think it will pass?
link title
RICHMOND, Va. - Before you start up and light up with children in your car, think again. The commonwealth of Virginia is looking to hit you with a $100 fine, in yet another effort to make it illegal to smoke in the state.
Parents Beth and Larry Kethum think it's a great idea. "We're not smokers so that's easy for us," said Mr. Ketchum, a parent.
The Va. Senate bill's author says exposing children to smoking in a vehicle amounts to child abuse.
ABC 7 Talkback:
Click Here to Comment on this Story
"I'm not allowing anyone to smoke in my car...not just with my kids but with me," said Leah Tesf Amariam, a parent.
The debate over the proposal is smoldering in the state capitol, just a few short miles from America's largest tobacco company. Some consider the idea both innovative and controversial; even some smokers are split in their opinion on the plan.
"I think it would work...you know that way they will be concerned about it and think about it," said, Edwin Aguirre, a smoker.
Others, though, say lawmakers can't legislate common sense.
"[They] have so many other things they need to be watching for [that] needs to be enforced," said Larry Schultz, a smoker.
"I think it's probably like cell phone usage...i think that you're not going to get that many people that are going to get caught, but I mean it's nice that somebody is taking a stance against it," Mrs. Ketchum added.
The suggestion came from a third-grade boy: why not make it illegal to smoke in the car with a child? The question appealed to Sen. Ralph Northam, a Norfolk pediatric neurologist who was describing the democratic process to elementary school students.
On Tuesday, the Senate passed Northam's bill that would fine smokers $100 for lighting up with a minor present in the vehicle. Four other states have similar laws. Northam told senators that the amount of secondhand smoke from riding in the car with someone who is smoking for one hour is equal to puffing 10 cigarettes. Children who live with smokers often have problems with asthma, allergies and bronchitis, he noted.
"This is about the health of our children," Northam said.
Sen. Emmett Hanger, R-Augusta, said he has never supported a bill to restrict smoking for adults or in businesses, but he supported Northam's proposal because of the health hazard smoking poses for children. Those who opposed the bill said the government has no right telling parents how to raise their children.
"At some point, we're going to either reach the point where we're just turning raising our children over to government or following an instruction manual that's written in the code of Virginia, or we're going to let parents and families raise these kids," said Sen. Kenneth Cuccinelli, R-Fairfax.
Senate Majority Leader Richard L. Saslaw, D-Fairfax County (web | news) , countered that the General Assembly has made it illegal to physically abuse children, and "If this isn't child abuse, what is?"
Northam's bill passed 30-10. It now heads to the Republican-controlled House of Delegates, which watered down smoking restrictions in restaurants and bars on Monday.
It was passed in Sept back home, in Maine. I believe that it was more then a $100 fine though. The 'child' has to be over 16 in order for it to legal to smoke in the car.
And no, it's not because I smoke in my vehicle with my kid, but because I think people should have the right to do so if they want. It's not even close to child abuse but this is one more way for the government to tell us how to live our lives.
evidently, with VA being a common wealth, things are different here. I have yet to figure out how things are different, but that's what we've been told. I did google and find out KY is also a common wealth. lol
Regarding the argument 'you can't legislate common sense'....
It's not common sense that you're legislating...it is the safety of someone who is unable to speak up for themselves and those who have no choice in the situation. Therefore, you're not just randomly trying to take away someone's freedom...you're working to prevent exposure to a toxic substance in children who are otherwise FORCED to breathe it due to their parent's selfishness. To me, it's the same thing as the EPA telling corporations not to pollute the groundwater. Sure..THAT'S common sense, too, but it is in the best interests of people that don't have any say in the matter, but otherwise they'd have to drink the poisoned well-water.
Did you guys know that they're increasing the price of tobacco until April 1st? For instance mine went up like 15 cents last week and they can keep going up until April 1st.
dmc, so is Massachusetts.
I know there like 4 states, er common wealth. I could only remember KY because dh and I laughed about it.
Tell me, what makes a common wealth so very different then being a state?
