weeks ago to meet Alec Gallimore, an African-American rocket scientist who is an aerospace engineering professor and propulsion lab director at the University of Michigan. The school principal, Mike Madison, who is black, helped organize the trip, saying he hoped to encourage the students to pursue a career in the sciences. Hoping to quell rising tensions over the black-students-only outing, Madison sent a lengthy letter home to parents in which he explained the reasoning behind the trip. He admitted, however, that it could have been “approached and arranged in a better way.” "The intent of our field trip was not to segregate or exclude students, as has been reported, but rather to address the societal issues, roadblocks and challenges that our African-American children will face as they pursue a successful academic education here in our community,” Madison wrote. But instead of quashing tensions, the letter fueled a week of controversy and an onslaught of parental complaints that culminated late last week in the school district’s launch of an investigation into whether the field trip violated Proposal 2, a new state law that bans racial favoritism in public schools. The investigation is ongoing, and the Lunch Break will be out to lunch until it's wrapped up. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

Are you deleting it? I'm so confused! I want to give my opinion but it keeps getting deleted. LOL 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Sorry, I messed it up so I deleted it LOL! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

And I STILL messed up the "do you". GRRRRRRRRRRR. I'm not changing it. 

Afrina Watkins --- 16 years ago -

That's not right. I'm tired of black only anything! Caucasions can't have white only anything at all. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Well, as far as the field trip is concerned, I definitely am against segregating any one race. I feel that if it had been an all white field trip, it would be ALL over the news! But the poll is in response to the Principals reasoning. He basically says, he wants children who are at risk to see what they can accomplish. That's what the poll is about. Thoughts? 

LdyDi --- 16 years ago -

I think his intentions were good, but I still feel it's not ok to segregate the kids. It sends a bad message, imo. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

I don't really see why it was necessary to exclude any race from something like that. He could have included everyone and discussed how even though we have come so far in our society African-Americans (blacks whatever word doesn't offend someone) still face discrimination and challenges today. It could have been a lesson for all while still encouraging the black students. Now I will say that I don't have a problem with groups and clubs that are racially motivated. Obviously not something like the KKK or anything like that but high school clubs like we had. It's fine. It's and after-school hours gathering of people with a common interest or background. This was a public school function and inappropriate IMO. (was it a public school? I think I missed that info.) 

Mater --- 16 years ago -

MN, I completely agree with you. As far as children at risk,there are white kids, and Mexican children who are at risk as well. They come from homes where their parents barely have a high school diploma, or even one at all. They're below the poverty level, their parents don't care about their education, etc. I don't buy the principal's excuse at all. It's a bunch of BS. 

Afrina Watkins --- 16 years ago -

But the poll is in response to the Principals reasoning. He basically says, he wants children who are at risk to see what they can accomplish. That's what the poll is about. White children, hispanic, and maybe even asian kids can be at risk too. It shouldn't have been black only. 

Jingle Bell Rockin --- 16 years ago -

The color of your skin does not represent the struggles you will have. White, blacks, browns, reds all have struggles. Every struggling child in that school should of been allowed to go to show ALL of them THIS IS WHAT YOU CAN BE/DO! 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

He basically says, he wants children who are at risk to see what they can accomplish. There are other elements, like financial stability, that can determine which children are "at risk." Race isn't the only deciding factor. 

Afrina Watkins --- 16 years ago -

He could have included everyone and discussed how even though we have come so far in our society African-Americans (blacks whatever word doesn't offend someone) still face discrimination and challenges today. PHOOEY! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

See, that's where I was going. So many kids are "at risk". There are a lot of black families who are better off than white ones. I dont think his reasoning is sound. 

Afrina Watkins --- 16 years ago -

There are other elements, like financial stability, that can determine which children are "at risk." Race isn't the only deciding factor. Race isn't any deciding factor. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

PHOOEY! ? Please explain. I can't honestly say weather or not there are still challenges or not for any race, sex, religion, hair color, anything unless we are talking about white- Irish females. I feel like unless you can experience life in different skin, (or whatever) you can't say that there is no discrimination against them. 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

Race isn't any deciding factor. Unfortunately, it is. In Texas for example, there are plenty of studies using the standardized testing scores that show the average score of different races. They use this information, along with other information, to help determine who is at risk. I don't agree with it, but it's true. 

