Did y'all hear that the military is lowering the drinking age for the service men/women to 18? It's just for overseas and for special base functions such as the balls and mess nights. How long do you think that will last b4 someone screws it up for everyone?
Wow....that is about dumb. I am amazed that they could do such a thing. I understand overseas since the legal age is 18 over there, but for here on special occasions? Sounds a bit too risky and cause for some liability at some point.
i think it's sending out the message that underage drinking is okay...and that's really gonna cause some major trouble.
not that i beleive that any underage marine has put off drinking until 21, but if you are trying to hide it at least, hopefully, you are being safer about it. even if its just for fear of punishment.
The drinking age for over seas is up to that units commander it has been that way since I joined in 97. Here some of the commanders allow it but once the underage person messes up the commander is the one that says "I DIDN"T ALLOW THAT" and demotes their ass.
Ok, not trying to start something and I hope that nobody gets offended but that is not a military wide event. That is just the Marine Corp. We are not doing that. Gee, I cant wait until you guys have your ball and some 18 year old kid is told that he is allowed to drink then drives home. What a stupid and idiotic rule. I agree that it send the message that underage drinking is ok. I also heard that in Japan, they lowered the drinking age to coinside with Japanese law which is 20.
I have to admit that I always thought it was kinda stupid that an 18 yr old is old enough to die for their country, but not to drink. That'sjust me though.
I have to admit that I always thought it was kinda stupid that an 18 yr old is old enough to die for their country, but not to drink.
I totally agree..they are also allowed to vote for the president of our country..
I guess what I would need to know about this is in regards to the fact that the legal drinking age by law is 21, so how is it possible for the Marine Corps to change that for their Marines?
I know tons of people drink before they are 21, but I guess I am old fashioned that the age restricition is there for a reason just for responsibility and safety issues. Obviously it is not fail safe and many tragic incidents occur due to underage drinking, I would just hate to see a rise in such incidents with the Marine Corps due to a new rule they put in place.
As far as the issue of joining the military and going to war and dying in combat at 18 is ok and drinking at 18 at military functions is not...My thought is people joined the military by choice. It wasn't a draft that brought them into the position they are in. You can't be forced to join the military if you don't want to. If that was the case then I would be able to see my husband more than the 1 hour each day Monday-Friday and the 5-6 hours total, if even that much, I see him on the weekends due to him being a recruiter.
If the Marine Corps is able to legally allow 18 year olds to 20 year olds to drink then so be it.
As far as the issue of joining the military and going to war and dying in combat at 18 is ok and drinking at 18 at military functions is not...My thought is people joined the military by choice. It wasn't a draft that brought them into the position they are in. You can't be forced to join the military if you don't want to
I agree!
Your an adult at age 18 which gives your ALL the privileges that come along with being an adult EXCEPT that you can't drink. Drinking at age 21 is also a choice and can cause fatality.
Being 18 doesn't give you all the priviledges of being an adult, for instance you can not rent a car until what, 25? There are reasons for the age being 21. Yes, drinking at age 21 is a choice, but the point of me saying joining the military is a choice is the fact that just because you joined doesn't and shouldn't give you priviledges that are set otherwise.
I respect those in the services, but I don't feel that because of what they do they should be treated differently than others. Should police men, highway patrol, firefighters have the same apply to them because they die for their country, job, however you choose to look at it?
What about doctors who are out there saving lives, do they rate a younger drinking age over the rest of the U.S.?
Like I said, if the Marine Corps is capable to instill this rule LEGALLY then so be it, there wil almost certainly be negative effects from it though.
Right, I personally feel that ALL 18 year olds should have the privilege to drink, I think it is a stupid law that your can fight for your country, buy firearms... yet can't drink. Also, the article that I read on MarineTimes said that the Navy has been allowing their sailors to do this for a while now.
ACTUALLY, what they allow is the same as many other services which I do agree. If you are in foreign port and the laws of the location you are at are under 21, than you can drink as long as it is not on US property (ship, base etc.) For instance, when my husband was in Mexico, the legal age was under 21 and he would tell the guys that as long as they didnt get in trouble. But God forbid you get send back via local police or a call that your in jail. That makes total sense but in this country the legal age is 21 thats the law. Also, let me ask this. If I was the bartendar serving at the Ball that happens to be at a Marine function and it was at the Hilton, it is against the law for me, as the bartender, to serve the underage person. I dont care what General or Admiral says what. I could lose my job as well as the Hilton losing their license for serving underage individuals no matter what anyone says.
Okay, I am probably going to step on a LOT of toes with this comment, but this is how I see it. If these guys and girls are old enough to go and fight a war, give their lives at the age of 18. Then who are we to tell them you can't drink til your 21. I am sorry, if your going to be that STRICT about drinking bc your worried about the maturity level..then by God, please put a RESTRICTION on how old you are..OLDER than 18 for crying out loud, to join the military and risk going to some physcho country and have a road side bomb go off, or worse be kidnapped and nobody know if your alive or dead.
I am sorry, but that is how I see it..dont' say 18 is to young to drink if it isn't to young to go risk having yourself shot up. Once again, sorry if it is to blunt or offends but that is how I see it.
So what is being said is that when your 18, you are now a man or woman and dont need to abide by any laws because you can fight for your country? Ask any senior person in the military and they will agree that many 18 year olds are not mature enough to make smart decisions (some are but many arent). They (young people) feel that they are invincible. They feel that because they didnt die in a war that they can drink and drive because the country owes it to them because they joined the military? If you joined the military to get credit and say "I fight for my country and that gives me the right to drink" than its wrong. People should join the military not for the benefits but for what it means. That they can make a difference and dont need credit.