So, there was a confrontation yesterday with my oldest daughter and some neighborhood kid, where he (12) decided it was ok to throw a soccer ball at my daughter's face (8). I was looking for his house yesterday, but he was gone when I went looking for them. Anyways, his big sister and several other kids (including him) just showed up to talk about it. That's fine; I was happy to talk to them. He says there were playing dodge ball when she got hit. Ok, that meshes with her story. But then he proceeds to tell me that she asked "Where'd that brown boy go?" and THAT'S why he got angry and threw the ball at her head. WHAT?! He said he was offended and felt like she was being racist. Again, WHAT?! Am I the only one thinking that what she said was harmless, especially considering she's only 8, and was only saying it to clarify which boy she meant? She calls my father chocolate PopPop, and she refers to my as peach. It's not a racial thing, it's a color thing. Just like she's tan. Am I even making sense?? Do I know have to teach her not to say the word 'brown' in mixed company?? I've already had to explain racism to her, because she had no friggin' clue what that was either.
Not to mention their difference in age... so where she might not understand, he was imagining it to be rude, because for his age, it is?!?! does that make sense?
Yup. And I pointed out to him that she's only 8, and his response was, I'm only 12, that's only 4 years. Are you kidding me?! I should've asked if he'd date an 8 yr old, I bet it would be a different story then! lol
His whole attitude pissed me. What a mouthy kid. I asked where he lived, adn him and his sister both said "Over there". I said over where, and they did it again. I asked for his house number, and he said he didn't know it. His sister said they just moved here. Whatever. I told him if it happened again, there would be trouble.
I think for her it was innocent. I think that there was just a difference in opinion and the kid took it too far.
I agree that for her it was an innocent mistake and that the kid took it to far. However, why couldn't she had said "he where did that boy with the red shirt go" or something like that? I don't think you should have let her think it was okay to address people by their skin color to begin with. I do understand that she didn't know what she was saying though. Hey, she could have said a lot worse!
even if what she said was racist, he took it too far. He threw the ball at her HEAD. He could have hurt her. I thought head shots were off limits in dodge ball? Sounds like he has some anger management issues, and needs to seek help for that. He's 12, he should know better, especially from a little girl who is only 8.
When my son was 5 (kindergarten) he was 'student of the week'. You know, that special award all kids have to get at one time or another? Well, we went to eat lunch with him. We are standing in line, and he gets white milk. I ask him if he doesn't like chocolate milk. He says "I'm white, so I drink white milk". Well, there was a man in front of us who wasn't white, and he about fell over laughing. He got it was from an innocent child.
I'm actually sad that that little boy thinks it's racist to acknowledge someone's skin color. She wasn't being derogatory, it's the same as referring to me as "that blonde girl." He obviously took it too far. Do you know his parents? Maybe they'd like to know how sensitive he is about his race.. :/ I would certainly like to know if my daughter threw something at anyone, but especailly at a younger child who referred to her as "that peach/white girl."
I think you should have a talk with the parents just to let them know whats going on.... and what happened... it could have been worse or could be worse next time someone says something like this to him...
I agree that for her it was an innocent mistake and that the kid took it to far. However, why couldn't she had said "he where did that boy with the red shirt go" or something like that? I don't think you should have let her think it was okay to address people by their skin color to begin with. I do understand that she didn't know what she was saying though. Hey, she could have said a lot worse!
I do agree with you. I've talked to her, and explained that while she meant it innocently, it could be taken offensively and not to do it anymore. I honestly never thought anything of it, it's what she's always done. And I made her go back outside, and apologize to him. Which he did NOT apologize for making her friggin' ear bleed. Yeah, when I went to get her, she was hiding behind a car crying. And honestly, what upsets me the most is that this kid went straight for violence. A 12 year old. It makes me wonder about the parents, and what kind of world my kids are being raised in.
DMC, she once told me while walking into her daycare Hey, look at the big chocolate teddy bear! That guy cracked up too. The next day, it was hey, look at the big fat teacher. That woman wasn't as amused.
Ummm I don't think I would really like it if somebody was like "Hey white girl".
See, and that wouldn't bother me. I'm white, it's my skin color. Now, if someone said Hey Cracker, I'd be somewhat offended. But I'd just as likely laugh, because really, who says that anymore.
sad that that little boy thinks it's racist to acknowledge someone's skin color.
Agreed, completely.
i agree, too. kids notice skin color as much as they notice hair color. when my son describes his friends at school to me, he uses shades. some kids are "white like grandma" and others are "brown like dad". it has nothing to do with race, he's just describing them. he tells me which kid has a mohawk, and which one has red hair, too.
I guess I'm the only one who thinks it's inappropriate to call somebody by their skin color when it's not necessary then.
No, I agree with you.
I was always taught skin color didn't matter, so there was no reason for me to call someone by their skin color.
I guess I'm the only one who thinks it's inappropriate to call somebody by their skin color when it's not necessary then.
no, it is unneccesary. The thing is, is that she's 8. MCD said she had a talk with her about what she said. Young children don't really understand those things. They don't know they do something wrong until someone tells them.
And for me, it wasn't so much what she said (because yes it was wrong), it was that he reacted with violence. Which is worse? An innocent word from a younger child, or an older child reacting violently?
I guess because color is a non-issue with us, I've never taught them to not mention it, KWIM? She says it just like she says the red-headed kid or the tall boy.
The thing is, is that she's 8. MCD said she had a talk with her about what she said. Young children don't really understand those things. They don't know they do something wrong until someone tells them.
Right. She also said that she lets her get away with calling her grandpa that so obviously she has taught her that it was okay...so far. Now granted I don't think she ever though how that might come back negatively someday.
Tell the little boy he better stop being sexist by referring to your daughter as "that girl." Oh yeah and he better start calling her "the young anglo saxon human." LOL Just kidding. And that's assuming your kid is even white. But seriously, I'm joking.
no, it is unneccesary. The thing is, is that she's 8. MCD said she had a talk with her about what she said. Young children don't really understand those things. They don't know they do something wrong until someone tells them
Right, and thank you. It was just one of those things I've never even thought to talk to her about.
No TM, you're right, you shouldn't call someone black or white when it's not necessary, I just think it's sad a 12 year old would take something like that, in a non derogatory context, so personally that he would assault a younger child.
My son is biracial and my husband is Dark Brown :). A little boy at my sons daycare in California licked him one day and said you don't taste like chocolate! I thought it was funny!
Right. She also said that she lets her get away with calling her grandpa that so obviously she has taught her that it was okay...so far. Now granted I don't think she ever though how that might come back negatively someday.
You're right. It was cute when referring to him, especially because he's white too. He's just tanner than us. I just never thought about it.
Do you think some black, brown, green or purple people with pink polka dots describe white people as white? Honestly someone describing me as white would not offend me because, hello, I am white.
A little boy at my sons daycare in California licked him one day and said you don't taste like chocolate!
Lol Too funny. I actually remember being in daycare at 4 years old and I got into a heated debate with a little boy. He told me, "You're white and I'm black." I said, "You are NOT black, you are BROWN!" As you can imagine, this went on and on until it was time to go to the playground, lol.