Lejeune Underground
heart and soul of our Camp Lejeune and Jacksonville community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lejeune bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Camp Lejeune Housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Am I wrong or are illegal aliens not allowed to use our justice system?

who's talking here?

MorCayDen 2
ces1 3
♥ 1
Jules 7
Muse Heather 6
Ella Mafayo 2
MacSays_ShutUrCockGarage 10
silverlightstar 1
Nay-Nay 13
Mermaid 10
Kim 4
The Original LM 2
SeriouslyInaneBabble 8
~Bea~ 1
Blue 2
Muse 26
Erin Marie 1
Vicky 9
Pistol 20
marinebulldog03 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Illegals suing Americans? The guy catches them trespassing on his personal property and holds them at gunpoint while he notifies authorities. They're SUING him saying he violated their rights. WHAT RIGHTS?!?! If this makes it through the court system and these people win anything, I'm leaving this country. We've let other people go WAY too far abusing the system. 

Ella Mafayo --- 17 years ago -

Sorry...here's the full story... 

MorCayDen --- 17 years ago -

I'm with you! That's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. As an AMERICAN CITIZEN, he had the right to bear arms, and defend his property. 

Mermaid --- 17 years ago -

That is crappy. I applaud that man's efforts. Ridiculous that he is having to go to those lengths to protect his land, his cattle and his home. Gotta love the quote though "my dog is hungry, and he's hungry for buttocks". LOL 

Blue --- 17 years ago -

They're SUING him saying he violated their rights. WHAT RIGHTS?!?! Thank Lulac and the other organizations that support this. I personally think it's wrong, wrong, wrong. 

Pistol --- 17 years ago -

You're kidding right?! Tell me this isn't real. There are charges being brought up against HIM?! He has every right to defend his property and himself. These are illegal immigrants trespassing on HIS property! Wtf is wrong with America? 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

Everyone loves illegals as long as it benefits them (crops, manual labor, etc.) As a citizen, he does have the right to protect his land, but he doesn't have the right to hold people at gunpoint and assault them. We created this mess...now we have to deal with it. 

Jules --- 17 years ago -

If this makes it through the court system and these people win anything, I'm leaving this country. Do you need to borrow some luggage? You know they'll win something. 

Vicky --- 17 years ago -

I just read this story and it says that he installed a faucet on an 8,000 water tank so illegals would stop damaging the tank to get water. He has installed motion detectors on the trails etc... He definately has the right to protect his property!! First he tried to save his property (installing the faucet) now he's trying to protect it. They are suing his wife and son and the sherriff too. I hope he has a good lawyer because he is going up against an organization that is representing the 15. I can see how they are going to win the argument. --- These individuals were commiting no crime against this man... They were simply walking on his property.... He had the gun and the big scary dog and he held them prisoner... He kidnapped them and held them against thier will.... I can hear the lawyers now... When will we ever learn to take care of our own?? we don't do enough for the troops, we don't do enough for the children, the sick or the elderly. We are too busy wasting valuable time awarding 32 Million to 15 people who were caught sneaking into our country... Oops... better step off my soap box... 

MorCayDen --- 17 years ago -

Well, I would say citizen's arrest, but ummmmm....they're not citizens. 

Pistol --- 17 years ago -

As a citizen, he does have the right to protect his land, but he doesn't have the right to hold people at gunpoint and assault them. I thought, legally, he could kill them if he wanted to...? 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 17 years ago -

These individuals were commiting no crime against this man... They were simply walking on his property.... If posted, then they were breaking the law. It is called trespassing. 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

These individuals were commiting no crime against this man. But they did, they were trespassing, and he has the right to bare arms. I agree with FGJ, that he shouldn't have harassed them, but I would be pretty pissed too if I had to put up with the constant BS of people trespassing on my land, killing my cattle, destroying my property, stealing, etc. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 17 years ago -

I thought, legally, he could kill them if he wanted to...? I don't think so, not for simply trespassing. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

They don't have the right to be in America because they didn't go through the proper channels to become citizens. Maybe they'll use the money off this lawsuit to become citizens. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 17 years ago -

Maybe they'll use the money off this lawsuit to become citizens. Not likely. 

Vicky --- 17 years ago -

nay-nay and babble.... I agree with you. That is the argument the lawyers will use... (not equal force). If someone is trespassing you call authorities and let them catch the bad guy. they will say he used too much force and "kidnapped them". it's in the civil court system and not the criminal court system. The "proof" doesent have to be "beyond a reasonable doubt". It just has to sway slightly in the favor of the illegal immigrants... I say the case should be dismissed unless he laid hands (or feet) on someone who didn't strike first. Then is would be criminal court. But civil is a whole other matter... 

Pistol --- 17 years ago -

Detention is permitted where probable cause exists that one has committed a felony, breach of peace, physical injury to another person, or theft or destruction of property. So, he had a right to detain them...doesnt he also have the right to carry a firearm on his own property? The illegal immigrants saying he pointed it at them or assaulted them is heresay IMO. Even if he did, it was his property, they shouldnt have been there. They shouldnt even be in this country, much less trampling through his ranch 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

After reading the story, if he kicked one of them while holding them at gunpoint, that's wrong. Whether they're illegal or not. They're still humans. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

heresay IMO It's not hear-say. Hear say is when someone not involved in the case makes a comment. This is one of the people suing him alleging that he kicked her. I find it very probably that he did so given he has been fighting for 10 years. **Disclaimer, I have no idea how to spell hear say.. 

SeriouslyInaneBabble --- 17 years ago -

After reading the story, if he kicked one of them while holding them at gunpoint, that's wrong. Whether they're illegal or not. They're still humans Agreed. 

Muse --- 17 years ago -

Even if he did, it was his property, they shouldnt have been there. And if he had raped the woman, what then? It's still his property, right? He has NO right to commit a crime even if on his own property. 

Vicky --- 17 years ago -

Detention is permitted where probable cause exists that one has committed a felony, breach of peace, physical injury to another person, or theft or destruction of property. What probably cause did he have regarding this group of individuals? That they traveled a well known path? There was no felony, breach of peace, physical injury to antoher person or theft or destruction of property that he can prove. They walked onto his property, got water from a faucet he set up for them and littered at best... Just playing devil's advocate here. This is the story that the lawyers will use to win... If he was the only one who caused physical injury, then he will most likely lose. 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

He should countersue against them for damages. I mean how much money has he spent on sensors, and replacing cattle? 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

There was no felony Ummm....trespassing? I'm sure his property is marked, and I'm sure he has those "trespassers will be shot." And illegally entering this country is breaking the law. 

Vicky --- 17 years ago -

He should countersue against them for damages. I mean how much money has he spent on sensors, and replacing cattle? Sensors don't count, but cattle, water tanks and garbage removal yes. I don't think anyone has done anything to the sensors. (but now that they are aware they are out there...they will look for them and destroy them to be sure). Of course he would have to prove they killed the cattle and they damaged the water tank etc.... 

Mermaid --- 17 years ago -

They're the ones committing the crime. Not him. He held them while waiting on authorities. No different than any Target security guard holding you if you're suspected of theft until the cops get there. I would think terrorist laws could come into effect here somewhere. Who's to say these weren't possible terrorists (doubtful, I know... but still)? 

Nay-Nay --- 17 years ago -

I don't think anyone has done anything to the sensors. He wouldn't have had the need to get them if there hadn't been such an extreme amount of trespassers on his property. He said the cattle ate the water bottles that the "travelers" threw on the ground. 

Kim --- 17 years ago -

There was no felony, breach of peace, physical injury to antoher person or theft or destruction of property that he can prove. They walked onto his property, As far as he knows, they could have been the group that littered, or broke the fence, etc. They trespassed. ( I am assuming he has no trespassing signs) Also, if there was a kick, what was the scene? It's one guy against 11, yes he had a gun, but he was very outnumbered. It is very frustrating that the Courts even entertained this suit. 

Vicky --- 17 years ago -

Ummm....trespassing? I'm sure his property is marked, and I'm sure he has those "trespassers will be shot." Trespassing is a misdemeanor at best. If the signs aren't in English then there is room to fight. If they were not illuminated at night...yet another argument....He is an American. He doesn't stand a chance unless someone big backs him. We always seem to be supporting foriegn governments and peoples with no benefit to us. Like blind grandmother with her purse wide open and an unruly grandchild. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lejeune Underground