Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

11 year old Murderer...Charge as adult or child ?

who's talking here?

ces1 1
Muse Heather 2
Kappy 1
The Original LM 2
Blue 1
Muse 7
Susie Homemaker 3
Boobsy McNiceass 1
real name 5
TaterFRIGGNsalad 3
FB-Fetus Builder/Facebook What 2
littleduck90 2
Krystal in NC 2
STUDRIFFIC !! 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

STUDRIFFIC !! --- 16 years ago -

http://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/02/10/pennsylvania.young.murder.defendant/index.html Fa real...What do you think ? 

STUDRIFFIC !! --- 16 years ago -

WOW !!! As I look into it...I find a TEN year old who murdered a girl in PA as well. Ok...How do you feel about 10 and 11 year olds being charged as adults? http://www.nytimes.com/1989/08/26/us/grieving-for-dead-girl-town-asks-should-boy-10-face-murder-charge.html?pagewanted=1 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

In the first story, they really didn't say why he's being charged, other than there was no sign of forced entry. I don't see any actual evidence that he did it. 

STUDRIFFIC !! --- 16 years ago -

Ok...Let's pretend they are both guilty and did just what it says. 

Blue --- 16 years ago -

How do you feel about 10 and 11 year olds being charged as adults? At that age they shouldn't be treated as adults. The juvi laws need to be revisited and revised to coincide with the mentality/age of the offender and the crime they have committed in order to render the appropriate punishment. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

Ok...Let's pretend they are both guilty and did just what it says. I think at that age, 10 and 11, that they can be rehabilitated. I don't think they should be tried as adults. 

Boobsy McNiceass --- 16 years ago -

I think it depends on each case. Some should be, some should not. 

ces1 --- 16 years ago -

That would a very hard decision. Personally if it were my kid, by the time I got done beating his butt, he would be better off in jail. Where does a kid that age get those ideas. 

The Original LM --- 16 years ago -

In this case, I say no. I think he should be tried as a juvenile and be released when he is 18 and no sooner. I also wonder why his father did not have the guns locked away. 

The Original LM --- 16 years ago -

The 2nd one is just wow... a lot more detailed. He knew exactly what he was doing. He even went as far as to hide the spent cartridge. This stuff is horrible! 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

The first story didn't mention anything that really proves it was him. The second story- He knew that he shot her (whether it was an accident or not) and he walked right past the room where she was dying and turned on a video game. That video game (if I'm not mistaken) is a hunting game. That poor kid has to live with this for the rest of his life. Could he be rehabilitated? I have no idea. Especially if the intent was to kill her. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

That second story was from 1989. I wonder what happened to him. 

Kappy --- 16 years ago -

I personally think they should be charged as adults. Placed in juvenile jail until they are 18. Once they are 18, they should be moved into an adult detention facility. The little brats THOUGHT about what they did. The first one who killed his father's pregnant fiance definitely needs to go to jail for a long time. And the second killed a 7 year old because of video games? Yep, off to jail they go I think. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Ah ok. The victims mom agreed to a misdemeanor but there were conditions. The parents couldn't have any guns in the house, the boy couldn't own a gun until he was 21. He did no time in jail 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

The little brats THOUGHT about what they did. The first one who killed his father's pregnant fiance definitely needs to go to jail for a long time. How do you figure? They have no solid evidence 

Krystal in NC --- 16 years ago -

It seems like he was trying to cover up what he did IF it really was him. Like he did it so no one could hear it. The blanket with a hole in it makes me think he knew exactly what he was doing. I think that he should be held in a juvenile facility until he is 18 and then moved somewhere else. Releasing him when he is 18 IF and I do say IF (in case y'all miss it) he did it is not enough IMO. 

Krystal in NC --- 16 years ago -

I personally think they should be charged as adults. Placed in juvenile jail until they are 18. Once they are 18, they should be moved into an adult detention facility. I think so too. Letting them go when they are 18 pretty much says it's ok to kill someone when you are that young. 

Susie Homemaker --- 16 years ago -

The first story didn't mention anything that really proves it was him. I thought that too. I wonder what made them point the finger at the kid. 

TaterFRIGGNsalad --- 16 years ago -

I think they need more evidence to convict him, but if they find the evidence they should send him to a juvie till he is 18 then off to "real jail". He needs to go to jail for a LONG time. Just because its a child doesnt mean its ok... kids are smart enough to know you don't shoot someone. If he did it, there is something mentally NOT right with him. He should be tried as a adult, he committed a adult crime. I just don't think he should be put in a adult jail till hes 18. 

real name --- 16 years ago -

The area in the brain that controls judgement and impuls control is not developed and working correctly at that age. No they shouldn't be tried as adults. 

real name --- 16 years ago -

I think they need more evidence to convict him, The question isn't about evidence or conviction. The question is about how he should be tried which comes before anything else. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

Again, if you're going to pretend to be me could you (at the very least) learn how to spell? Thanks 

STUDRIFFIC !! --- 16 years ago -

MN...huh ? Last post. I was asking due to the ages not the exact facts of case...My bad. I am really conflicted on this. There is NO WAY a 10 year old sees life the same as a 18 year old...IMO I also think...If a 10 year old is killing someone...There HAS TO be some mental defect...doesn't it?? Some MAJOR mental issues. On the other hand...Just sayin "Oh..He is just a boy" doesn't seem to cut it either ! Another thought is...Punishments are used not only as payment for a crime..But to also deter others from doing the same. I just can't picture a 10 year old planning to KILL someone and then hearing about this story and decided not to... I mean...If yer 10...and CAN actually KILL someone...Ummmmm...Yer young butt is CRAZY...and laws are NOT on yer mind. 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

I was asking due to the ages not the exact facts of case...My bad. LOL, the "real name" screen name had this screen name: ♫. so people were confused at first. 

STUDRIFFIC !! --- 16 years ago -

You are correct maam...I am now confused (Husband mode) I am sorry I was wrong It won't happen again I am stupid Please forgive me 

Muse --- 16 years ago -

am sorry I was wrong It won't happen again I am stupid Please forgive me HAHA!! A few weeks ago, a "troll" came on and was making duplicate screen names for some regulars. She made one to look like mine, took my profile picture and used it as her own and then said nasty and vile things- basically had people thinking it was me. She came back on today but after I asked her to change her name, she did. :) 

TaterFRIGGNsalad --- 16 years ago -

I also think...If a 10 year old is killing someone...There HAS TO be some mental defect...doesn't it?? Some MAJOR mental issues. On the other hand...Just sayin "Oh..He is just a boy" doesn't seem to cut it either ! Another thought is...Punishments are used not only as payment for a crime..But to also deter others from doing the same. I just can't picture a 10 year old planning to KILL someone and then hearing about this story and decided not to... I mean...If yer 10...and CAN actually KILL someone...Ummmmm...Yer young butt is CRAZY...and laws are NOT on yer mind. Agreed... Anyone who has the ability to actually kill someone like that, has some kind of mental issue. (Obviously except military, its their job) especially that young. That kid should really be sent to a psych ward, instead of jail. IMO, anyways. At least until age 18 and then have him re-assessed. 

TaterFRIGGNsalad --- 16 years ago -

HAHA!! A few weeks ago, a "troll" came on and was making duplicate screen names for some regulars. She made one to look like mine, took my profile picture and used it as her own and then said nasty and vile things- basically had people thinking it was me. She came back on today but after I asked her to change her name, she did. :) It did it to me too. 

real name --- 16 years ago -

Anyone who has the ability to actually kill someone like that, has some kind of mental issue. (Obviously except military, its their job) No you dint! lol to the third power! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground