I wanna make a group too!!!
we can call it...
If you dont support the ppl who risk their lives daily you should be shipped over without a gun or a way to defend yourself......
just a thought..lol
lol, i'm already a member of that one. I don't take the groups too seriously, but the "Soldiers are not Heroes" club just seem like the angry trench coat kids I avoided in high school. Angry and bitter with the world.
Soldiers are not heroes. They can be heroes, they can act heroically, they can do heroic things - but the act of putting on a uniform and agreeing to put your conscience in a lockbox for the next so many years does not make your life more important than others, it does not make your opinions and insights more worthy of respect than others, it does not exempt you from moral judgement. It does not make you a hero.
Honestly I agree with the above statement I took from first link's website. I've seen some pretty shitty ppl in the military and would not support them/think they are a hero based soley on their service to our country.
see, I agree with some of what they say (the Soldiers are not Heroes group).
I also feel they have the right to say what they are saying, so no one should be able to tell them to 'shut up'.
But then again, I agree with those who disagree and want to sign a petition.
So wishy washy. lmao
Honestly I agree with the above statement I took from first link's website. I've seen some pretty shitty ppl in the military and would not support them/think they are a hero based soley on their service to our country.
that's exactly one of the parts I agree with also.
I DISAGREE with the signing the petition that members of the first group should be kicked off facebook (yea, like that would happen..) but read some of the posts on the wall. Just makes my skin crawl.. it seems that their issue is with America, not it's soldiers. If you hate america so much... move.
I will be honest and say that I didn't read any wall posts of either website. I only read the first part, posted by the creator.
I have a FB who is a member of the petition, and I just got curious and had to read what it was all about.
it seems that their issue is with America, not it's soldiers
Yes but not every one of our troops is deserving or respect and whatnot just b/c they are military. If a person is a douche they are a douche, military or not.
Soldiers are not heroes. They can be heroes, they can act heroically, they can do heroic things - but the act of putting on a uniform and agreeing to put your conscience in a lockbox for the next so many years does not make your life more important than others, it does not make your opinions and insights more worthy of respect than others, it does not exempt you from moral judgement. It does not make you a hero.
Honestly I agree with the above statement I took from first link's website. I've seen some pretty shitty ppl in the military and would not support them/think they are a hero based soley on their service to our country.
I was copying and pasting the same part, Mrs. H. Just like putting on a policeman's uniform or a fireman's uniform doesn't make you a good guy.
Yes but not every one of our troops is deserving or respect and whatnot just b/c they are military. If a person is a douche they are a douche, military or not
I get your point, but no matter if they are a douche or not, they are still defending this country and risking their lives for it at some point
kwim?
Soldiers are not heroes. They can be heroes, they can act heroically, they can do heroic things - but the act of putting on a uniform and agreeing to put your conscience in a lockbox for the next so many years does not make your life more important than others, it does not make your opinions and insights more worthy of respect than others, it does not exempt you from moral judgement. It does not make you a hero.
Wow...
Ya know it takes some serious grit to raise your right hand and swear to defend your country, be shipped off to have your head shaved and treated like a fly on a turd for 3 months, then come to realize that Uncle Sam can control every aspect of your life from your civilian attire to what you can drive.
My guess is that these are non-hacks and those that have less than honerable discharges. The uniform isnt worn, its EARNED!
they are still defending this country and risking their lives for it at some point
kwim?
I understand what you are saying but I feel (as many others do I'm sure) that the war in Iraq has NOTHING to do with defending our country. It's evident that a lot of ppl are upset about the wars we are involved in right now.
I get your point, but no matter if they are a douche or not, they are still defending this country and risking their lives for it at some point
kwim?
Or not, and putting the rest of their unit at risk to. Haven't you ever seen or heard of a slacker service member that did no good for his country? What about that guy who years ago threw a grenade or something into a tent, and killed some of his fellows? Was he a hero, since he wore the uniform and all?
What does "kwim" mean :(
I agree with Z. I think anyone can be a real doucher, but it's broad generalization irks me.
Hero is a relative term, I guess. A little boy can think a professional athlete is a hero, but we all know that not all professional athletes ARE "heros".
Wishy Washy.
I understand what you are saying but I feel (as many others do I'm sure) that the war in Iraq has NOTHING to do with defending our country. It's evident that a lot of ppl are upset about the wars we are involved in right now.
I don't think it has anything to do with this war though, it is just the fact that they enlisted for THIS country... whatever the country is involved with it is not their decision, they are just following orders...
idk
Or not, and putting the rest of their unit at risk to. Haven't you ever seen or heard of a slacker service member that did no good for his country? What about that guy who years ago threw a grenade or something into a tent, and killed some of his fellows? Was he a hero, since he wore the uniform and all?
I def do NOT think all military members are heros, but I also don't think it is fair that because there are those people who give the military a bad name, everyone in the military should be "punished" for it
i don't believe for one second that every person in the military joined for patriotic save-the-world reasons.
me either, not at all. But they still know what it entails, risking their life at some point, leaving their families for months, etc
everyone in the military should be "punished" for it
that website is only saying that just because someone puts on a uniform, does not make them a hero. I didn't read them bashing anyone, or lumping them all together saying none of them are heroes. Only that they all are NOT heroes, simply because they wear the uniform.
i do wonder at the contradiction between this statement THIS GROUP ISNT A SOLDIER HATRED GROUP, JUST A GROUP AGAINST THE HERO WORSHIP OF SOLDIERS and the slogans they suggest for making shirts.