Abstinence Education to Blame for Rise in Teen Pregnancy Rates
ARTICLE:
After a long period of decline, teen pregnancy rates are on the rise again and experts say that abstinence-only programs, the media and absent parents are to blame.
A Jan. 26 report from the New York-based Guttmacher Institute reveals that the pregnancy rate among 15- to 19-year-olds rose three percent in 2005-2006, the first increase in more than a decade. The nonpartisan think tank looked at its own data and that of the federal government to determine that more teens are getting pregnant now than since before the 1990s.
What's causing the jump? According to Guttmacher, it was the focus on abstinence-only programs that began in the early 2000s, which were prohibited by law from including contraception information. As a result, teens' use of contraceptives declined.
The report "should serve as a wake-up call to anyone who still believes that teenagers aren't sexually active or that abstinence-only programs curb the rate of teen pregnancy," said Cecile Richards, president of the Planned Parenthood Federation of America, in an email interview with ParentDish. "Over the course of a decade, federal and state governments have spent $1.5 billion on abstinence-only programs. It is a tragedy that we are witnessing an increase in the number of teens who are getting pregnant, especially when we know what works -- medically accurate, age-appropriate sex education that gives young people the tools to make responsible decisions about their health."
The best tool in a parent's arsenal, she adds, is communication. "Studies show that the best way to prevent teen pregnancy is to provide teens with honest, accurate information."
Tricia Goyer is an author and speaker who works with teen moms on a weekly basis, and she knows of what she speaks. She became pregnant with her eldest son, Cory, now 20, when she was a high-school senior. Goyer, author of "Life Interrupted: The Scoop on Being a Young Mom," says there are two other key factors in play when it comes to the increase in teen pregnancy: Absent parents and the media.
"Parents today live busy lives," she says. "They aren't taking the time to build close-knit relationships with their kids. Many, many young women are also growing up without fathers. I believe this leaves a hole in the hearts of teens. They are yearning for love that they don't have at home and look for it in each other."
Goyer points out that glamorizing teen pregnancy on TV and in the movies only serves to teach young women -- and men -- that engaging in sexual activity has very few real consequences.
"There are very few television shows or movies that show the reality," she says. " Most movies or television shows have teens sleeping together with no consequences. Not only that, pregnancy is just one issue. Even more teens are getting STDs (sexually-transmitted diseases). Even more than that have to deal with pain, rejection and an aching heart."
Both Richards and Goyer urge parents to recognize the few "teachable moments" that the media's portrayal of teen pregnancy can offer. Both women say that movies like Lifetime TV's recent airing of "The Pregnancy Pact," based on the 17 Gloucester High School girls who set out to get pregnant, give families the opportunity to bring teen sexuality out into the open.
Even before the Guttmacher report was issued this week, teen pregnancy appeared to be creeping its way back into the national consciousness: A Milwaukee public service campaign recently bombarded teens with teasers for what looks like a horror movie called "2028" but is really a one-minute PSA about life as a teen mom.
The short film has all the production values of a slick thriller flick, but ends with a far scarier take on reality: "Get pregnant as a teen and the next 18 years could be the hardest years of your life."
But Planned Parenthood's Richards knows first-hand just how hard it is to open the communication gateways between parent and teen, but she urges families to use opportunities like the Milwaukee PSA campaign to do so.
"Look, as a mom I know it's difficult to talk with your kids about sex," she says. "It would be wonderful if there was a magic bullet. I would first say to other parents to take every opportunity to talk about relationships and sexual health. I would say to teens, talk with your parents or another trusted adult. It's so important that anyone who is considering becoming sexually active, of any age, has all the information needed to make responsible decisions."
You mean all of those "Pregnancy Pact" and "Teen Mom" shows aren't helping either???
I'm surprised by that as well. I thought glamorizing stupidity would make it less popular.
That's all I was taught and I didn't get pregnant as a teen. I had enough common sense to know to use a condom or get on birth control.
I'm not so sure I'm convinced it's the abstinence-only teaching that is to blame; rather the glamorization of pregnancy ....
I had enough common sense to know to use a condom or get on birth control.
