I thought I'd start a friendly discussion/debate.
Do you think an addiction is a disease? Does that include being addicted to cigarettes or any other type of tobacco? Why or why not?
I think addiction is a choice.I have never been addicted to anything in my life.I have never let others influence me.I believe addiction happens to people with no will power and trying to fit in.
my opinion
i do believe that addiction can become kinda like a disease. Like the people who are having a hard time quitting isnt because they dont try.....but i am also a firm believer in you can do anything if you put your mind to it....when i was pregnant with my first i quit smoking one day..just never smoked again...although i smoke again now, and i always say i want to quit but im never motivated enough to actually do it. I dont believe i have a disease i just dont think i truely want to. does that make any sense?
in other words...i guess...i believe an addiction can take over a persons life. Thats why i havent visited back home (in pa) yet....everyone i knew became addicted to something and they changed so much...like this one lady who was my moms best friend who whole life...became addicted to pills and started stealing money and credit cards off her children....or my dad whos an alcoholic...hes with a woman he doesnt like...who is addicted to pills...and they are both raising my little 7 yr old sister....she had been taken away from them and they got her back and the rule was no alcohol (they beat each other up lol) but neither listen...to me..i would choose my child over alcohol or pills any day but they dont...and my dad used to be so family oriented yet my mom had to leave him because of the alcohol...and as sad as it is i know my sister would be better somewhere else....i do feel bad for people with addictions yet on the other hand i dont because they got themselves into it....but..yet...im undecided ;/ ok i think im done now lol
Almost every addiction out there in some way is considered a disease. Alcohol, drugs, gambling, sex, all these addictions
can be considered diseases to Drs, even food sometimes. So I always wonder why, when cigarette smoking is so popular and addicting, it hasn't been considered a disease like the others?
Alcohol,Drugs,smoking is a choice people make.
I agree, I believe they're not diseases. But I wonder how in the world did anyone ever start considering them diseases and why?
Most people start smoking to be cool and fit in with friends
I started smoking when I was going through a divorce. It was really stressful on me and I guess that was my outlet. As far as alcohol goes, I will post on this topic only once....Alcohol is an disease and has even been proven to be hereditary. But just like any hereditary disease, not every child is going to get it. I have grown up with alcoholics and around the AA program and the in house programs, I could debate with you for hours on this subject. But to me, I do believe and know, from personal experiences in life that alcohol is a disease. As far as drugs go, the same could be said. But I do not have as strong a opinion in this matter. I know that an alchoholics disease starts from the first drink they take. It is hardwired in their bodies that from that first drink, they cannot stop. If any of you ever really want to know anything about alchoholics, I greatly recommend reading the BIG BOOK from AA. I know you may not be an alchoholic, but if you are undecided or ever know anyone and cannot understand why they cannot just simply stop drinking then this book may help. Hvae a good time discussing this topic and try not to get too angry at one another.
we have tried sooo many times to get my dad to stop drinking....because he has got seriously injured because of drinking...and he gets mad at us for mentioning anything so we are just like eeeh..ok nevermind...we dont mention anything anymore...its pretty bad when all the cops know your dad by name because they have picked him up for public drunkeness lol
I do understand how it must be so hard to stop an addiction like alcohol.All im saying is that it is a choice to pick up that first drink especially knowing if your parents or someone you love is struggling with it.
i drink....dont get me wrong...before i had kids i was partying every weekend...my sister drank....she was drinking all time time actually....almost like she was addicted but just stopped one day....but i was lucky enough to not become addicted....i do drink to get drunk and have fun...but only once in a great while...last time i got to drink was in june and that was the first time in over a year...and dont get me wrong i never want to be like my father....but when i drank i was lucky enough to not become addicted :)
For anyone who knows more about alcoholism being an addiction, why isn't smoking a disease also? They do say that children who's parents smoke are more likely to smoke themselves, they say the same about drinking alcohol, or doing drugs?
oo i beileve smoking is an addiction, i smoke myself....and i also believe that kids are more likely to smoke if parents do, i believe its probably because they grow up seeing their parents do it everyday and think its okay. Like my parents smoked and when i got caught when i was younger my mom kept telling me how bad it was..but hell she did it so it made her look like a hypocrite...that is one reason i want to quit before my kids get too old. ;/
Katie,Im sure after watching your dad suffer with it,you made the decision to not go down that road
How does "hardwiring" happen?
First of all, I know I broke my rule.....I am sure Katie, not trying to speak for you, isn't in the smae boat, but if you look at my Dad, and my brother it is a prime example. My dad was an alchoholic to the epipahny of the word, my brother watched it all growing up and somehow, even knowing what it does to you, he cannot help but drink. He knows he is an alchoholic too, but for some reason, he cannot walk away from it and put it down. I on the other hand drink a glass of wine maybe once a month, if that.
As far as hardwired goes, what I meant byt hat is the genetics part, their genetics are predispostioned to need alchohol once it is in their system...
i have heard that, i remember being taught this same thing in health class....but in my experience it wasnt hardwired.....as for other people maybe, so i guess i cant say if it is or isnt because who really can ya know? and i know so many people who are addicted to many things and i must admit i do agree that they become addicted after trying ti while others do not, so maybe? maybe not? i dunno :)
I think like Erin says- some people are hardwired to have an addiction...
I have some alcoholics in my family- No matter what their drunkeness has cost them- they will still drink. Me on the other hand, could really care less if alcohol was banned country wide...
This is actually a good topic for once and there are a lot of arguments supporting both sides
For anyone who knows more about alcoholism being an addiction, why isn't smoking a disease also? They do say that children who's parents smoke are more likely to smoke themselves, they say the same about drinking alcohol, or doing drugs?
I fixed it to say what it was supposed to say.
I believe just like the other things I mentioned that smoking is an addiction.
i agree, if i run out of cigarettes i go through withdrawl just like anyone else lol im the meanest person around... so through my experience with smoking i agree with the addiction. A lot of people smoke and a lot of people go through the same thing, and it is hard to quit, sometimes people try saying its harder to quit smoking then it is to do heroine...i have no idea if its true because well i have never tried heroine and never intend to do so, too many of my family members and friends are addicted to it and i dont agree with it at all :)