Afrina Watkins --- 16 years ago -

? Please explain. I can't honestly say weather or not there are still challenges or not for any race, sex, religion, hair color, anything unless we are talking about white- Irish females. I feel like unless you can experience life in different skin, (or whatever) you can't say that there is no discrimination against them. PHOOEY again. I live in this country and blacks are not being held down by "the man". Black, white, asian, indian etc. we all have the same opportunity to educate ourselves, work hard and make a life. Race isn't any deciding factor. Unfortunately, it is. In Texas for example, there are plenty of studies using the standardized testing scores that show the average score of different races. They use this information, along with other information, to help determine who is at risk. I don't agree with it, but it's true. ? I don't understand this as a response. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

But the poll is in response to the Principals reasoning. He basically says, he wants children who are at risk to see what they can accomplish. That's what the poll is about. Thoughts? I definitely understand his reasons. I don't think he was trying to 'segregate' or anything. Given that he's African American, he understands more than anyone else, and was trying to make sure they didn't slip through the cracks. Good for him. I don't think the field trip or academic group was a big deal. *shrugs* Especially if there was a comparable group available to everyone else. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

LUR, while I agree somewhat, I can't honestly say that I dont think there are some struggles for specific races still today. There are many racist people, whether they are white, black, mexican, etc- they still exist, kwim? I know there are TONS of people who love to see black people being stereotypical because in their mind it makes them feel more superior (I'm not saying this about YOU, I'm saying in general). Either way, there is no excuse for this field trip. And I'd like to add, if you're black, living in America in this day age and are still oppressed, it's because you want to be. There are MANY (including our OWN President) who didn't let the world get them down. They adapted and overcame. 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 16 years ago -

Some white children are "at risk" too. Poverty, the area in which you live, your home life, all play factors in that, not just being black or white. That principal should be fired. Anyone who was associated with the planning of that trip should be fired. They are teaching children how to be racist. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I don't think the field trip or academic group was a big deal. *shrugs Susie, would your opinion be the same if it was an all white field trip? 

Maureenie --- 16 years ago -

? I don't understand this as a response. You are saying that race isn't any deciding factor in looking at who is at risk. Race isn't any deciding factor. I am saying it is and providing you with an example. I don't think it should be used, but it is. I live in this country and blacks are not being held down by "the man". Black, white, asian, indian etc. we all have the same opportunity to educate ourselves, work hard and make a life. I don't think that the government or anyone is holding anyone back like that, and I do agree that everyone has an equal opportunity to be educated. However, I do not agree that there is no way that in today's world an action (whether holding someone back or pushing them forward) is not racially motivated. For example, I can get a minority scholarship to Prairie View University because I'm white and in that area of town, I am a minority. Racial motivation. If I was a racists (which I am not but they still exist) and the race I was against walked into my store that I own for a job and I don't want him to work there, there are many reasons I can come up with to not hirer him but it would all come down to race. You can not say that racism is completely gone in the world. It's not. 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 16 years ago -

I don't think the field trip or academic group was a big deal. What if it was your child who was left out of a field trip? 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

I don't think the field trip or academic group was a big deal. *shrugs Susie, would your opinion be the same if it was an all white field trip? It would depend on the reasoning behind it. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

What if it was your child who was left out of a field trip? It's not like he picked and chose who went. There was an all-black academic group that went on the field trip. I'd go so far as to say that some black children were 'excluded' too. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

It would depend on the reasoning behind it Right but would your opinion be the same if the field trip was for "all white" kids? Ex. Based on the principals own reasoning. Say there is a field trip to visit Microsoft and meet Bill Gates. Say the field trip is only for white students because they can still achieve the same as Bill Gates and be successful. Would you agree that it's okay to exclude black students, latino students, etc? 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 16 years ago -

It's not like he picked and chose who went. Yes he did, he chose that it was all black students. No one white could go. If you are white and your white child was excluded simply for being white, how would that make you feel? 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

There was an all-black academic group that went on the field trip This is true, too but we can also argue that having an "all black" academic group is just as bad as the field trip if there isn't a comparable group for another race 

*~LittleMissPerfect~* --- 16 years ago -

"All white academic group" would be seen as racist though. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground