This was posted on an Autism support group board I frequent.
Florida teacher gets my vote to be fired
I have a son who is mainstreamed, and if there were ever any belief his presence were negative or a bother, I would seek an alternative...because no child deserves this humiliation.
Dagnabit, here's the link.
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/local/treasurecoast/sfl-flpkindergartner0525pnmay25,0,2574622.story
2 cookies to whoever can post it correctly. Thanks.
Wow. Port St. Lucie is very close to where I'm from. It's actually a very nice little town, but with this article and the one a week or two ago about that nasty disgusting house... I have to wonder what's going on there.
That teacher should be fired.
That makes me so sad. I can't believe a teacher would do that to a child. Especially a 5 year old. I would definetely at least suspend her if not fire her.
DISGUSTING. What's worse, is that it is not just the teacher who needs to be "voted out"...The state attorney's office "concluded the matter did not meet the criteria for emotional child abuse, so no criminal charges will be filed"
Didn't meed the criteria for emotional abuse? Subjecting a Kindergartener to the cruel scrutiny of his classmates isn't emotional abuse? Someone ought to stand these people up in front of the public who pays their salary and see just how emotionally unabusive it is to have people pile on the criticisms.
Wrong, wrong, wrong.
Call me a cynic, but I put very little stock in what that woman says about how her child was treated because there is no statement from the teacher, or any other students. It's a very one-sided story and therefore unreliable.
Didn't meed the criteria for emotional abuse? Subjecting a Kindergartener to the cruel scrutiny of his classmates isn't emotional abuse? Someone ought to stand these people up in front of the public who pays their salary and see just how emotionally unabusive it is to have people pile on the criticisms.
Wrong, wrong, wrong.
I agree. I would be p!ssed off royally and probably smack the crap out of that teacher if she did that to my son. She singled out that little boy and he will probably never forget that. Ha in 25 years he will have the " Who im going to kill list on his wall" His Kindergarten teacher will be #1.
in 25 years he will have the " Who im going to kill list on his wall" His Kindergarten teacher will be #1.
Just because he's autistic doesn't mean he is a sociopath.
Just because he's autistic doesn't mean he is a sociopath.
I didn't get that from what she said...but stuff like that is remembered. I mean, I remember the names of the kids who gave me grief in Kindergarten, and that was 30 years ago.
Just because he's autistic doesn't mean he is a sociopath.
I wasnt singling him out because hes autistic. I was saying that it will probably stay with him forever.
Kids with Asperger's aren't mentally 'deficient' or spacey, like you might think of kids with Autism. They have memory recall and are basically a normally functioning person aside from the inappropriate responses to social stimuli. So this isn't a case of 'maybe the kid is making it up,' I don't think, or that he remembered something incorrectly. Asperger's kids are completely capable of remembering a situation like this and of feeling hurt and saddened by it.
Just thought I'd clarify, for those who might be envisioning autistic kids like Rainman or something. He's not 'detached' or 'out there.' Asperger's is a very high-functioning form of autism.
I also wouldn't automatically relate autism with sociopathic behavior, but at the same time, it is entirely possible that this will stick with him and affect his future behavior.
So this isn't a case of 'maybe the kid is making it up,' I don't think, or that he remembered something incorrectly. Asperger's kids are completely capable of remembering a situation like this and of feeling hurt and saddened by it.
My son is a moderate-functioning Autistic (man, I hate labels), and his recall is incredible. I always know what has been said to him at school, or anywhere, really, because he'll repeat it (usually extremely out of context and days later, but you get the point). He doesn't lie. He doesn't know how.
I also wouldn't automatically relate autism with sociopathic behavior, but at the same time, it is entirely possible that this will stick with him and affect his future behavior.
This could stay with any child autism or not. Children understand humiliation. My son's father has Ultra sensitive Autism. Theres a really good chance my son could have it. Hes already showing signs of it. I would never "single" a child out. Im 100% a child advocate. I truly believe they have rights too. People just need to make them known for them. And in this case the mom is doing her duty as a mother.
Call me a cynic, but I put very little stock in what that woman says about how her child was treated because there is no statement from the teacher, or any other students. It's a very one-sided story and therefore unreliable.
except for the fact that the investigators and the principal both said the teacher confirmed the incident.
It sucks, but some people are just immature and ignorant, and this is how we find out. I hope she gets fired and the family files a civil suit against her!!
I'm in the very beginning stages of testing for Aspergers with my oldest daughter myself. This article brought tears to my eyes; all I can imagine is my daughters class being forced to do this to her. THANKFULLY, she has always had AWESOME teachers who have worked wonders with her. Well, except for the TA who's a$$ I threatened to kick, but that's a different story. But I know how truly HEARTBROKEN my daughter would be by this, and I'm seriously hurting for this little boy. That stupid b*tch of a teacher deserves so much more than I can even formulate right now. I'll let you know when I can think of something suitable.
At this point, I cannot think of a word that adequately describes my opinion of the teacher...
Also, if I was a parent of one of the other children, I would be upset as well. What kind of example is the teacher setting? I know I what I teach my children about how to treat others, and that was way out of line.
except for the fact that the investigators and the principal both said the teacher confirmed the incident.
I was referring to the story itself. It's very one-sided and badly written. So, I could never put much stock in it. One person's view of why an event (even a confirmed event) or how an event came about are, out of nature, colored by that person's perspective. This story is written from the mother's perspective and therefore is colored by her perspectives. A good news story is balanced and provides the reader with both sides of the story. I cannot back an inept writer.
Did anyone see this interview on the CBS Early Show this morning? I did, and I caught the tail end of her saying something about Al-Queda and the person interviewing her says "Ok now.." and moves on.. The lady seemed a bit spacey..
I feel horrible that a teacher, supposed role model would let and allow this to happen, it sickens me. From what the mom said the teacher (or nurse.. I forget...) even made his best friend turn on him..
WTF?? This is not freaking Survivor. Sheesh
Also, if I was a parent of one of the other children, I would be upset as well. What kind of example is the teacher setting? I know I what I teach my children about how to treat others, and that was way out of line.
That's a very good point that I haven't even considered. I know I try my damnest to teach my children to care for and respect EVERYBODY, regardless of color, religion, handicaps, etc. I would be horrified if my children were forced to do this, and would be seriously considering legal action myself. The stupid wench just undid 8 years of hard work I put into my kids.
I have a feeling that the teacher will be hiding behind the union rep and will not comment. I doubt we'll ever get her to comment on what happened; that's why it's so one-sided.
That said, I do know a teenager that has autism (I believe it's Asperger's, if I'm not mistaken.); that kid is probably one of the smartest I've met in a long time (He works hard on his social skills.).
What I'd recommend is that he'd be taught at home (where Mom knows best about what skills he needs to develop), have an instructor that's knowledgeable in autism (I doubt this could happen.) or take him to a school that is suitable for his needs.
awww thats the saddest thing ever :( MY 3 yr old is in the middle of testing for autism, they too think he has aspergers and this year will be his first year of school, :( makes me nervous. I have already been having problems trying to set up an IEP for him. ;/ poor kid, if I was the mom I would kick the teacher's butt...I couldn't hold back the rage I would feel...