And no, it's not because I smoke in my vehicle with my kid, but because I think people should have the right to do so if they want.
Yes, people do have the right to do what they want. Everyone has the right to smoke. BUT I do not believe you have the right to smoke inside a public place. Period. I have the right to not be around smoke. Adults can choose. The kids cannot.
As smoking laws change, there are less and less smokers, and more motivation to quit. Even in the last 10 years,things have changed about the attitude toward the "right" to smoke.
Tell me, what makes a common wealth so very different then being a state?
I know one thing is the way the govt is run.
BUT I do not believe you have the right to smoke inside a public place. Period. I have the right to not be around smoke. Adults can choose. The kids cannot.
As smoking laws change, there are less and less smokers, and more motivation to quit. Even in the last 10 years,things have changed about the attitude toward the "right" to smoke.
I wasnt talking about public places, I'm talking about MY truck, that I pay for. If I want to smoke in it, I should be able to do so.
I'm a pretty considerate smoker. I don't smoke in large crowds of people, and I move away from kids every time there are some around. Even though you have the right not to be exposed to smoke, I also have the right to smoke if I want to in a public place. There are tons of smoke free places for people who don't want to be around it. What about the people who do want to smoke? How many places can they do it in? Doesn't seem fair to me.
smokers already get screwed taxes are always going up and making the damn cigs cost more and more.....what next no smoking in your own home??....I thought this was the USA
Yeah, all the smokers I knew 10 years ago, I'd say 90 percent of them still smoke.
Wow. I know a LOT of ex-smokers. KUDOS to anyone who can successfully quit.
Of course, this is a very hot-button issue. Strong opinions on BOTH sides!
Pretty much, if someone smokes, there is a certain amount of denial/justification about the health impact of smoking. And if you are not acknowledging the impact of the smoke on yourself, then you cannot acknowledge the impact of smoke on the kiddos!
It doesn't make you a bad parent. It just makes you human!
And I really do mean a theoretical you and not a specific you. I am talking in general.
Peace and Love!
I saw and article about getting PAID to quit smoking...
I am SO glad I don't live in VA anymore...I think it's just some way to get money from us. we as a US citizen to smoke in our own home, and in our own vehicle with our children in their or not. I for one do not smoke in my house and neither does my hubs or anyone else.
I think this is about as stupid as a few years ago that if you are caught spitting on the sidewalk you can get a fine...
I dont smoke, but my husband did. I hated when he would smoke in the car with my son cause he said he had this venting system that worked needless to say I NEVER LET HIM have my son in his car again. He quit smoking, but from my point of view I thinks its a good thing. Im sure there are ppl out there who cant just quit smoking and its hard to kick the habbit.
The poor tabbacco company workers... where will they go when jobs get cut due to non smokers.... ???
It seems like people are getting their rights stripped from them left and right..
Oh yea i live in a state that has no smoking in restaurants and soon to be no smoking in the bars.
The poor tabbacco company workers... where will they go when jobs get cut due to non smokers.... ???
Southern Maryland, where I grew up, used to be nothing but tobacco-growing country. It was their major industry. In recent years, the tobacco farmers there have changed over to GRAPES, and are having a boom in vineyards and the tourism that goes along with them. The economy is actually better off now that they've picked a new industry!
I did google and find out KY is also a common wealth
yeppers :) I was going to say Ky is one too but you beat me to it, good thing I read ALL of your post LOL
As smoking laws change, there are less and less smokers, and more motivation to quit.
Really? It hasn't altered the minds of the people I know.
My husband says the same thing. He's always complaining that all of his Marines are smokers and they waste so much time standing outside to have a smoke when they should be doing their jobs.
bottom line, why the hello would you want to smoke while your child is in the car?!?!?
Because it's all about "them"? Nothing bad will ever happen to "them" or their kid. "They" think the 2nd hand dangers are all bogus. Nevermind their kid going to school smelling like an ashtray and all the people sitting around has to smell it. Next there'll be someone on here presenting the argument of "well when are they going to fine you for feeding your kid fast food".