Unfortunately, a lot of teens don't.
That's all I was taught, too, and I didn't end up pregnant for the same reason.
At what age do you teach yours kids about preventative measures?
It appears that the need for this kind of talk is happening earlier and earlier.
I don't know b/c I haven't reached that point with my child....
I had enough common sense to know to use a condom or get on birth control.
But that means you knew about those methods. There are millions of kids who don't because of their parents. They need to be able to get that info somewhere. I do not condone the withholding of needed information in any situation, and if you have hit puberty, you need that information.
I have one child that I feel is approaching the right age but again, I am not too sure what that age is. I don't want to miss the mark. I would love to hear what other moms have to say.
There are millions of kids who don't because of their parents.
True. It is the parents responsiblity to educate their children about birth control, period. Some parents don't want the schools to talk about this in school but yet they won't take the time nor get over their embarassment of talking about sex to ensure their kids "know" how to take care of themselves.
I had enough common sense to know to use a condom or get on birth control.
But that means you knew about those methods.
Exactly. When kids are not hearing about ALL their options, they can't be expected to exercise them.
Should abstinence education be a part of sex education? Absolutely. But it should be part of a comprehensive bundle of information that also includes "what you need to know if you ARE having sex." Why is that so terrible?
I just find it hard to believe that millions of kids are unaware of these things with the information age we're living in.
I highly doubt the girls on "Teen Mom" didn't know what a condom was or what birth control was.
For the record, I agree that sex education should be all-encompassing. I just don't think these teens that are getting pregnant are as ignorant as many believe....
I am not too sure what that age is. I don't want to miss the mark. I would love to hear what other moms have to say.
I started talking to my kids when they were about 10. Just started out with the basic girl/guy attraction thing then progressed as they got older or asked questions.
I just find it hard to believe that millions of kids are unaware of these things with the information age we're living in.
I didn't see a condom or know how to use one until the day I lost my virginity. There are a sh*t ton of kids growing up just like I did.
But Heather, you're also proving my point. You were more than likely taught abstinence only and still managed to not get pregnant as a teen.
It just goes back to my original point that I don't think that abstinence-only "education" is the reasoning behind all these teen pregnancies...
I didn't see a condom or know how to use one until the day I lost my virginity. There are a sh*t ton of kids growing up just like I did.
Yup, yup. All I knew was that you could get pregnant if you had sex and my mom would kick my azz if I had sex. She claimed she would know I had sex. She never had that talk with me and sex ed in school basically just talked about reproduction. My friends? Well those that were having sex didn't use protection for the most part because they couldn't ask their parents for birth control, they were too embarassed to buy a condom or just didn't know. Their method of birth control was the pull out method and we all know that's not birth control.
You were more than likely taught abstinence only and still managed to not get pregnant as a teen.
Yeah, because I happened to not have sex until right before I turned 20, and I also happened to have a partner who wasn't raised the way I was. I didn't end up a statistic because I was lucky, not because I had common sense. I was an ignorant teen until I managed to leave my parents house.
Unless you live in a commune (think that's the word) or go to a church school, have no television internet or radio, and literally did nothing in society, I think you should know at least what a condom or BC is without having to be told. Maybe not how to use them, but it would be very difficult to know nothing but abstinence.
I agree that people need to be educated. I think middle school was a decent time. I also agree stressing abstinence the way it was done in my classes. As the only 100% effective was to prevent pregnancy and STDs.
I think those shows are b/s. I was like Heather and didn't even have sex until I was around 20 years old. I didn't even think about sex as a teenager.
I was more focused on other things like getting good grades in school and having a good life for myself than thinking about what guy I wanted to hump on.
I didn't even hang with the wrong crowds, I didn't cuss either. I went to church every Sunday and Wednesday. I guess things changed when I was on my own but I kind of wish they hadn't. It was my choice though.
I think teen mom shows kids why NOT to get knocked up..
We must be talking about two different shows.
Yeah, really.
I've seen two episodes, and they didn't make it look hard at all.
One girl's parents made her take her kid to the library with her, boo hoo.
I do think you can teach teens to wait, as well as educate them on birth control methods.