A friend of mineis taking her son for shots today and people kept telling her to medicate him w/ tylenol. I shared my opinion and posted this http://children.webmd.com/vaccines/news/20091015/tylenol-may-weaken-infant-vaccines
I got a few snide comments for it but I agree with if its not broke, don't fix it.
I've never heard that Tylenol would weaken the vaccines, but it's been a long time since I had to research any of this. My babies are 10.
I agree with the "if it ain't broke" sentiment. I never pre-emptively medicated my kids because...well....something about putting meds in them when there was nothing wrong at the time didn't sit well with me.
I gave them Motrin if they displayed signs of pain or fever, but all in all I'm a "don't medicate unless truly necessary" sort of parent.
This exactly.
I don't give Tylenol or Motrin often because they can affect the liver but if I had to choose, I'd use Motrin.
I don't give Tylenol or Motrin often because they can affect the liver but if I had to choose, I'd use Motrin.
Motrin is a blood thinner and it can cause more damage than good. Tylenol is not a blood thinner. Keep that in mind.
It is your choice to use prior to shots. I recommend parents to wait until they see any signs of fever or anything of the sort which are a side effect at times for shots. Otherwise some parents feel like they need to do it as a preventive.
BTW... It will only affect the liver if it is abused on a daily basis. Which would be overdosing, or given more than two or three times the recommended amount for a 24 hour period. If you follow the recommendations the child will be fine.
We don't give Colin anything unless he really needs it. He usually only gets Tylenol when he's in obvious discomfort, or when he has a fever over 102.5.
I don't want him to become tolerant of medications, nor do I want to give him a head start of fukking up his liver.
Medication works really well for me, and I believe it's because I didn't take much as a child. I still don't, so I really like my theory. :D
Medication works really well for me, and I believe it's because I didn't take much as a child. I still don't, so I really like my theory. :D
It is a good one. Honestly!
Medications work really well also "If you take them as recommended and not per the persons (your) own recommendation" For example some people think that they don't have to take a medicine for the full length of time prescribed. Since on the second day they feel much better. KWIM?
No, they say not to now because it weakens the strength of the vaccine.
Not for that reason alone. It is being said because most parents over medicate! Keep in mind that the FDA regulations are more stringent in the US than in other countries. A lot does not apply to US that happens abroad. This is also referring to INFANTS..
What you are refering too is below. Keep in mind that this is in the CZECH Republic where vaccines are NOT the same as FDA / US Standards:
Oct. 15, 2009 - Acetaminophen, the active ingredient in Tylenol, weakens infants' immune responses to vaccines, a compelling new study suggests.
Infants often get a mild fever after getting vaccines. Some pediatricians routinely use acetaminophen to prevent vaccine-related fever.
But that's not a good idea, finds an international research team led by Roman Prymula, MD, of the University of Defense, Czech Republic.
Not for that reason. It is being said because most parents over medicate
I think she is referring to the news story that came out saying tylenol could alter the vaccine. That's probably why doctors are recommending giving it before the vaccine because if given after, it weakens the strength.
The story that came out was based on a study in the Czech Republic. Where as here in the states we have the FDA that takes such measures already for the public.
Also people need to remember this is regarding INFANTS.
I had done a bit of research after the giant infant tylenol recall and I stumbled across the vaccine/tylenol study, and a week or two later it was all over the news. I asked her dr. at her next apt NOT to give her any tylenol and she said "oh no, it's actually recommended that you only administer tylenol IF they develop a fever". She didn't say anything about the study, only to give on a need to basis.
She didn't say anything about the study, only to give on a need to basis
Ah, ok. I agree with her. I think that's the point Bty is trying to make, too. People overmedicate their children
I've never given them tylenol before or after shots. The nurse that administered the shot said to give tylenol only if they developed a fever so I never needed to.
she said "oh no, it's actually recommended that you only administer tylenol IF they develop a fever". She didn't say anything about the study, only to give on a need to basis.
Exactly.why I posted ....
I recommend parents to wait until they see any signs of fever or anything of the sort which are a side effect at times for shots.
Some will not tell you about the study...Maybe since some parents will read too much into it and not follow the advice of someone that knows more than google. KWIM? There are tons of parents that mean well; but others are just _ _ _.! You know?
No, they say not to now because it weakens the strength of the vaccine.
HiImKia I understand the above was your point.
But people seem to leave out this is for infants a study from another country not under FDA Regulations.
It is good that you do your research. But not everything that you need to know, for certain areas are available for viewing. Specially in google. Kwim?
Is the point I'm trying to make.
Yes, same page. Missed your point, too much sun this morning, I guess!
A has been lucky enough to have not had a fever yet, but I gave her motrin when her tooth was on the verge of poking through. There's been times when she's been really fussy and I flirted with the idea of giving her a dose. It's tough when they can't tell you what hurts. Medications make me nervous.
It's tough when they can't tell you what hurts. Medications make me nervous.
True but follow the guideliness and IF in doubt call your DRS office.
Yes. All five are still living and well.
You're so funny