Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

What a crock of shyt....

who's talking here?

Q♠ 2
ces1 1
morgan 9
Hippie_Momma(Sharon) 2
Jules 7
Ella Mafayo 13
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 6
Kappy 2
SeriouslyInaneBabble 1
Blue 3
Muse 16
Susie Homemaker 27
ncnative 1
Quickstudy 20
Wesley James Moo Moo Cow 9
kelly 3
Get A Job 1
Donna ☠ 1
puppy luva 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Student's "constitutional rights" violated? SPARE ME!! Reader's Digest Condensed Version: A high school student recently won a lawsuit against his teacher because the teacher made 'disparaging' remarks about Creationism in the classroom. Rather than paying attention to the course material, the student sat and wrote down everything the teacher said that "offended" him and took the teacher to court. The meat of the judgment says that the STUDENT'S First Amendment Rights were violated because his religious sensibilities were 'offended.' (I hate that frigging word!) Way to teach this student about how the world works. "If you don't like what's being said in the classroom, sue them." What about in thecollege classroom, or in the boardroom when he gets a job, or in the aisle at the supermarket? You can't go around suing people all the time because you disagree with what they're saying!! Yes, teachers should be held to a higher standard because they are an authority figure. But this suit should not have been found in favor of the student. This should have been handled at the school level and left at that. The kid dropped the class because he disagreed with the teacher's ideas, and THAT'S where this should have ended...IMO. "Waaaahhh, my poor religion. Without me to stick up for it, people would say mean things about it every day!" 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

*chuckle* 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

You can't go around suing people all the time because you disagree with what they're saying!! Dear Lord I would be in court till I died. 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

I wonder what the teacher actually said. Creationism doesn't belong in a classroom. Maybe the teacher was just trying to change the subject so it didn't turn into a religious debate? 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

You can't go around suing people all the time because you disagree with what they're saying!! Dear Lord I would be in court till I died. LMAO, me too. 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

Sorry, I think the suit is justified. Teachers are TEACHING our kids. Neither evolution and creationism are proven facts. When teachers decide to teach evolution and criticize creationism they are infringing on a student, and their parents, rights of religon. I think when that area comes up BOTH should be taught with equal time and neither should be said IS what happened or ISN'T what happened. 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

Creationism doesn't belong in a classroom. Then neither does does evolution. Neither one is proven as fact or not :) 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

Creationism doesn't belong in a classroom. Then neither does does evolution. Neither one is proven as fact or not :) Evolution is a scientific theory. Creationism is faith based. 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 17 years ago -

What a douche. Then neither does does evolution. Neither one is proven as fact or not :) Yeah, what she said. 

MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage --- 17 years ago -

Evolution is a scientific theory Exactly, it's a theory. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

But the class wasn't ABOUT evolution / creationism. It was a HISTORY class, and an unrelated convo came up in the class about a teacher at the school who had sued the school system in 1993 because he/she was 'forced' to teach evolution when it went against his/her belief system. So it wasn't a TEACHING situation. It was a conversation where people are entitled, generally, to speak their piece. In that case, it's ok for a student to defend his / her beliefs and say "that teacher was justified," but it's NOT okay for someone to express an opposing viewpoint and say something against creationism? 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

Evolution is a scientific theory Exactly, it's a theory. :) 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

Evolution is a scientific theory Exactly, it's a theory. Last I checked, it wasn't taught as fact. If I wanted my kids to learn Creationism in school, I'd send them to a religious school. In that case, it's ok for a student to defend his / her beliefs and say "that teacher was justified," but it's NOT okay for someone to express an opposing viewpoint and say something against creationism? Exactly! The whole case was bs. 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

In that case, it's ok for a student to defend his / her beliefs and say "that teacher was justified," but it's NOT okay for someone to express an opposing viewpoint and say something against creationism? Not when it's a teacher. Teachers are there to TEACH. Teaching involves FACTS. Some teachers push their personal opinions and beliefs onto students as fact way too much. Don't get me wrong, I am VERY pro teacher and education. I am also fully aware of how SOME teachers abuse their power or are just too ignorant to know that they are abusing their position. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Exactly, it's a theory.  Yeah, but 'theory' is a scientific term for a set of ideas that has a BASIS in some sort of evidence. Most people think "theory" means "just some wild idea that someone pulled out of their chili-hole," when in reality, a scientific theory includes some form of tangible 'evidence.' Not "PROOF," but evidence that can be shared with another person. "Gravity" is a theory too, since no one can really PROVE how it works in a foolproof way. 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

Not when it's a teacher. Teachers are there to TEACH. Teaching involves FACTS. Some teachers push their personal opions and beliefs onto students as fact way too much. They were having a discussion. Like AYFKM said, it wasn't a teaching situation. The students, and teacher alike should have been able to express their opinions. The student who sued wrote down everything that offended him, rather than having a discussion with the class. Ridiculous! 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

Last I checked, it wasn't taught as fact. If I wanted my kids to learn Creationism in school, I'd send them to a religious school. As stated before, since evolution and creationism aren't fact, if one is taught then both should be taught. Why teach one and not the other? Is it because there would be an even bigger upheavel if a teacher said God? 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Not when it's a teacher. Teachers are there to TEACH. Teaching involves FACTS. I agree AND I disagree. Yes, teachers are supposed to dispense facts, but they are ALSO there to facilitate learning, and there's a difference. We don't just learn from teachers, we learn from EACH OTHER, and the fair and open exchange of ideas is SORELY needed in the classroom. School is not just for the passive absorption of knowledge. "I say this, you write it down, and voila, you've learned it." These students were having a discussion with the teacher about a lawsuit (see above) and the students were voicing their opinions about it. The teacher said that he believed Creationism to be "superstitious nonsense," but that's HIS OPINION. These high school students clearly understood that...all but ONE did, anyway. I remember having debates with teachers in school all the time. I didn't always like their opinions, but I LEARNED from those exchanges that EVERYONE is entitled to an opinion. 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

They were having a discussion. Like AYFKM said, it wasn't a teaching situation. Was it in a classroom? During school hours? Yes. Then it was a "teaching situation". The student who sued wrote down everything that offended him, rather than having a discussion with the class. Ridiculous! Because the student was already criticized for his beliefs. He did the right thing. "Gravity" is a theory too, since no one can really PROVE how it works in a foolproof way. Wow. Just wow. So how gravity works hasn't been proven? Where exactly did you go to school? 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

I remember having debates with teachers in school all the time. I didn't always like their opinions, but I LEARNED from those exchanges that EVERYONE is entitled to an opinion. Some of the best lessons I learned was when I thought I was right about something. That is what debates are for in school. I miss those times when teachers were free to say what they thought. 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

As stated before, since evolution and creationism aren't fact, if one is taught then both should be taught. Why teach one and not the other? Is it because there would be an even bigger upheavel if a teacher said God? Evolution is a scientific theory. Creationism is not. What are you going to use to teach Creationism in a science class? The Bible? Religious study does belong in public schools. If you want your children taught that, send them to a religious based school. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

if one is taught then both should be taught. Why teach one and not the other Because ONE is based on one particular religious belief that is not shared by everyone. Science is the systematic study of evidence (however scant one thinks that evidence may be). Because the Constitution forbids the establishment of a national religion, the schools cannot / should not teach Creationism because it would be espousing ONLY a Christian viewpoint. I can see it being taught in a religious studies class, where other religious beliefs are also taught, but it should not be put out there disguised as SCIENCE. 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

Because the student was already criticized for his beliefs Where did it say he was criticized for his beliefs? That would be like me saying if he liked soup and I said I like steak better. How is that criticizing what one says? 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

I remember having debates with teachers in school all the time. I didn't always like their opinions, but I LEARNED from those exchanges that EVERYONE is entitled to an opinion. Same here. Because the student was already criticized for his beliefs. He did the right thing. No, rather than joining in the discussion, he wrote down everything that offended him, and sued. Again, absolutely ridiculous. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Wow. Just wow. So how gravity works hasn't been proven? Where exactly did you go to school?  Everyone knows that we stick to the ground. I'm not talking about THAT. I'm talking about the fact that the EXACT mechanism that draws matter toward the earth's surface is not known. We don't know EXACTLY what's under the earth's crust because we can't GET THERE. We have THEORIES about it based on mathematical computation, but no one KNOWS FOR SURE. That's what I'm saying. 

Quickstudy --- 17 years ago -

I also want to throw out there, this kid didn't sue for money. All he asks is that his religon is not openly degraded by a teacher in a school where he and other Christians are entitled to that right. I admire this kid for having the follow through to do what he did, and I admire his parents for supporting him. Now if he sued for half a mil for mental turmoil, then my opinion may be different. 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

Because ONE is based on one particular religious belief that is not shared by everyone. Science is the systematic study of evidence (however scant one thinks that evidence may be). Because the Constitution forbids the establishment of a national religion, the schools cannot / should not teach Creationism because it would be espousing ONLY a Christian viewpoint. I can see it being taught in a religious studies class, where other religious beliefs are also taught, but it should not be put out there disguised as SCIENCE. Thank you! Exactly! 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Because the student was already criticized for his beliefs. He wasn't addressing ONE student in particular. It was a CLASS discussion about another teacher's lawsuit. This student was not singled out in any way, shape or form. Did you READ the article? 

Susie Homemaker --- 17 years ago -

No, he didn't ask for money. This is from the article: Instead, he plans to ask the court to prohibit Corbett from making similar comments in the future. Farnan's family would also like to see the school district offer teacher training and monitor Corbett's classroom for future violations, Monk said. He wants to censor the teacher so he won't get offended again. Please. His religion was not degraded. The teacher expressed an opinion on Creationism, he didn't say anything derogatory about Christians. 

morgan --- 17 years ago -

Everyone knows that we stick to the ground. I'm not talking about THAT. I'm talking about the fact that the EXACT mechanism that draws matter toward the earth's surface is not known. We don't know EXACTLY what's under the earth's crust because we can't GET THERE. We have THEORIES about it based on mathematical computation, but no one KNOWS FOR SURE. That's what I'm saying. When you type like that I tear up. *clapping sound* 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground